Book of Heroes

Enemy scaling and leveling up

So Venan has addressed this before and I think many of us can agree it wasn't enough. SQ and TSR get harder and harder to raid as you increase from level 35 to 40. Personally I've gone from 1-2 hits to clear SQ mobs with my Mage, to 3-5 hits, and I'm really dreading leveling up. And don't get me started on TSR. So what parts is everyone else having trouble with? And what suggestions can we give?

I would like Venan to take this seriously so please keep this thread civil and on topic.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorTue Sep 13, 2016 5:37 pm
With the new T21 items I finally feel (at level 36) that the opponents I'm facing in TSR aren't OP. So I'd suggest that as the new top level for Vile Realm enemies and get rid of the scaling. Level 36-37 enemies are still a challenge but will allow us to absorb a little more of the damage. Our toons' own damage does not increase significantly between 35 and 40.

Another way around it would be PvE-only abilities that we can stick the 3 points from levelling to 40 into. The current ones are either designed for pvp or give meagre (because of diminishing returns) boosts along the stat curves that don't seem to make much difference. Some extra abilities designed for PvE that boost damage output might help if they don't want to cap enemy scaling.
Illy_the_Red wrote:
Another way around it would be PvE-only abilities that we can stick the 3 points from levelling to 40 into. The current ones are either designed for pvp or give meagre (because of diminishing returns) boosts along the stat curves that don't seem to make much difference. Some extra abilities designed for PvE that boost damage output might help if they don't want to cap enemy scaling.

I agree. I don't PvP my high end toons and I find those 3 points useless (okay 2, I don't have a toon at 40 yet).
Ames wrote:So Venan has addressed this before and I think many of us can agree it wasn't enough. SQ and TSR get harder and harder to raid as you increase from level 35 to 40. Personally I've gone from 1-2 hits to clear SQ mobs with my Mage, to 3-5 hits, and I'm really dreading leveling up. And don't get me started on TSR. So what parts is everyone else having trouble with? And what suggestions can we give?

Observations: fewer and fewer people are willing to do the onslaught portions of SQ and particularly TSR. It used to be I could help push TSR phase 1 confident there would be plenty of players eager to receive the rewards of the onslaught phases. As more and more players reach level 40, fewer and fewer do the onslaught phases because they find it discouraging. My kill rate went down, not up, with each level, and decreased substantially at level 40.

This is true in all the Vile raids. At level 35 before the update HM was a breeze, a delightful and relaxing change. Now, while not as bad as the later raids, it still can take multiple hits to work through the mobs. It is frustrating to realize that my level 35 justi, whose might is 15k lower than my main, has a much easier time of the vile raids than does my main. If the goal was to have people feel like they had progressed as they went up in level, the exact opposite has taken place.

That isn't to say I'm against a challenge. I get the bulk of my HS in SQ and TSR. But I don't think it's fair to punish players as they advance in level, and I think that's what the current system does in the vile raids and dungeons. This observation is not limited to bosses but applies to mobs as well.

Recommendations: I would like to see Venan dial back the progression of mobs and bosses in vile raids and dungeons. The goal should be that a level 40 toon finds it no more difficult to complete those than does a comparably equipped level 35 toon, that we stop penalizing toons for progressing. We don't play RPGs to go down in abilities as we go up in levels.

In addition, I think we should return to a progression in the vile realm raids. The difference in the difficulty between CV and HM, for example, is minute - much less of a difference than the difference in rewards warrants. To that end I would like to reexamine the scaling concept through the vile realm. Specifically, I propose the following levels of the opponents in vile realm raids:

HM: Max is player's level -4 ( but not less than 31)
LoB: Max is player's level -3 (but not less than 32)
CV; Max is player's level -2 (but not less than 35)
PM: Max is player's level -1 (but not less than 36)
SQ and TSR: Max is the player's level (but not less than 37)

This makes a progression of the vile realm raids. Players newly reaching the realm will be able to find challenging raids and have raids to look forward to doing. Level 35 toons would find HM at 31, LoB at 32, CV at 35, PM at 36 (and very challenging) and SQ and TSR at level 37 (and hence something to work for). Level 40 toons would find HM at 36, LoB at 37, CV at 38, PM at 39, and SQ/TSR at level 40. All the raids would still be a challenge, but the possibility of enjoying an easier raid as a change of pace is still available.
It is just about to get a LOT worse. A lot of people's toons in the new classes are or soon will be level 36 and above. The mights are going to be in the 20-40K range instead of 60-80K. I see a bloodbath.

FYI, if it gets to the point that my main mage (almost 38)/justi(36) are not 1-2 hitting mobs on the existing raids, I am going to quit playing them.

I'm opposed to scaling on the regular raids period. I know why you have to do it for the events so I am not talking about that. This gets to a core design issue this game has always had. Most RPGs pretty closely tie your level with your power. In this game, they are almost completely decoupled and so it is a bad idea to scale based on it.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorWed Sep 14, 2016 10:38 am
DerrinWatson wrote:
Ames wrote:So Venan has addressed this before and I think many of us can agree it wasn't enough. SQ and TSR get harder and harder to raid as you increase from level 35 to 40. Personally I've gone from 1-2 hits to clear SQ mobs with my Mage, to 3-5 hits, and I'm really dreading leveling up. And don't get me started on TSR. So what parts is everyone else having trouble with? And what suggestions can we give?

Observations: fewer and fewer people are willing to do the onslaught portions of SQ and particularly TSR. It used to be I could help push TSR phase 1 confident there would be plenty of players eager to receive the rewards of the onslaught phases. As more and more players reach level 40, fewer and fewer do the onslaught phases because they find it discouraging. My kill rate went down, not up, with each level, and decreased substantially at level 40.

