Book of Heroes

The "Merc" Problem · page 4

Markonian wrote:
Pfaff wrote:
TCG_japster wrote: ...the ease of mercing makes burn out occur even faster.

I'm not really sure I can even agree with that.

I don't think that many would say it was because they merced and got burnt out.

(And yet....)

Probable reasons for burnout:

I merced so much I wore myself out.


Hmm.....


A perfect example of quoting out of context. Well done.
TCG_japster wrote:
Actually how I felt merc-ing accelerates burn out is because huge presence of mercs consistently during a guild's major raids tend to demoralize existing members, giving them more reason to stop being dedicated.

From there they can either quit entirely, or drop out and become a casual raider/merc themselves. Hope that explains my POV.

You think the presence of mercs in your guild raids causes dropouts.
I think dropouts cause Guilds to invite mercs to join raids.

In truth there's both factors at work.
Pfaff wrote:
TCG_japster wrote: ...the ease of mercing makes burn out occur even faster.

I'M NOT REALLY SURE I CAN EVEN AGREE WITH THAT. (sic)

If we could survey the people who have burned out/dropped out (obviously not possible if they are no longer playing), I DON'T THINK THAT MANY WOULD SAY IT WAS BECAUSE THEY MERCED AND GOT BURNT OUT. (sic)

PROBABLE REASONS FOR BURNOUT: (sic)

1) Reached the top level (10250 Might or more), did War of Fellmarsh, nothing new for me to do.
2) Game got repetitive before I even got to 10250 might.
3) My guild died, and I didn't want to join another one
4) I played so much (possibly with multiple characters) that my wife/husband/boyfriend etc complained

5) I MERCED SO MUCH I WORE MYSELF OUT. (sic)

6) other reasons?


You're RIGHT! We SHOULD follow Journalistic Standards! So I have rewritten it, with Correct Citations Insitu & Stated in Context. Thanks for kindly pointing this out. It DOES help to Strengthen the Point. Much appreciated! :-)
Markonian wrote:
Pfaff wrote:
TCG_japster wrote: ...the ease of mercing makes burn out occur even faster.

I'M NOT REALLY SURE I CAN EVEN AGREE WITH THAT. (sic)

If we could survey the people who have burned out/dropped out (obviously not possible if they are no longer playing), I DON'T THINK THAT MANY WOULD SAY IT WAS BECAUSE THEY MERCED AND GOT BURNT OUT. (sic)

PROBABLE REASONS FOR BURNOUT: (sic)

1) Reached the top level (10250 Might or more), did War of Fellmarsh, nothing new for me to do.
2) Game got repetitive before I even got to 10250 might.
3) My guild died, and I didn't want to join another one
4) I played so much (possibly with multiple characters) that my wife/husband/boyfriend etc complained

5) I MERCED SO MUCH I WORE MYSELF OUT. (sic)

6) other reasons?


You're RIGHT! We SHOULD follow Journalistic Standards! So I have rewritten it, with Correct Citations Insitu & Stated in Context. Thanks for kindly pointing this out. It DOES help to Strengthen the Point. Much appreciated! :-)


Better, thanks!

So my point is, although it's on the list of reasons for purposes of completeness, I doubt many people would tick this option. I should have used the word possible instead of probable for clarity.
Shut the doors! Lets be exclusive! We hate mercs and we would rather fail raids than allow mercs to save our ass. Get my drift?

japster

ModeratorTue Oct 9, 2012 7:23 am
Pfaff wrote:

You think the presence of mercs in your guild raids causes dropouts.
I think dropouts cause Guilds to invite mercs to join raids.

In truth there's both factors at work.

I think you are right. It's an inter-play. Anyway just for the record...the topic thread wasn't meant to pin the problems on mercs. If people have been reading, my suggestions are for more guild-oriented content, not so much mercs are the end of BOH :P I just chose a more controversial title to get some attention.
TCG_japster wrote:
Pfaff wrote:

You think the presence of mercs in your guild raids causes dropouts.
I think dropouts cause Guilds to invite mercs to join raids.

In truth there's both factors at work.

I think you are right. It's an inter-play. Anyway just for the record...the topic thread wasn't meant to pin the problems on mercs. If people have been reading, my suggestions are for more guild-oriented content, not so much mercs are the end of BOH :P I just chose a more controversial title to get some attention.


Classic; so in typical social media style, you chose to encourage debate by titling your thread with a "hard hitting" headline to stimulate debate?

If PvP were and option; I'd smite you. Hard.

japster

ModeratorTue Oct 9, 2012 11:34 am
Chon wrote:
TCG_japster wrote:
Pfaff wrote:

You think the presence of mercs in your guild raids causes dropouts.
I think dropouts cause Guilds to invite mercs to join raids.

In truth there's both factors at work.

I think you are right. It's an inter-play. Anyway just for the record...the topic thread wasn't meant to pin the problems on mercs. If people have been reading, my suggestions are for more guild-oriented content, not so much mercs are the end of BOH :P I just chose a more controversial title to get some attention.


Classic; so in typical social media style, you chose to encourage debate by titling your thread with a "hard hitting" headline to stimulate debate?

If PvP were and option; I'd smite you. Hard.

Well, I would Incinerate you before you'd a chance to even move a finger =)

Anyway it's a legit strategy to draw some attention. It got the job done, the discussion flowed and well my points came across eventually.