Book of Heroes

Silencing by mods · page 2

Doctor_Love_Money_Shot

Fri Dec 28, 2012 9:55 am
TCS_Illanna_ wrote:I would like to go on record that no matter the outcome of this situation, the idea of mods is a good one. Being a mod is a thankless, as well ad unpaid, job and respect should be shown for their effort. No one has escaped life's less than shining moments and this in it's entirity is one. We need to trust venan's decision, accept it, and move on to complaining about the poor drop rate. Illanna.

I will fully agree with you on this Illanna. I have made numerous posts in global that I fully respect and support the mods and the job they must do as a whole. Their position is very valuable and needed to keep things in global clean. But that doesn't mean bad apples don't get in the barrel every now and then and that is the primary issue here. There needs to be a review process and either a re-education or reassignment of responsibilities to people who can better represent Venan to the rest of the gaming world.

It would be bad for Venan if people posted bad reviews in the app stores on this game simply because certain mods have run amok in global chat and ruined the gaming experience for other players. It is difficult to enjoy a game when heavy handed mods are silencing people at every turn for frivolous "imaginary" violations.

Doctor_Love_Money_Shot

Fri Dec 28, 2012 9:57 am
Lady_Katy wrote:
Doctor_Love wrote:
Lady_Katy wrote:Thanks for bringing this to our attention. We will pull the logs and review accordingly. For the sake of civility, we will deal with the parties involved individually and not on the forums.

Your own moderators told us to stop talking in global chat and discuss this in the forum as it was the proper location for this type of discussion. Are you saying that once again, the mods don't know what they are doing by advising us to take it up here? You see why SO MANY players are so upset with the apparent lack of regulation over the mods. They have free reign to do whatever they want, right or wrong. Something MUST change.

Nope, everyone is okay posting here. I just meant that I'm not going to discuss your personal moderation status with other players :) I didn't want people getting mad since a resolution to this particular issue won't be posted in this thread.

Thank you for clarifying your position Katy. Several players have already mentioned they were going to comment but stopped after reading your response, thinking you were forbiding further discussion.
The concept of a global mod is in and of itself a good one. But I see in many occasions where certain mods are obviously following a personal agenda. Mods should be neutral and emotionless but they're human beings and therefore by nature filled with their own biases and prejudices. We all have them so I don't mean it as an insult. However, if mods can't rise above them then they should not hold the position. Venan needs to police these people since some obviously have gone above what they were meant to do. We are the ones PAYING for this game. That gives us the right to have some fun, including global chat. Without us, mods have no jobs and VENAN doesn't exist. If GvG ever happens I KNOW some of these mods will not be able to keep a modicum of neutrality. VENAN review these people, just because someone applied for position of mod doesn't mean they have the intelligence or strength of character to hold it. Oda Jetras is, imo, a perfect example of what a mod should be. And only one who doesn't adv raids for his guild. I like that
Every one across BoH knows that I have an issue with the mods! Not the mod itself persay buy the fact that one mod will allow u to say one thing than the next will be telling you that it is globally inappropriate. What really irks me about this situation is 2 days ago there was a dev and mod in global and a player was upset and decided to go on a cursing tangent ... The dev said he understood that so and so was upset ... Themod did nothing ... 5 mins later the player was allowed to curse again ..I than asked if anyone was planning on saying anything ... and was completely ignored ... It is completely unfair that we are unable to report mods .. in times like this and when these mods are supposed to be applying chat rules and instead reading chat rules than making up the ones they think should be there also
I spoke about this in global but I think it's worth suggesting. We should have a weekly review of the mod. How much they post, etc. and there should be a voting system. And new candidates can replace not active ones or not so popular ones. Mods should be active as well as well liked.
Leeaiwaz wrote:I spoke about this in global but I think it's worth suggesting. We should have a weekly review of the mod. How much they post, etc. and there should be a voting system. And new candidates can replace not active ones or not so popular ones. Mods should be active as well as well liked.
I completely agree
First, Neph thank you for not dissapointing :).
Second, I have been around this game a long time and consider global to be my home lol. I have been silenced and warned on numerous occasions and rightly so if you looked at the logs. The night in question, several players should have been silenced including me for comments made after warnings were made about a certain topic. Doc, clearly did not step out of line during the night in question and received an undeserved silence while a noob continued to violate spam rules. Having a player violate spam unchecked and Doc silenced for reason not clear, showed a mod had silenced him based on personal dislike and not from a violation or chat rules. Slight correction, the spaming noob was eventually warned and silenced later, but well after it should have occurred. As difficult as it may be, chat police need to be unbiased or relieved of their duties.

Ps.Doc I hope you approve, for it is difficult for android users to type on BOH chat screens.
I was on global when this occurred and did not post because I didn't want to add fuel to the fire. However, monk was way out of line when he silenced doc. It was obviously a power play in addition to a run and hide. Mods need to be accountable for silencing and explain why they did so.

. If the majority of those watching what occurred could not understand why a player was silenced there needs to be a clearly stated rule or explanation not just to appease the vocal, but to define to the observers what warrants a silencing.
My issue is that after monk silenced dr he vanished and wouldn't respond on whisper or global. If you make a potentially controversial decision then you need to explain and defend it. By disappearing monk made a difficult situation worse. I think there needs to be closer monitoring of the moderators. Those who seek power are often those most likely to abuse it.


Chris
obviously the mods in chat are a necessary thing, but there must be a clear cut code of conduct, much the same as we are subject to. I totally agree with metting out punishment to people who can not abide by such rules, but doing it in an arbitrary manner or with an agenda is just wrong. This can become a very slippery slope. i know the situation and support doctor love 100% I can only hope that venan and the other mods deal with situation in a fair and timely fashion