Book of Heroes

The "Merc" Problem · page 2

The problem is the potential of endless raiding plus lack of incentives of solo farming. In any MMORPG, anyone can solo farm because it gives them the money and drops. Money is gained by killing so one can buy better equipment, but money in boh becomes obsolete after a while, best equipment money can buy can be achieved fairly quick and money has bare minimum use afterward. Drop in mmorpg is what kept ppl playing, so they can get better rare and unique items. In boh, you can no longer get items from boss drop but even if u can, one can achieve T11 final gear with moderate raiding fairly quick. There is no point of solo farming in this game

Now the potential endless raiding problem. The current raid system makes any guild to be able to raid as much as they can and as often as they want. So any guild that wishes to be on top can raid back to back pretty much or in anther word, none stop. I like to enjoy the freedom of solo farming or team farming like in other mmo, not endless raiding.

Also If I know the raid can be 100% successful and I get my reward at the end, I have no problem with it. But raids tend to fail these days and all effort and energy and time spent went down in drain. In other mmo, if a raid fail, at least players retain the money and drops from the raid. Since money is kinda useless, it really kills players when raids fail.

Last but not least, current stat system makes it less satisfactory and less motivated to farm for L4 gems let along T12 or L5 gems if they were ever introduced in 1.5. Since one can max out pretty much 2/3 of the stats with full t11 and l4 gems, there's really no point to continue if stats don't get revised. But I keep my finger crossed since dev said there will be stat revamp in 1.5.
Pfaff wrote:

As a final thought, there are several Guilds even in the top 20 who are notable for NOT asking for mercenaries in Global chat, and not trying to poach members from other Guilds, yet they're still rolling along happily and keeping their power up, which means they're completing raids.

Since I saw a merc ad from Black Lotus this week, I believe I have seen every guild in the top 30 or so ask for merc help. At most, there are one or two who don't ask for help.

japster

ModeratorThu Oct 4, 2012 9:10 am
I'm just glad to see that this thread has generated healthy discussion. I think everybody is in agreement that there's something direly wrong with the entire guild-raid system, thus leading to the prevalence of the mercenary culture.

Sure we have differences on solutions, but glad to see the community being alive to the idea that the current guild system is problematic and possibly obsolete if the server is to continue the way it is.

Keep up the great ideas and discussion guys! I'm sure Venan's reading =)
It isn't the "merc" problem. The real problem is retention. High end players quit playing BoH for a variety of reasons and you can't replace them.

Let me take my guild as an example. If everybody could be on at the same time, we can do Vallus ourselves but given time zones and real life that is impossible (except possibly Sunday afternoon). The way we usually complete Vallus is to work our alliances and get other mercs. It's a lot of stress and effort to play that way. Then something like this week I get sucked into real life and the guild has mostly downgraded to Zuur to be able to complete raids successfully.

Short of another guild imploding, it is doubtful that we will be able to recruit more Vallus ready players. By the time the lower might players get there, I expect a wash with attrition. The CK raid is just about as difficult because the fighting takes longer and the compressed time frame.

My suggestions:

1. Remove the min might limit!!!! Still leave it as a recommended might. If a player gets their ass kicked by being too weak, so be it.
2. Allow players to subscribe to raid notifications of other guilds.
3. Make an easier KV based raid so guilds can earn KV without needing about 20 people at once. One way is to rebalance Shadow Comes as everybody hates that raid and hardly anybody runs it - you can lower the payout but either lower the energy requirements (to 4 or 5) and/or put the time frame back. This would help player retention.
4. Instead of making raid failure an all or nothing, just pay out some type of pro-rated amount. This would make more guilds more aggressive in their raids.

GvG is a negative in my book. It would make me less likely to play.

This is an important problem because many high end players want their guild to be successful but given attrition, it is nearly impossible to move forward.
I agree with most of what's been said here. I have merced a bit to might up my alt in the past couple of weeks and boy it is so much easier than belonging to a guild. In essence this is wrong as it deters people from staying in a guild, hence making guild more dependent upon mercing. So, the idea of rewarding someone for their continuous presence in a guild is nice.

