Book of Heroes

Ties for Top 3 in Raid, Discussion

New Subject
Ties for Top 3 in Raid, Discussion

OLD Subject
Stop forcing ties in raids

EDITED DUE TO FEEDBACK

If multiple people tie for first in a raid the MVP bonus is divided between all that got first place.
Many guilds now force their members to hold themselves back to cause a tie.
Sometimes 15 - 20 players will tie for first.

What's the problem you might ask?
1. If 15 people tie for first they each get a 1.3% bonus. If those same people hold back 10+ energy just to tie, don't they now have less rewards? Are they not better off using that 10+ energy to get more rpp? What is the point of forcing a tie if everyone ends up with less rewards because of it?
2. It discourages people using GS to get more rpp.
3. It just doesn't feel like how raids were meant to be played.

My suggestion is simple.
Make it clear in the rewards mail that ties result in divided rpp bonus.
When people start to realise they are lowering their rewards by holding back energy just to tie for a weak bonus, they should stop.


Also, Darksideofman had an interesting idea:
Darksideofman wrote:

What if instead, the rewards were not only handled by attacks but also the time it took them to get their rpp. In an example, If I and 5 five other members of my guild go into a raid and I amass 5000 rpp and then my energy ran out. Another member who uses GS finishes raid while my energy is filling and reaches 5000 rpp in his final attack thus causing a tie. Since I got to the 5000 rpp first I would therefore have first place and my guild mate would receive second. This would solve your issue of ties as well as not punish "yourself" if you were to be top contributor.
molly wrote:

My suggestion is simple.
If 2 people tie for top spot, they should tie for 2nd and get the reward bonus for 2nd.
If 3 people tie for top spot, they should tie for 3rd and get the reward bonus for 3rd.
If 4+ people tie for top spot, they should tie for 4th+ and get no reward bonus.
Do the the same for a tie for 2nd highest and 3rd highest.

I don't like this idea. No offence intended but this method punishes the top performers. I think that if the devs were to try and create a new method to handle ties there is a better way. What if instead, the rewards were not only handled by attacks but also the time it took them to get their rpp. In an example, If I and 5 five other members of my guild go into a raid and I amass 5000 rpp and then my energy ran out. Another member who uses GS finishes raid while my energy is filling and reaches 5000 rpp in his final attack thus causing a tie. Since I got to the 5000 rpp first I would therefore have first place and my guild mate would receive second. This would solve your issue of ties as well as not punish "yourself" if you were to be top contributor.
So a feature of the game that suits 15-20 people in your guild but doesn't suit you should be changed?

In our Guild we got tired of people coming in once a day to rip up 1st place with massive GS usage, then leave to do the same to another Guild. They hurt our own members progress in the long run, by hogging the raid RPP. There's one mercenary toon doing the rounds at the moment that we won't allow to do that to us, and will get thrown from the Guild if he tries.

Guilds are about teamwork. Rather than trying to change a feature that many Guilds are using to help their weaker (and poorer) members grow, why not join a Guild where you can be selfish and burn GS as much as you like?
Like I said before, tie MVP is pointless. If 10 people all tied with Top 1, each will get 2% as oppose to 20%.

Little_Mike

Site AdminWed Aug 8, 2012 8:08 pm
I can confirm to you guys that the bonus is split between ties. If there are 3 or more tied for 1st place, all 3 bonuses are split equally. However, at the moment, all those tied for 1st place will get credit for the MVP achievements.
In our our guild, this is a cool exercise in teamwork, and we all marvel at the awesomeness of splitting MVP so many ways. Maybe it's just a question of viewpoint.
I'm going to have to go with the "Guilds Expansion" card, here.

Try GS'ing, a tough raid, solo; then ask yourself if your complaint is valid. Without those so called (cheaters) you get nothing, but the same isn't true in reverse.

I think the most valid point posted already is find a guild that fits your style.

I'd also like to point out that if 15 ppl have the same rpp in a tough raid, not only is that an awesome accomplishment, it doesn't reward enough Valor in comparison, to solo or tied payouts; even before the percentage splits happen.

So I believe a call for cheating is wrongly issued, there.

:) ...only have to wait 5 minutes before you can smack something, though. (5mins max that is)
thanks for the shout out, Setsuna_F_Seiei!

just wanted to say that if 15 people split first place, the bonus is higher than 1.33% each.

they actually get to split the 20%+15%+10% bonuses 15 ways and not just the 20% so everyone actually gets 3%.

a little better but probably still not worth the effort.