Book of Heroes

Mercs, power, and instability

With the patch we have changed to have Mercs count just as if they were guild members in raids. There are several problems I foresee with this, ending with boh community suffering.
1. Power ranking no longer will reflect the guild stability and effort of completing raids as a team. Power ranking just reflects how many raids you host. I've seen raids complete bronze with 5 members and the rest Mercs. This will now be no different than 40 guildies and 5 Mercs ?
2. By making power about hosting raids more than teamwork... Guilds are rewarded for HOSTING AS MANY RAIDS AS POSSIBLE. This is a big problem as it will create lots of bronze or fail raids imo since the reward for a completion is so big now. This will lead to over all inflation of bad guilds in power ranking and merc frustration.
The system was fine how it was. Not sure why we made a change. I can't see the benefit. Guild Power should be based on guild teamwork, not how many raids you can complete with the help of others.
-DumKnight epix

Ps- appreciate input.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorFri Jun 24, 2016 5:05 pm
Guilds have worked as just raid hosts for a long time now. I don't think things 'worked' before, as the guild model has been flawed since 1.6. I'm glad they are planning some kind of adjustment to guilds in the future.

Raids really worked well in 1.5. To merc a raid, you had to be in the guild. What's more you could unload loads of e into a lower raid then take yourself out, leaving the valour pool to those who needed it.
Soy Mitt0, primer líder de Hijos de Glenfort, actualmente oficial y consejero.

Desde nuestra fundación hemos adoptado una política de juego limpio, de ayuda a las demás guilds, como así de privilegiar el crecimiento colectivo y no el individual. Como también denunciamos  las injusticias que algunos pj's hacen, como cualquiera lo haría en la vida real, muchas veces somos advertidos, amonestados y amenazados por nuestra defensa a ultranza de lo que es correcto.

Podría decir que somos la mejor guild hispanohablante en ambos rankings, respetada por muchas guilds ya sean de habla hispana o de lengua extranjera.

Durante todo este tiempo, -más de dos años-, hemos reído, llorado, abrazado, amado, celebrado, alcanzando metas y objetivos. En nuestra guild, todos y cada uno de sus miembros son importantes.

Gracias a BoH, hemos conocido grandes amigos ya sea de Hijos de Glenfort o de las demás guilds,  amistad que nos une más allá de las fronteras físicas,  tecnológicas o virtuales. Lamentablemente muchos de estos amigos ya no juegan pero la amistad sigue fuera de BoH.

Podría seguir enumerando hasta la eternidad las virtudes de nuestra guild y de BoH. Obviamente sin desmerecer los méritos de las demás guilds.

Hemos visto como con el correr del tiempo, de los meses, que muchos pj's dejan de jugar, lamentando muy profundamente el no poder reír y disfrutar de este juego con ellos, y más alarmante aún vemos la poca o inexistente llegada de nuevos pj's, en crudas palabras hay más muertes que nacimientos en BoH.

Dejando sentimentalismos de lado y  poniéndome serio, somos un grupo de clientes de un juego, compradores y potenciales compradores de productos de BoH,  por lo que:

Creemos que el actual sistema de eliminación de la bonificación de mercs en raids es perjudicial tanto para nosotros como para el futuro de BoH.

1.- Uno de los pilares de la filosofía de este juego está en la lealtad a la guild, sistema que a muchas guild les ha hecho crecer, dando una bonificación extra si las raids se efectúan sin mercs. Con el nuevo sistema, las raids las harán mercs y casi sin esfuerzo de los integrantes de la guild.

2.- El ranking es solo un reflejo del momento, realmente no lo hemos buscado,  hacemos raids sin mercs,  no por despreciar a las demás guilds, sino que por evitar pj's que hacen poco rpps. No existe una herramienta para sacar de las raids a pj's que no ayudan al éxito de la raids.

3.- De esta forma se quiere encubrir la poca  cantidad de pjs activos. Hace falta un verdadero esfuerzo de publicidad en las tiendas de aplicaciones, un CEO eficaz. Hace faltan pj's nuevos, sabia nueva.

