Subject
Venting, valor, raid length and Niko part 2 of 3
Part 1 of 3
For how I feel about using character level for setting monster level:
Level & Might suck for predicting Seasonal combat(R=Exp+)
This is especially true with XP gains from PvP, Incursion Portals, and shortened quest lines, especially Hellmarsh, I mean Fellmarsh, that take less energy but still pay out same XP.
The problem for Devs is Level is the only stat that cannot be gamed except for Hero Score and Monster Kills.
Part 2 of 3
I have not raided every day since getting the last piece of Tier 16 gear as a member of Warriors of the SPOON! I have not enjoyed raiding since Guild Favors were nerfed and War of Fellmarsh stopped being the highest raid.
Niko quit at least once over raid energy totals (Note 1).
Deathwing Raiders died over raid energy totals.
CJ and I have rage quit multiple times over raid energy totals.
Raid caps didn't work because most players want to run the same exact raid for each valor tier.
Ex: Deathwing Raiders favored Lockbolt (for squire valor and bandits), Zuur (for quick soldier valor raid, later with mountain lichen), and Vallus (soft Raid Boss later with polar melt). Later our preference switched to from Zuur to Crypt (soldier valor, silver, runes, healing potions), and Vallus to Cursed Keep (pirates in Phase 1, before pirate raids, and Ice Mages loved the other phases).
We did not like running Skar or Overseer for squire, Kraken or Helion for soldier, The Shadow Comes (especially Justicars lacking Backswing at the time), Forgotten Sentinels (except for the Bog Queen), War of Fellmarsh (except old school mercing in a Guild with all v1.0 Favors unlocked, Hail Haste +10%!). In fact, many guilds initially had trouble getting members to run multiple Helion and could not unlock Cursed Keep [CJ also rage quit over "One and Done" unlocking Raids, but that is another post).
Quick Raids, that still allow burning, would let people run the raids they like, and the raids they don't, without being bogged down in enough characters or enough Gold Shields.
The longer the phase, the more difficult Onslaught is to balance as previously seen with War Mages with combustion, Shadow Walker's Vanish, Justicars before Backswing, first version of War Mage Deep Freeze, Shekka's Justicar 2h Axe rotation, and Shadow Walkers with heavy Defense enchants and Death Wish rank 3. The more number of combats/ waves/ CELDC per Onslaught Phase, the more an imbalance causes the other classes, or builds, to just not run that phase.
Quick Raids, that still allow burning, would let people run the raids they like, and the raids they don't, without being bogged down which class to run Onslaught or skip Onslaught.
Incursion Portals v1.0 had varying lengths (1, 2, & 3) hours, dropped random flux and were not popular. They were replaced with 1 hour portals, that have a tendency to drop one color flux over another. For players using Gold Shields, they still have an an unlimited number of combats/ waves/ Combat Encounter Loot Drop Checks in the max incursion portal level. A good balance between casual and hard core portal farming.
Quick Raids, that still allow burning, would let people run the raids they like, and the raids they don't, without being bogged down in setting alarms to come back after energy regen, or to check the credit card for how much money is left for buying energy.
Quick Fix Ideas
Pirate raids all have the same valor (doubloons) making them popular with all level of players from Level 10 to 40. Even a failed Pirate raid pays some valor (doubloons) making them popular with jumping in for a two hits or burning a wagon of Gold Shields. There is only one pirate raid so players are not spread thinly among a huge number of raids.
Streamline valor, pay out if raid not finished, end raid quickly, but have enough combat/ wave/ CELDC for high level players.
All raids would only have a Gold Finish Timer, but all raids pay out when the timer expires (similar to pirate raids). Since the valor and hero tokens are prorated, the faster you finish, the better the rewards. Players get the speed of a Gold Finish (the only timer) but if you only finish Phase 1 you get much less valor than if you finish all phases. Payout for a finished raid would be based on Gold Finish pay out.
Remove every other tier of valor, but adjust the payout. Ex: a Soldier Valor raid would become a squire valor raid with x20 its current payout per combat/ wave/ CELDC. Instead of making players upconvert a huge load of valor, just adjust the prices in the shop. Ex: soldier valor gear would cost x20 it's current price but in squire valor. This would allow characters needing Tier 12 gear (old soldier valor) to raid lower level raids for their gear. Yes, this means Crypt would pay out x20 its current but in squire valor.
Then scale the rewards an difficulty on a smoother curve. Instead of 4 squire and 4 soldier raids with a jump in difficulty from squire to soldier, you have 8 raids to gradually ramp up the difficulty.
