Book of Heroes

Lower potion drops drastically · page 2

Adduced, from another thread:
Romain wrote:With a similar might as Musketeer, I indeed take more damage than my mage but am still selling piles of healing potions, so nothing to worry about.
I agree. This game is simply too easy for high might players. The only time we die is when we become careless or unlucky combo chained by Behemoth. Any other time, add long as you drink pots regularly, you'll never die. And problem is pots come around too easy and doesn't cost much honestly. If making great and powerful these two potions obtainable only thru crafting, then this game would become challenging. Players will become more defensive in order to avoid being hit. Drinking pots is like drinking water in current version and all Previous Version.

I'd like to suggest revising health regen timer completely and replace with additional health regen stat. Like the higher level the more health regen per sec or min. Currently health regen timer of 5 min seems to be useless, at least to me. I never once count on it to recharge my health. Yes it is nice for some free hp when you are away, but consider pots are cheap and come easily, I really don't mind popping couple open.

japster

ModeratorThu Jan 24, 2013 1:06 am
I agree that health pots are still in utter abundance, and extremely cheap to purchase. Like what hai5 suggests, making pots expensive (e.g. crafting), as well as limiting its drop rate to only (for example) dungeon bosses will certainly force a more prudent style of game play to give players real options as to whether they rather play defensive and kill slowly, or go really offensive and take the hits and spend money on potions.

I would go so far as to say, please remove the greater and powerful healing pots from the temple!
Interesting observations and ideas :) Let me sketch out a possible tier system based on the discussion thus far.

Small: drops, Temple
Medium: drops, Temple (lower frequency)
Large: Temple, crafting
Powerful: crafting only

Something like that, maybe?

In an auction house sometime in the far future, perhaps we'll see a market for crafted powerful health potions. The ingredients would be found in challenging zones, but not challenging enough for the players who want them, so lower-level players could work as gatherers and alchemists to make extra cash...
If you want to see my anti-crafting rant, look in the 1.5 preview threads. Crafting consumables is a boring, waste of time and makes RPG games significantly less fun. Fortunately, I consider the craftable items not worth the time and completely unnecessary currently so it is not bothering me.

NO, NO, NO, NO, NO to crafting health potions!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Doctor Love doesn't have narcolepsy just exhaustion - he just spent way too much time playing BoH instead of sleeping like a normal person. :lol:
Bbbb wrote:Crafting consumables is a boring, waste of time and makes RPG games significantly less fun.
I completely agree, which is why I wasn't the one to suggest it, and which is also why I'd never do it. ;)

But why would anyone suggest such a thing? Because potions are so ridiculously common that people want to take drastic measures to curb what they see as a major balance issue.

Something has to be done about the potion problem. And it is a problem, and it's not just a problem at extremely high might levels. I experienced the problem when I rejoined BoH at ~12k might, and I still have the problem now at ~150% of that. The issue of potion excess hasn't become appreciably worse: that is to say, it wasn't significantly better at a much lower might. It's not a class issue, either: my mage and justicar alts have gone from 10k to ~14k in the same time period, and they pile up even more potions, because I play them more carefully. But that's because I'm less comfortable with them, not because I need to conserve resources. I don't. I never do. I could fill swimming pools.

As Hai so very frankly said:
SAO_SwordArtOnline wrote:Drinking pots is like drinking water in current version and all Previous Version...

...pots are cheap and come easily, I really don't mind popping couple open.
If I may be "devil's advocate", anyone who would prefer to see fewer potion drops could simply ignore them, let your stash reach 99, and let the potions drops bounce off your full backpack. My potion supplies always hover in the 90's, and like many of the VG-level raiders, I like to maximize my kills while minimizing damage taken. I don't need the added incentive of HAVING to do this because of scarce healing potions.

For the casual player, like my wife, who enjoys following the plot line and progressing in quests, and whose objective is not to squeeze every last encounter out of a health bar before drinking a healing potion, having accessible healing potions makes the game more enjoyable.

Remember that progression to the highest levels of this game still relies on a raiding community, and alienating the casual, non-optimizing characters may hasten the games death.