4.- BoH nos pertenece, somos nosotros, los jugadores quienes hacen que este juego sea único en este tipo, ciertamente.  Aunque Venan sea el propietario legal. Y merecemos ser escuchados y tomados en cuenta, ya que solo perseguimos que este juego continúe por mucho tiempo más.

5.- Obviamente, nos reservamos el derecho de abandonar masivamente este juego.
** Translation for Spanish post. I'm sorry for my english


I am Mitt0, first leader of Hijos de Glenfort, currently an officer and assessor.

Since our founding we have adopted a policy of fair play, of helping other guilds, as well privileging collective growth and not the individual. As we also denounce the injustices that some pj's do, as anyone would in real life, we are often warned, reprimanded and threatened by our uncompromising defense of what is right.

You could say that we are speaking the best guild in both rankings, respected by many guilds whether Spanish-speaking or foreign language.

During all this time, -more than two years-, we have laughed, he cried, hugged, loved, held, reaching goals and objectives. In our guild, each and every one of its members are important.

Thanks BOH, we have met great friends either Hijos de Glenfort or other guilds, friendship that unites us beyond the physical, technological or virtual borders. Unfortunately many of these friends no longer play but friendship is still out Boh.

I could go into eternity the virtues of our guild and Boh. Obviously without detracting from the merits of other guilds.

We have seen how with the passing of time, months, many pj's stop playing, regretting deeply not being able to laugh and enjoy this game with them, and even more alarming see little or no arrival of new pj's at crude words there are more deaths than births in BoH.

Leaving aside sentimentality and putting seriously, we are a group of clients of a game, buyers and potential buyers of Boh so:

We believe that the current system of elimination of bonus mercs in raids is harmful both for us and for the future Boh.

1. One of the pillars of the philosophy of this game is loyalty to the guild, many guild system that has made them grow, giving an extra bonus if the raids are carried out without mercs. With the new system, the raids will mercs and almost without effort of the members of the guild.

2. The ranking is only a reflection of the moment, I really have not looked, we do raids without mercs, not despise other guilds, but avoid doing little pj's RPPS. There is no tool to remove the raids to pj's that do not help the success of the raids.

3. This is to cover up the small amount of active pjs. a real effort advertising in app stores need a CEO effective. They are missing ago pj's new, wise new.

4. BoH belongs to us, we, the players who make this game unique in its kind, certainly. Although Venan is the legal owner. And we deserve to be heard and taken into account as we pursue only this game to continue for much longer.

5. Obviously, we reserve the right to massively leave this game.
Illy_the_Red wrote:Guilds have worked as just raid hosts for a long time now. I don't think things 'worked' before, as the guild model has been flawed since 1.6. I'm glad they are planning some kind of adjustment to guilds in the future.

Raids really worked well in 1.5. To merc a raid, you had to be in the guild. What's more you could unload loads of e into a lower raid then take yourself out, leaving the valour pool to those who needed it.

This may be your experience but it is not mine. You constantly write on this point, so you must care deeply about it. However, for me, this game would not be what it s without the guild motive that Dumknight lays out above. In my view Lord Venan would seriously weaken the unique character of BOH were he (or she) to remove this incentive to cooperate as a team and a stable one at that.

As anyone can form a guild, the 1.5 system is no system whatsoever. Currently we have no system whatsoever either. The pre-update rule should be reinstated pending a lasting structure. Many of us strongly hope that that outcome will not be a return to 1.5.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorSun Jun 26, 2016 5:13 am
Lamorack wrote:
Illy_the_Red wrote:Guilds have worked as just raid hosts for a long time now. I don't think things 'worked' before, as the guild model has been flawed since 1.6. I'm glad they are planning some kind of adjustment to guilds in the future.

Raids really worked well in 1.5. To merc a raid, you had to be in the guild. What's more you could unload loads of e into a lower raid then take yourself out, leaving the valour pool to those who needed it.

This may be your experience but it is not mine. You constantly write on this point, so you must care deeply about it. However, for me, this game would not be what it s without the guild motive that Dumknight lays out above. In my view Lord Venan would seriously weaken the unique character of BOH were he (or she) to remove this incentive to cooperate as a team and a stable one at that.

