Book of Heroes

The "Merc" Problem · page 3

japster

ModeratorSun Oct 7, 2012 11:23 pm
Pfaff wrote:
Camaro wrote:
You don't see the problem because you haven't had many members who have reached maxed out everything and are burned out.

Mercenaries aren't the problem, they're the solution to the problem of burnout.

Yes I kinda agree. But the ease of mercing makes burn out occur even faster. Regardless, the bottom line isn't so much of a "merc problem" (I titled the thread as such get the attention haha), but of a "guild problem". How can we give greater incentives to being loyal in a guild?
TCG_japster wrote: ...the ease of mercing makes burn out occur even faster.

I'm not really sure I can even agree with that.

If we could survey the people who have burned out/dropped out (obviously not possible if they are no longer playing), I don't think that many would say it was because they merced and got burnt out.

Probable reasons for burnout:

1) Reached the top level (10250 Might or more), did War of Fellmarsh, nothing new for me to do.
2) Game got repetitive before I even got to 10250 might.
3) My guild died, and I didn't want to join another one
4) I played so much (possibly with multiple characters) that my wife/husband/boyfriend etc complained
5) I merced so much I wore myself out
6) other reasons?


However, reasons for dropout and lack of Guild loyalty aside, the simplest way to keep people loyal to a Guild was one I suggested when the new levels of Veteran & Recruit were introduced. Recruits don't get Guild Favors.
Danielywl wrote:How about a cup of stfu


Thank you for a most helpful and stimulating addition to the discussion.

japster

ModeratorMon Oct 8, 2012 12:32 pm
Pfaff wrote:
TCG_japster wrote: ...the ease of mercing makes burn out occur even faster.

I'm not really sure I can even agree with that.

If we could survey the people who have burned out/dropped out (obviously not possible if they are no longer playing), I don't think that many would say it was because they merced and got burnt out.

Probable reasons for burnout:

1) Reached the top level (10250 Might or more), did War of Fellmarsh, nothing new for me to do.
2) Game got repetitive before I even got to 10250 might.
3) My guild died, and I didn't want to join another one
4) I played so much (possibly with multiple characters) that my wife/husband/boyfriend etc complained
5) I merced so much I wore myself out
6) other reasons?


However, reasons for dropout and lack of Guild loyalty aside, the simplest way to keep people loyal to a Guild was one I suggested when the new levels of Veteran & Recruit were introduced. Recruits don't get Guild Favors.

Actually how I felt merc-ing accelerates burn out is because huge presence of mercs consistently during a guild's major raids tend to demoralize existing members, giving them more reason to stop being dedicated.

From there they can either quit entirely, or drop out and become a casual raider/merc themselves. Hope that explains my POV.
Pfaff wrote:
TCG_japster wrote: ...the ease of mercing makes burn out occur even faster.

I'm not really sure I can even agree with that.

I don't think that many would say it was because they merced and got burnt out.

(And yet....)

Probable reasons for burnout:

I merced so much I wore myself out.


Hmm.....
Danielywl wrote:How about a cup of stfu

A Shining Example of "Endearing" Merc Philosophy! ;-)

Hachiman_Defender_of_Oda

ModeratorMon Oct 8, 2012 2:24 pm
Camaro wrote:
You don't see the problem because you haven't had many members who have reached maxed out everything and are burned out. Also, you guys are Lv7 guild or below, meaning you haven't even started to raid fs or wof which require more than half the guild to complete. Wait until majority of your members are above 10k might and are raiding fs/wof, then come back and tell us you don't have merc problem. Maybe you'll be one of the few guild that doesn't have it but the chance is quite slim judging by the current trend

I love it when someone else tells me why I don't see something, when they don't know what I've seen.

Yes we do have people that have maxed out, but they stay with us because we are their guild. They had to merc to build up to that might, but they have stayed loyal to the guild because we have more to offer than just favors. I'm not going to assume why you have experienced this problem, or assume why you feel the need to put the short comings of you guild onto the backs of the mercs that are there to help you, because I don't tell people what only they know.

The Mercs and the Guild Problem that you are describing are totally not related, I mean think about it, your point is that your guild is burned out, and having difficulty completing raids, and I assume that mercs HELP you complete them, so why is this a Merc problem and not a guild problem? I am trying to follow your logic, I'm not going to judge you and belittle you, I truely am trying to follow the logic.

Hachiman_Defender_of_Oda

ModeratorMon Oct 8, 2012 2:30 pm
TCG_japster wrote:Actually how I felt merc-ing accelerates burn out is because huge presence of mercs consistently during a guild's major raids tend to demoralize existing members, giving them more reason to stop being dedicated.

From there they can either quit entirely, or drop out and become a casual raider/merc themselves. Hope that explains my POV.

I understand that japster, but I would move to point out that the burnout your talking about isn't on the merc side, its on the perception of the guild members that the mercs are helping. The only way that would be demoralizing is if they didn't truely want the merc help and their perception was "tired of being helped" instead of "enjoying the raid with friends that are also mercs".

When you lock down the boundaries of your guild to where you very mercs as pests instead of friends, this can happen, but again, that's a guild problem, not a merc problem. Most of the "problems" in this game are simply "perception" issues. Change the perception and you'll soon overcome your "problem".