Book of Heroes

Lower potion drops drastically

I've recently noticed more than one person claiming, dismissively, that BoH requires no skill to play. I've also noticed that these same people tend to complain about the cost of buying potions. I find that incongruous, but apparently they don't, so let's see if they make the connection when their troubles grow worse.

Right off the bat, eliminate all potion drops from animals and viles. Animals can't drink them and viles probably have different physiology. (I admit it's possible to conceive of undead having carried them prior to reanimation.) Next, the Temple should be the only source for powerful healing potions and cleansing potions. And goblins are tiny; they should never carry anything but small healing potions, if those. Basically, make supplies scavenged off the battlefield less than an ideal choice, as they should be.

The following types of characters will suffer:

1. the incompetent
2. the unprepared
3. the careless
4. the unlucky
5. the poor

No one can do anything about 4, 5 will just have to play more until they're no longer 5, and 1, 2, and 3 deserve all the misery they get. How about it?
They have already dropped the potion rates. I find them fine currently.

I'm still unhappy that you convinced them to remove health regen while in a zone. It is annoying when I am gone for hours and forgot to leave one and come back to no health.

Disagree 10,000%.
Well, this is a point on which we'll have to disagree, Beebs. I still need to sell off about a dozen powerful healing potions per character every day to keep from running into the 99 per item limit.

Potions should be an expenditure, in my opinion, not a source of additional silver.
I have to agree with Marney here. I have to use potions now, sometimes quite a few, if I prefer to move carelessly fast, but the number I get from drops still exceeds the expenditure.. This devaluates the idea of having potions, actually.. However, in order to help new players, I would suggest to leave current drop rates for small and, possibly, medium potions, but to decrease them for large and powerful.. The latter should be very rare.

Doctor_Love_Money_Shot

Wed Jan 23, 2013 5:00 am
The amount of silver gained from selling pots is negligible in my opinion. I never viewed it as a significant source of silver farming. Just something to sell so my bags didn't fill up. I agree the drop rates are fine where they are. Oh, and since when does a game ever take into account realistic scenarios when considering what mobs might actually be carrying or drinking or whatever. Maybe we should consider making the lights go dark at night time and the monsters might trip and fall on my sword while wandering about aimlessly because it's so dark in the woods? But I could have night vision goggles to see them. Or maybe I just need to carry a fleshlight?

What I would like to see more is rune rates increased again. I could care less about the minor runes. What I want is major runes. Currently you have to spend 20e in LoB and GK to get a single rune. This is essentially worthless to me as I can't run more than half a dozen dungeons a day with our raid schedule. Or just let us buy the major runes in the temple already. Give us something else to spend our silver on that can actually have value other than the Alchemist lockbox which is mostly worthless now that the GS drop rates are laughable.

I also agree with Bbbb on the issue of discontinuing health regen while in a zone. I too have had plenty of times where I forgot to leave a zone or raid, just to come back and find I have almost no health. Or, the nasty glitch strikes that saps all my health down to zero while my device is asleep. I can understand not having health regen while a player is actively fighting. But if the player steps away for let's say 10 mins or 30 mins or whatever amount is deemed reasonable, let the health begin to regen again. This will keep players from using this regularly as a way to survive a dungeon, but not punish people who just forgot to leave a zone, or maybe fell asleep while raiding on the pot or something.
Doctor_Love wrote:The amount of silver gained from selling pots is negligible in my opinion. I never viewed it as a significant source of silver farming. Just something to sell so my bags didn't fill up.
Yeah, um, duh. My point isn't that the silver gained from selling potions is excessively generous. My point is that HEALTH POTION INFLOW should not exceed HEALTH POTION OUTFLOW if you're fighting anything remotely close to your level.

If a player wants to heal up and lay in potion stocks, his first thought should be "Gee, I should go to the Temple," not "I need to kill more critters!"
Doctor_Love wrote:Oh, and since when does a game ever take into account realistic scenarios when considering what mobs might actually be carrying or drinking or whatever.
You're right! You're so right! That's why I keep finding Black Wyvern Scales when I kill the Cave Serpent, and Alpha Wolf Paws when I kill Steelclaw!

Oh wait...

But seriously, a certain level of abstraction in monster drops is necessary and good. For example, I don't mind the silver drops because I can easily imagine that we're taking bits of useable stuff from the viles, weapons or armor or scrap metal, and selling it to Majerio for use in the war effort. Animals may have furs, etc.

However, potion drops are quite different. Gaining potions during a raid could have an impact on your RPP, assuming you would have run out without the drops. (One of the players I cited in my original post did claim that he can go through an entire stack of 99 in a single raid.) That has gameplay impact, and I don't see why incompetent players should be coddled.
Doctor_Love wrote:What I would like to see more is rune rates increased again... (snip)
Then make your own thread to discuss that.
Doctor_Love wrote:I also agree with Bbbb on the issue of discontinuing health regen while in a zone.
That decision was taken here. Please discuss it there, or make a new thread.
Doctor_Love wrote:This will keep players from using this regularly as a way to survive a dungeon, but not punish people who just forgot to leave a zone, or maybe fell asleep while raiding on the pot or something.
Uh, first of all, ew.

Second, please see a doctor about your narcolepsy. You could injure yourself seriously in that situation.
Grnm wrote:However, in order to help new players, I would suggest to leave current drop rates for small and, possibly, medium potions, but to decrease them for large and powerful.. The latter should be very rare.
Yes, that sounds like a good cutoff point. By the time players have gained enough levels to use large and powerful potions without wasting any healing, they should definitely know what they're doing.
My thoughts are, health shouldn't regenerate in a fight but in a zone, so lets say you burned all your energy in a raid, waiting that 5minutes for your energy to regen your health should be provided there are no active enemies you are engaged with, that's my two cents.

Potions I think could be nerfed down but I think they should be craftable and potentially be able to spend energy to "harvest" herbs or ores from various locations?
I like the idea of crafting health potions, especially now that we have ingredient drops for buff potions already. :) Gathering/mining is a bit obvious, but I guess that could work too.