I don't know, I suppose we can all just agree to disagree with you sinphil.
I still feel like the whole point of a speed raid event was to see how fast a raid could be completed. And like I've already stated multiple times, the whole point of any community event is to foster the community together and I think it excelled in those two purposes. I had, hands down, the most fun I've had since starting BoH last month. I made a lot of friends, and took place in a lot of fun, speed raids. The prizes were nice, but more important to me was the achievement and the people met. I can now count myself among the fastest CoC and SC raiders
I see how the event was unfair to lower-level players, and while I totally understand the resentment, events can't cater to an entire community as we discovered with the last one. The leveling drawing for gold shields was clearly geared towards newer players or older players who wish to try new characters out. No event can ever be completely fair, and when a loophole exists, it tends to be exploited. It's through that "exploitation" that the game becomes progressively "fairer" like the whole haste potion nerf from a while back.
Will I be sad if the next speed raid is limited to guild-only? no, not at all... I'll enjoy the event for what it is. But it doesn't change the fact that this event will remain in my memory as one of my favorite BoH moments. It's something I can reflect on later and be like "haha... I can't believe we finished that raid in three minutes..."