I loveeeee all the mods! But my beef with them is they just won't silence me even though I beg my hearts out

Leeaiwaz wrote:I spoke about this in global but I think it's worth suggesting. We should have a weekly review of the mod. How much they post, etc. and there should be a voting system. And new candidates can replace not active ones or not so popular ones. Mods should be active as well as well liked.
The selection of mods is not a popularity contest and is not up for debate. We (Venan) will decide who and who does not become a moderator.
I must say I agree with little mike above but I think they need to be monitoring the mods more closely as far as I have seen we have some great mods on the whole but there's one or two that are misusing the power you have vested in them and this needs reviewing
I've finally been able to read through the chat logs and this is our stance on it. In my opinion, no one is blameless in this situation, even us at Venan. There are several issues at hand here.
First an overview, a word that can be used questionably was used in a raid ad. A moderator kindly asked that the initial poster should not use that word. The initial poster agreed and that should have been the end of it. However several people decided to argue on his behalf that the word is perfectly fine. Moderators then asked for people to end the conversation but it continued. Even after repeated warnings, it seemed to me that Dr Love started being disrespectful to Monk. Monk then seemed to take this personally and issued a 3 hour silence to Dr Love.
In my own personal opinion, the word that was initially used can be used inappropriately in certain contexts. I think all of us as moderators can do a better job determining if certain words were used in an inappropriate way. To me, I don't think the person who posted this raid ad had any devious intentions, however one of our moderators did. It is our fault as Venan that not all of the moderators are on the same page when it comes to what exactly is considered inappropriate in chat. We will do our best to work with our moderators on this in the future.
This being said, I believe that the silence that was issued was not due to the use of this word. In fact, the initial poster even tried to keep the peace in chat and was cooperative with the moderators. It seems to me that several users were not finished and continued to argue on his behalf. Expressing your discontent with something is fine in global chat but when it starts to negatively affect other players, then moderators have the right to try to keep the peace. In my opinion, this is what I think Monk was trying to do. Several verbal and system warnings were given to try to get people to end the conversation, but it continued. Dr Love then started calling Monk childish and a coward for trying to keep the peace. At this point, I believe Monk took this as a personal offense and issued the 3 hour silence.
Now, Dr Love has his right to his opinions about the moderators, but I believe the arguments in global chat was not constructive at this point. The arguments should have ceased and an email complaint should have instead been sent to us. However, Dr Love continued to argue with Monk, and then started being disrespectful to him, at which point he was silenced.
Was this warranted? The silence was issued shortly after Monk requested Dr Love to whisper him so they could discuss the problems, but right after that, Dr Love called him a coward. I think Monk didn't need to silence him at this point and instead try to discuss it with Dr Love in private first. What should have been said was that the conversation was starting to negatively affect global chat and that if he had any issues with the initial word being moderated, he should email us about it. I believe that could have been an amicable ending to this ordeal.
However, the silence was issued and it has come to this. To make this clear, there were 2 moderators involved in this situation. The first taking offense to the initial word, and the second being Monk silencing Dr Love. The argument Dr Love was making was that moderators were using their own personal agenda and abusing their power. Looking at this, I do not believe this was the case. The first moderator took an offense to a word that I would say 80% of the time is fine, but I don't believe there was some crusade going on to silence everyone that uses it as some have argued the mods are doing. We will be looking into making our moderators more consistent so something like this doesn't happen again. The second moderator, Monk, was I believe simply trying to keep the peace and silenced someone that was being disrespectful to him. I think that the situation could have been resolved without it going to that. Dr Love should not have kept arguing with the moderators and have instead ended the conversation when it was requested to by the moderators. Continuing to argue in global chat is not constructive and future grievances should be instead emailed to us.
Please understand that being a moderator is a very tough position. Since we as Venan cannot be in chat 24/7 we have volunteers from all over the world helping us keep Book of Heroes a nice and clean environment. We are all humans and mistakes will be made. It is my opinion that Monk is not the power hungry person some of you are making him out to be, but rather someone that was trying to keep the peace with whatever tools he had available (system warnings and silences). We will be looking at ways in the future to improve the moderation process.
This is our final comment on this particular situation, and I will be locking this topic. If you have any opinions about this post, please email us. If any of you are still angry for whatever reason and decide to send us a hostile email, please be aware that we will not engage in conversation with you. Thank you for your understanding.
/end long verdict