Book of Heroes

Silencing by mods

I would like to voice my concern over the silencing of Dr love, he like myself are veteran players of this game & to be silenced over an a difference of opinion is very concerning. We have rights as paying players to voice our opinion on any matters & if this said opinion contradicts that of a mod we are silenced for it, this is also of great concern for me. Venan doc did not violate any of the said 'rules' of chat, all he did was have a difference of opinion to a mod & for this he was silenced, I and many others are very upset with these turn of events & would like doc to be reinstated to full & active playing status immediately. 
I second the petition to lift ban on doc. It is disturbing when mod or venan cannot take a criticism. Those are for improving the game as a whole. I know mods are supposed to stick to each other but one rotten fish can ruin the whole mod system. I would like to have venan review the situation and fix the situation properly.
The behaviour of the mod in question has already been put under review previously with regard to this particular player. A mod should be able to control his/her emotions and not get personal when they perceive criticism, and this applies even more so when they're dealing with a player with whom they clearly have issues. If a mod can't be impartial, they should have their status revoked. I support the removal of Doc_Love's silencing and request a review of the mod's actions.

Doctor_Love_Money_Shot

Fri Dec 28, 2012 7:37 am
I freely admit, and the review of chat logs will show, that I commented that some mods are childish in their actions and enforcement of rules that they seem to make up on the fly. This earned me an immediate warning with no explanation in whisper and KG Monk, the mod in question, took a very long time before hinting in global as to why the warning was issued, despite repeated requests for explanation. I told Monk that he should have whispered me if he felt I was violating the rules of chat before throwing out warnings.

Later, I called Monk a coward for acting childish in issuing a warning without giving any explanation and avoiding the situation. Monk replied saying that if I had a problem, I should take it up with him in whisper. I immediately agreed and stated that he should have whispered me first if he didn't feel the conversation was appropriate for global chat. Mere seconds after I agreed to move to whisper, I was issued a silencing.

The sad part is that this is not the first time Monk has issued a warning to me. He did it several months ago when saying I was violating chat rules. However, I immediately re-read the chat rules and there was in fact no rule against what was said. Monk decided to make up his own chat rules, just like today when he openly stated that he "personally" didn't like the comment by another player which started everything off in the first place. It was not a violation of chat rules as written by Venan. It was simply something Monk didn't "personally" like. And the last time I was issued a warning by Monk for his made up chat rules, I complained to Venan and they actually removed my account warning and overruled Monk because he was clearly making up his own rules and then handing out warnings based on them.

So now you know the things that I said which earned me a silencing from a rogue moderator who has a history of making up his own rules. Was this really deserving of an account silencing? Or was this a case of gross abuse of power by a mod with a history of being overruled by Venan already. Maybe this was retribution for being embarassed the last time? Sure looks like he has a personal agenda to me.
Dr Loved did not breaking any chat rules. It's not fair that he got silent because of certain mod doesn't like him. I'm always happy playing his game cuz of good ppl that r on it. Now I'm frustrated because a certain mod abuse his power. These kind of actions make play don't wanna play anymore. Should I be afraid to go global have an argument with a if he is right or wrong( without breaking any chat rules)? Or should I kiss up every mod so I won't get silent? Please do not turn game into a dictatorship and this lift the band on Doc. Love.

Lady_Katy

Site AdminFri Dec 28, 2012 8:29 am
Thanks for bringing this to our attention. We will pull the logs and review accordingly. For the sake of civility, we will deal with the parties involved individually and not on the forums.
Just one thought, as I really dont want to pursue flamewars since Lady_Katy responded (though I too believe that this silencing was arbitrary).

It is perfectly OK to have likes or dislikes or specifically dislike someone (I am e.g. definitely not a people person and am not aiming at becoming everyones best pal) or uphold personal preferences, or codes of conduct, but please ppl think twice before getting trigger happy i.e. silencing.

Despite current lack of PvP or GvG BOH is moving further towards competitive environment, with guilds becoming more active, leaderboards and all. Players and guilds will compete more and more. Things could become much more competitive in the nearest future.

So it is one thing to routinely silence a juvenile badmouth novice jumping out of nowhere to drop off a few favorite curse words, but quite another to silence an officer / prominent member of a major guild for no good reason. Being silenced means not being able to post guild ads, speak with your buddies or mercs during a raid and generally being unable to promote the raid (mind you, KOTOR is actively into GK/VG now). So there should be a good, valid, obvious and unequivocal reason to do so. Not just "fuelling the uneasy topic" or "doing a bit of regular very mild trolling on the edge". The latter are rather usual things which a person with even a moderate forum/chat experience should be able to handle without silencing, unless things go REALLY ugly...

Doctor_Love_Money_Shot

Fri Dec 28, 2012 9:04 am
Lady_Katy wrote:Thanks for bringing this to our attention. We will pull the logs and review accordingly. For the sake of civility, we will deal with the parties involved individually and not on the forums.

Your own moderators told us to stop talking in global chat and discuss this in the forum as it was the proper location for this type of discussion. Are you saying that once again, the mods don't know what they are doing by advising us to take it up here? You see why SO MANY players are so upset with the apparent lack of regulation over the mods. They have free reign to do whatever they want, right or wrong. Something MUST change.
I would like to go on record that no matter the outcome of this situation, the idea of mods is a good one. Being a mod is a thankless, as well ad unpaid, job and respect should be shown for their effort. No one has escaped life's less than shining moments and this in it's entirity is one. We need to trust venan's decision, accept it, and move on to complaining about the poor drop rate. Illanna.

Lady_Katy

Site AdminFri Dec 28, 2012 9:54 am
Doctor_Love wrote:
Lady_Katy wrote:Thanks for bringing this to our attention. We will pull the logs and review accordingly. For the sake of civility, we will deal with the parties involved individually and not on the forums.

Your own moderators told us to stop talking in global chat and discuss this in the forum as it was the proper location for this type of discussion. Are you saying that once again, the mods don't know what they are doing by advising us to take it up here? You see why SO MANY players are so upset with the apparent lack of regulation over the mods. They have free reign to do whatever they want, right or wrong. Something MUST change.

Nope, everyone is okay posting here. I just meant that I'm not going to discuss your personal moderation status with other players :) I didn't want people getting mad since a resolution to this particular issue won't be posted in this thread.