I think having ties is a fantastic idea. It helps the whole team to grow toegther. Even if the individual has more energy left. They can always do some farming or get ready for next raid. it allows them to have time for themselves while the whole team can slowly aim to hit the same rpp and get bonus, rather than one individual grabbing all n not sharing. Cheers
Ties for Top 3 in Raid, Discussion · page 2
Wow people actually plan 1st place ties? This would never fly in the guild I'm in, we're much too competitive.
During our first onslaught, we were joking on chat that there should be a bonus guild challenge where *ALL* members of a specific raid MVP (much easier now that there are 1st, 2nd, and 3rd place positions). [We had to entertain ourselves while recharging.]
Perhaps this challenge would reward prestige that would be related to the difficulty of the raid. Therefore, Goblins would yield the least prestige.
Perhaps this challenge would reward prestige that would be related to the difficulty of the raid. Therefore, Goblins would yield the least prestige.
Set a mark for all to climb to make this third place have 1 first place and 1 second place so most all can be top contributors for their feats and top two can get their own untouched full bonus for being on the top... get lower might players up or players who burn alot get little more for what they spend in gs for energy i sure those players would like this way to deal with ties
500 MVP is a lot. Younger players rarely have Max energy (all sigs). We've been tieing sometimes on lower raids, usually 3rd place. Challenging raids, whomever can, gets first. We aren't worried about how the squire valor is split- it's for the feat
As someone already said (but I'll repeat anyway) the main reason to do this isn't so more people get the bonus, it's so the few at the top leave more than scraps for lower level members who are trying to advance.
In our guild we now have a rpp cap and all try to tie for first. It isn't really about the bonus % but more about teamwork. Its about a guild that strives to bring its members up in might and experience together. Its about All members having an equal part in its guilds successes and reaping an equal part of the rewards for that success.
If there is a tie for one of the top 3 contributors does each person get the bonus or is it divided among the people who tie?
This question was posted elsewhere by me. Thank you for moving it here and answering my question.
This question was posted elsewhere by me. Thank you for moving it here and answering my question.
Read above, the reward(s) is(are) split. If two tie for first, they each get half of 20%+15%, which would be 17.5%. If five tie for second, they each get one fifth of 15%+10%, which would be 5%. If 10 tie for third, each gets one tenth of 10%, which would be 1%.