TCG_Garrison64 wrote: Although I do find it amplifies the issues with blocking and dodging on Justicars.
This. The trash mobs are fine (really enjoy those phases), however Justicar is so dependent on getting crits (SW is not) and avoiding blocks and dodges (WM is not). It really exposes the wide balance gap between classes. For example, our guild's top WM was getting 6-8 hunter kills per 4 energy, top SW was getting 5-7 hunter kills, and top two Justicars getting 2-4 kills (all above 10k might). Granted, our WM and SW are awesome players, but that's a pretty sizable gap regardless.
The trash mob phases are definitely where the Justicars shine, but consider: 1. These phases are very short compared to the boss phases; 2. SW and WM were blazing through the trash mob phases too so no real advantage to Justicars here.
My thoughts on Onslaught. It's great in terms of rewards if one can kill more than twice with 4 En. It is also great in terms of actually requiring players to think which skills to choose from instead of mindless grinding which I don't mind. Now here comes what I think it sucks. It sucks in terms of time consumed for burning all 42 En are now doubled, tripled or even quadupled. Instead of being able to burn En in 5-10 minutes every 90 minutes or so, now I need more than 30 minutes to do so. That's with my SW, with my justicar and WM it takes even longer. Although I don't mind concentrating on a raid for an hour or two once a while I don't wish to do so for every single raid. It felt like back when we did double valor weekend again, very exhausting. Right now we have two raids, we haven't tried the Lake Onslaught but Dragonmoor Onslaught has over 10 hours cooldown. I think it is cool to be able to participate no more than 2 Onslaught raids daily. Anymore seriously drains the energy of those hardcore players. This is just my opinion.
I like the onslaught mode, it's much more of a challenge to actually have to think out your moves, and it gives a reason to carry all those runes and potions; in a normal raid or boss run I rarely get hit, but in onslaught it's inevitable.
It certainly allows the mightier characters to score more raid points, which was a large part of the idea. It also makes one think about the skills and gems build, because some skills that are great in normal play are virtually useless in onslaught (good for one round and then long recharge). However as long as onslaught is a sideshow and not the way the whole game runs, you're not going to rebuild your character just to suit onslaught.
Should the whole game work this way, or some phases in normal raids? I'd prefer not. It takes a lot more input, both in real-time concentration and in game invenroty items, and the payback does not reflect this.
You don't have to do the onslaught dungeons, they're totally voluntary in terms of game progress, so if you don't like them, don't do them.
One thing I'd like to see is a solo onslaught dungeon (or three), geared for the level 25s. This could be used as a training ground for regular onslaught, with higher-geared rewqards to refelect the greater input required. Perhaps every regular boss could have a solo onslaught option?
If you manage to beat only two encounters during 4 energy period in onslaught, it just means that your character sucks. Onslaught mode isn't responsible for your incompetence. In our guild we nail 6-8 encounters with 4 energy. You do the math.
I've run through Shadow Comes a few times now on my Justicar and my Shadow Warrior and I have to say this raid is tedious on my Justicar. There are just too many blocks and dodges for a pure melee character. Justicars only have one decent magic attack and it has a very long cool down so it can't be relied on for much. Other than that it's melee only and that is the truely painful part. The wolves especially have a very high dodge rate. I've had wolves dodge me 3 or 4 times in a row and that is just infuriating when there's a timer counting down on each attack. My SW easily outperforms my Justicar even though my SW has 1500 less might. All of the Justicars in our guild are very frustrated with this raid which prompted me to make a seperate thread about Venan re-evaluating blocks and dodges in the game. Things are certainly not fair for Justicars as it stands and the Onslaught raid amplifies that imbalance between classes.
Other than that I still like the idea of these raids and how they function is basically ok. It is more of a challenge and like others have said, it requires strategy and the use of potions and runes much more than in the normal raids. If the blocking and dodging could be changed a bit I might actually enjoy them.
I love onslaught and if you're close to the required might for the raid it's hard but it gets better as you do so it makes it that high and low level might players can get decent rewards from it for their might the only criticism that I have for it is that slow and poison abilities don't carry over but overall AWESOME great job Venen
Pfaff wrote:
One thing I'd like to see is a solo onslaught dungeon (or three), geared for the level 25s. This could be used as a training ground for regular onslaught, with higher-geared rewqards to refelect the greater input required. Perhaps every regular boss could have a solo onslaught option?
I like this idea. I have not done the onslaught mode yet but from what I have heard this sounds like it could be a very welcome addition.
People in this thread complaining about justicars in onslaught need to respec or figure out a decent attack sequence. Justicars do the best of all three characters against the mobs because of heroic will letting you reuse the mob attacks quickly and they are fine against bosses as well. I find Walkers to be the weakest against the mobs due to lack of mob attacks and acid spray being near useless.
The balance is closer on bosses.
Acid spray3 practically eliminates an entire trio of phase 1 Hunter mobs for me (but don't try it on spiders), so it's hardly useless. :)
This thread has more specifics on why people feel justicars don't get a fair shake in onslaught. As expected, it has to do with the dodge/block mechanic, mostly, and I can't disagree. Even outside raids, that needs to be looked at.
Bbbb wrote:People in this thread complaining about justicars in onslaught need to respec or figure out a decent attack sequence. Justicars do the best of all three characters against the mobs because of heroic will letting you reuse the mob attacks quickly and they are fine against bosses as well. I find Walkers to be the weakest against the mobs due to lack of mob attacks and acid spray being near useless.
The balance is closer on bosses.
I agree with your comment on Justicars, with appropriate skills and a good attack sequence it can holds its own on mobs, if not reach the top. For bosses, havent heard manh good things there tho cant imagine why (even taking into account dodge/block).
For second part, i am a SW and by no means think they fall short. I can net 8-9 waves per 4 e on all 3 phases on Shadow raid, and 12-13 waves per 4 e on all 3 phases of Crypt raid. Idk what max are so far, but SWs definitely arent the runt of the litter if you play them correctly.