As anyone can form a guild, the 1.5 system is no system whatsoever. Currently we have no system whatsoever either. The pre-update rule should be reinstated pending a lasting structure. Many of us strongly hope that that outcome will not be a return to 1.5.

'Constantly'? A few posts...but yes it is an important issue.

The 1.5 system and the way guilds worked in it was fantastic. There are a LOT of people that think that. Guild Loyalty and how mercs worked in it was deeply unpopular, based on observations in chat and on the forums. The main positive of the GL system was that we got bonus energy out of it. Unfortunately however it locked everyone in their guilds. It was because of this that the Loyalty penalty for moving guilds was dropped to half of what it was. Even speedruns were made much harder than they should've been by that system.

In 1.5 it was simple. Your guild began a raid and everyone hit. You could then open your guild and allow mercs in based on how things were going. There was no loyalty penalty for moving around, so you could help people out and (more importantly) go and talk to people. People loved this aspect of the game and it was not popular when it was changed. For speedruns, it was about getting everyone together at the same time, and nothing more.

The problem with the way things currently work is that many of the top raids have very high wave counts. Most guilds use mercs these days at the top end, because player activity is pretty low (not sure what the latest update has done to activity). This change seems to be an acknowledgement of this and a preparation for something different.

Any guild that decides to throw open a higher raid then it knows it can do will quickly fail those raids, even if they have full merc support. The wave count on the raids won't support that kind of raiding. Lower raids might well be possible for more guilds now, which isn't a bad thing to me.

DoyleDD

ModeratorSun Jun 26, 2016 6:51 am
I am thrilled with this change that Venan has made please don't change it. There are some points I would like to make:

1) Since this change affects all guilds the playing field for guild power remains consistent
2) Raid frequency and speed are now a key to retaining or building your guild power. This also reflects guild participation.
3) This allows people to move from guild to guild let's say when a raid is in trouble and you want to help. I've wanted to help another guild who's raids were struggling but there were no merc spots left. Or how about just visiting Boh friends for a special occasion like a speed run or their guild anniversary raid etc.
4) With everyone building new toons and new players to the game, They may have to move from guild to guild to help them grow so they can finally go home to their end game guild. Why penalize players for growing their toons? I know of not one guild who can take a baby toon amd have them grow to their full potential in one guild.

One of the best things about this game is the Community of players. Allow them to grow, move or just visit another guild.
Doyle, no disrespect but I would expect you to be thrilled just on the basis of methodology employed in guild. However, for those of us who value community in BOH, that's exactly the effect we are finally speaking up to oppose.

You have been pretty successful under the old system. There was no need to eviscerate it.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorSun Jun 26, 2016 1:49 pm
De_Gallis wrote:Doyle, no disrespect but I would expect you to be thrilled just on the basis of methodology employed in guild. However, for those of us who value community in BOH, that's exactly the effect we are finally speaking up to oppose.

You have been pretty successful under the old system. There was no need to eviscerate it.

Don't diss people without explaining exactly what you mean. Don't tiptoe around what you want to say.

Community in BoH has nothing to do with mercs. The old system is and will continue to be poor, because at the moment the guild concept is dying. I think Venan recognise this and are throwing the game a hand. I'm yet to see a coherent explanation of why exactly this is bad. I'm guessing it will allow some other guild to pass the guilds of those posting above to get above you on the boards. Most people don't care about any guild board, and if the current situation is affecting your board placing then adapt.
My biggest problem with the change... Is that the more raids you run, regardless of guild member contribution the higher ur power will be. Realistically I should split my guildies into two raids and then have 15 Mercs helping in each. That would maximize our ranking.

That is a flawed thing to promote. It will lead to guilds running as many raids as possible for ranking and hoping for Mercs.

To make my point simply.... I'm the GM of a captains valor guild. Should guilds that constantly run KFS as much as possible with 90% merc contribution gain the same amount of power as our guild that runs a closed Vg with no Mercs ? Is that realistically reflecting the "power" and teamwork of a guild ? I don't think so. My 2 cents. It might be different for GV raids, but for mid tier cv and Kv this seems like it's gonna end up with a lot of people starting raids and praying they finish with Mercs. Which will lead to a bad gaming experience for a lot of players and instability.

DumKnight epix