This is true in all the Vile raids. At level 35 before the update HM was a breeze, a delightful and relaxing change. Now, while not as bad as the later raids, it still can take multiple hits to work through the mobs. It is frustrating to realize that my level 35 justi, whose might is 15k lower than my main, has a much easier time of the vile raids than does my main. If the goal was to have people feel like they had progressed as they went up in level, the exact opposite has taken place.

That isn't to say I'm against a challenge. I get the bulk of my HS in SQ and TSR. But I don't think it's fair to punish players as they advance in level, and I think that's what the current system does in the vile raids and dungeons. This observation is not limited to bosses but applies to mobs as well.

Recommendations: I would like to see Venan dial back the progression of mobs and bosses in vile raids and dungeons. The goal should be that a level 40 toon finds it no more difficult to complete those than does a comparably equipped level 35 toon, that we stop penalizing toons for progressing. We don't play RPGs to go down in abilities as we go up in levels.

In addition, I think we should return to a progression in the vile realm raids. The difference in the difficulty between CV and HM, for example, is minute - much less of a difference than the difference in rewards warrants. To that end I would like to reexamine the scaling concept through the vile realm. Specifically, I propose the following levels of the opponents in vile realm raids:

HM: Max is player's level -4 ( but not less than 31)
LoB: Max is player's level -3 (but not less than 32)
CV; Max is player's level -2 (but not less than 35)
PM: Max is player's level -1 (but not less than 36)
SQ and TSR: Max is the player's level (but not less than 37)

This makes a progression of the vile realm raids. Players newly reaching the realm will be able to find challenging raids and have raids to look forward to doing. Level 35 toons would find HM at 31, LoB at 32, CV at 35, PM at 36 (and very challenging) and SQ and TSR at level 37 (and hence something to work for). Level 40 toons would find HM at 36, LoB at 37, CV at 38, PM at 39, and SQ/TSR at level 40. All the raids would still be a challenge, but the possibility of enjoying an easier raid as a change of pace is still available.

Trying to clarify something: in the early part you say don't punish us for progressing to 40, but then later say TSR should have level 40 enemies. Do you mean that the enemies' level should be in line with as you said above (a progression through the raids), but with reduced defence/damage etc? That's the only way I think of that would allow both to work, as the main problem is that the defence/damage of level 40 enemies is 5 levels higher while our own damage output is the same or very similar to what it was at 35. We're still essentially level 35 characters with more health fighting level 40 enemies.

CheMClarc

Site AdminWed Sep 14, 2016 10:56 am
We will be dropping down the enemy levels in the Vile Realm raids a few from what your current level is.

We are also going to have some encounters way easier and others a little bit harder throughout the raids so occasionally you get a fight that keeps you on your toes but it also worth more in drops.

Check out the Pirate Invasion and let us know how you feel about those as they have the same type of principals above.

On top of that, we will be looking to smooth out the might progression curve since players are out leveling content through questing before jumping into any raids.

We are also considering dropping down the wave count on raids so they are easier to accomplish. Though shorter raids means less rewards but more frequent attempts will be available.

Continue to add your feedback here and we will review it all.
CheMClarc wrote:We will be dropping down the enemy levels in the Vile Realm raids a few from what your current level is.

We are also going to have some encounters way easier and others a little bit harder throughout the raids so occasionally you get a fight that keeps you on your toes but it also worth more in drops.

Check out the Pirate Invasion and let us know how you feel about those as they have the same type of principals above.

On top of that, we will be looking to smooth out the might progression curve since players are out leveling content through questing before jumping into any raids.

We are also considering dropping down the wave count on raids so they are easier to accomplish. Though shorter raids means less rewards but more frequent attempts will be available.

Wow. I sit on Santa's lap, hand him my wish list, and he says "It will all be under the tree Christmas morning." I guess I have been a good boy this year after all. :D

On time of raids, I can see that as beneficial. Particularly as GM of two guilds (remind me to have my head examined), shorter raids have a lot to commend them. But, that being said, suppose, for example, there is a raid with 1000 waves, that allows 100 minutes for gold, 150 for silver and 200 for bronze. Suppose you decide to take it to 800 waves. I would allow 85 minutes for gold, 130 for silver, and 180 for bronze. In other words, I would not quite cut back the time commensurate with the reduction in waves. This takes into account the reduced player base in the game generally.
Illy_the_Red wrote:Trying to clarify something: in the early part you say don't punish us for progressing to 40, but then later say TSR should have level 40 enemies. Do you mean that the enemies' level should be in line with as you said above (a progression through the raids), but with reduced defence/damage etc? That's the only way I think of that would allow both to work, as the main problem is that the defence/damage of level 40 enemies is 5 levels higher while our own damage output is the same or very similar to what it was at 35. We're still essentially level 35 characters with more health fighting level 40 enemies.

I am making two independent recommendations. One is to reduce the level of some of the raids. The other is to scale the relationship between enemies and toons at a given level more carefully. Going back to my recommendation, a level 37 toon would find level 36 enemies in PM while a level 40 toon would find level 39 enemies in the same raid. But the raid would be no more difficult for the level 40 toon to complete (and perhaps just a wee bit easier) than the level 37 toon. It wouldn't be a lay down. It wouldn't be like doing KFS, for example. But it should not be harder for a level 40 toon to fight a level 40 foe than it is for a level 37 toon to fight a level 37 foe in the same raid.

Having said all that, I am quite content to see what happens with what Chem suggests. They have obviously given this considerable thought and I commend them for it.