I'm not sure about removing the might limit though. You usually don't need the might required to complete a raid (I'm sure I could do vallus with 6k might without taking a hit) but at least the fact that might requirements are so high gives people an incentive to progress and play. If you could do WoF at 7k might, less people would go above 10k and hence people may get burnt out faster than they are now.
Pfaff wrote:2) Offer easier/shorter raids with the same Valor rates of return. Either reduce the hits necessary in the current time, or increadse the timespan of the raids retauningthe current hit requirement. Either will make it easier for a smaller number of toons to complete a raid. New raids could be added as testers for this approach, rather than messing with the current raids that people are used to.
I'd actually like to see much longer raids. 6h raids were originally supposed to be easier but didn't work out that well. If you could get, say, a 16h raid requiring twice as many fights as a current 4h raid, it would be easier for people to pop in/pop out whenever they can and not at a specific time. Increasing the membership limit would be good too. It may also make it easier to merge current guilds and reduce the number of dying/struggling groups.
TCG_japster wrote:
I think more has to be done to make the concept of a guild attractive, beyond favors. Methods to promote guild loyalty. A straightforward way may be to penalize mercs for hopping guilds by lowering the ratio of valor they get to RPP.

If not, perhaps more attractive bonuses for guilds, or a sort of guild-exclusive items, where they can only be obtained and used when someone is in a particular guild.

God forbid but there are way too many mercs, and way too few guilds capable of running a guild raid with only loyal guild members, without mercs and gs.

All I'll say is, Amen!

Hachiman_Defender_of_Oda

ModeratorFri Oct 5, 2012 1:44 pm
Besides, for those with hectic schedules, Mercing IS the best for them to develope their toon. I think Venan should be complimented on creating an environment that so closely follows real life in this manner. There are plenty of people that work for companies, and then there are freelances. Its always been this way, mercenaries have a long history, and it has a rightful place in BOH.

And the responsibility DOES fall on the guild to be innovative and special to keep their members, loyalty is earned, not demanded, or "fixed" by an update.

We have about 250 toons in the Kingdom of Eld, and I like to think its because we are doing something right. Whether its having a uniquie Model for Individual Growth, a Strong Bond, or just the way we respect people, I think we have earned the respect and loyalty that we have from our members and even our regular mercs.

I don't see a "Merc" Problem, I see a natural environment full of great people.
Jetras_of_Eld wrote:Besides, for those with hectic schedules, Mercing IS the best for them to develope their toon. I think Venan should be complimented on creating an environment that so closely follows real life in this manner. There are plenty of people that work for companies, and then there are freelances. Its always been this way, mercenaries have a long history, and it has a rightful place in BOH.

And the responsibility DOES fall on the guild to be innovative and special to keep their members, loyalty is earned, not demanded, or "fixed" by an update.

We have about 250 toons in the Kingdom of Eld, and I like to think its because we are doing something right. Whether its having a uniquie Model for Individual Growth, a Strong Bond, or just the way we respect people, I think we have earned the respect and loyalty that we have from our members and even our regular mercs.

I don't see a "Merc" Problem, I see a natural environment full of great people.

You don't see the problem because you haven't had many members who have reached maxed out everything and are burned out. Also, you guys are Lv7 guild or below, meaning you haven't even started to raid fs or wof which require more than half the guild to complete. Wait until majority of your members are above 10k might and are raiding fs/wof, then come back and tell us you don't have merc problem. Maybe you'll be one of the few guild that doesn't have it but the chance is quite slim judging by the current trend
Farful has most members WoF ready. We raid FS and Vallus regularly. Yes, we have gone through dark times with burnout and loss of that initial momentum. We pulled together as a guild and found more lasting reasons to play. We enjoy the camaraderie and the collective effort.

We enjoy the fresh perspective and enthusiasm that mercs bring. Some even like the place well enough to stick around and become members.
Camaro wrote:
You don't see the problem because you haven't had many members who have reached maxed out everything and are burned out.

Mercenaries aren't the problem, they're the solution to the problem of burnout.