Finally sell gear back for Gold Shields equal to 80% of the purchase price if bought with Gold Shields. Sell back gems for Gold Shields equal to 90% if purchased with Gold Shields. This preserves a characters energy spent in lower level raids so they don't have to start from scratch at the next higher level raid. If the energy, and more importantly *TIME* a player has spent in lower level raids is preserved when they switch to higher level raids, there is more incentive to run a lower level raid with your guild instead of mercing higher valor raids with *other* guilds and spending your time, energy and Gold Shields in the other guilds. With the upconvert rate of 1/20th between valors, it quickly causes fights in guild over which raids to run, with members just not showing up for the raids they can't run, or the raids far below their current combat effectiveness.
Ex: Tier 3 Gems bought with Gold shield would sell back for 90% purchase price in Gold Shields, and Tier 3 Gems bought with valor, or marks, would sell back for the same number of Gold Shields.
If this is ever implemented, Black Market would no longer sell items for Gold Shields, there would be a new Black Market currency that could be purchased with Gold Shields making the Black Market similar to a seasonal event shop. This would preserve the premium mark up on Black Market items (see also Glory currency below). Or PvP weekly Medals could be bought in the Black Market and prices for Black Market items would be in PvP weekly Medals, but that might cause rioting.
Nuking Valor
Instead of the idea of buying gear for valor, or marks, and selling back gear, and gems, for Gold Shields above, eliminate valor and marks. All gear is bought with Gold Shields and sold back for Gold Shields (80% for gear, 90% for gems). Change Gold Shields from an integer value to a decimal. Raids, and PvP, would now pay off in Gold Shields (or more likely parts of 1 Gold Shield).
Just like pirate raids are popular because they pay out one valor that is valuable to all players (seasonal currency of doubloons), nuking valor would let *all* raids pay out hero tokens and Gold Shields. Ex: GG might have a Raid Pool of 9.7 Gold Shields and 97.65 Hero Tokens while Vallus might have a Raid Pool of 377 Gold Shields and 3770.55 Hero Tokens.
Raids would become a way to convert energy into Gold Shields, get monster kills for feats, and get material drops. Blue bags and new guild challenges, would be another way to encourage raiding. Perhaps weekly quests that require X encounters in Y raid.
Without the artificial wall of valor tiers, some raids could be eliminated and a smoother raid reward pool curve could be implemented similar to the current curve for Hero Token raid reward pools. Hero Tokens are a great example of this, if I help a guild finish a GG that is in trouble, I am only going to spend the Hero Tokens and the Hero Tokens paid in GG are worth a lot more to a max Level character than the squire valor.
To prevent players from just buying all max tier gear, each tier of gear would be unlocked by running a raid quest chain.
Example:
Quest for completing W encounters in GG,
unlocks quest for X encounters in Skar & Tier 6 raid gear which,
unlocks quest for Y encounters in Lockbolt which,
unlocks quest for Z encounters in Overseer which,
unlocks quest for A encounters in Kraken & Tier 10 raid gear,
etc.
You would only have to run each raid until the quest was done, then you can run the raids you *want* to run, instead of the raids your *have* to run since gear and gems are bought with the same raid currency.
The Doubloon solution
Nuking Valor has the problem of seriously affecting buying energy for Gold Shields for raids below Vile Realm or buying resolve potions for PvP. Instead of all gear and gems being bought for Gold Shields and selling back for Gold Shields (which can buy energy), they would be bought for Glory currency and sell back for Glory (80% Glory for gear and 90% Glory for gems). 1 Glory would have the same buying power as 1 Gold Shield currently has, but cannot be used to buy energy, resolve, seasonal currency, Hero Tokens, any other type of future energy, any other type of future currency.
Ex: 1 Gold Shield could buy 1 Glory which could then be used to buy a Tier 3 Gem and selling back the Tier 3 Gem would return 90% of the Glory.
This makes raid rewards a type of currency between Hero Tokens, which cannot be lost but can be misspent, and Enchant materials, which are lost transferring between gear and can also be misspent.
Either Nuking Valor (Gold Shields) or The Doubloon solution (Glory currency) makes raids closer to the doubloons and hero token pools for pirate raids. This allows Level 10 to 40 characters to raid together. It would also allow the elimination of some raids, concentration the pool of potential raiders instead of spreading them thinly among a larger number of raids.
Crowdsourcing
Niko left, and many of the other math people did with him or before him. But if there are enough left, start a crowd sourcing project and let them crunch the numbers. Slowly ramp up the new system. First replace GG, then Skar then Lockbolt then Overseer, etc. If public raids now pay out even if not finished, testing the changes in public raids using weekly quests would be feasible. Ex: Complete X encounters in a public GG, Skar, Lockbolt to get a reward.
Note 1)
Did VenN get it right this time?
https://www.venan.com/boh_forum/search.php?st=0&sk=t&sd=d&sr=posts&author_id=1852