Book of Heroes

Speed Run Event · page 9

Little_Mike

Site AdminMon Mar 11, 2013 7:27 pm
Even though there were obvious issues with the contest due to our current limitations with guilds, it has provided some good information for us. We hope that if we do run this event again after 1.6 comes out, players will compete for the raids in their proper might tier.
Little_Mike wrote:Even though there were obvious issues with the contest due to our current limitations with guilds, it has provided some good information for us. We hope that if we do run this event again after 1.6 comes out, players will compete for the raids in their proper might tier.
Little_Mike wrote:Even though there were obvious issues with the contest due to our current limitations with guilds, it has provided some good information for us. We hope that if we do run this event again after 1.6 comes out, players will compete for the raids in their proper might tier.

The issue was not with Venan, and you tried to provide a level playing field by creating pools based on existing guild standings according to existing roster. Players should not need to be told changing an entire team in a pool event is considered cheating in every sport and gaming competition in world. It's not rocket science to be told that ringing in a team of pro ball players into a college division is cheating. That putting a group 1 horse into a group 5 event in another horses racing colors is cheating. Is a very big difference between filling a few spots in team with replacements and substituting entire roster.
Thank you Venan for effort you put in, it was a great idea and no doubt will improve after teething problems that not your fault. This is a game you shouldn't have to write a rule book every event just to get people to play fair especially on something this painfully obvious.
Hello, for the speed run 'dark helion' the guild members from fallen swords were never sent any rewards! Thank you, SniperBms

Little_Mike

Site AdminMon Mar 11, 2013 9:19 pm
Sniper_bms wrote:Hello, for the speed run 'dark helion' the guild members from fallen swords were never sent any rewards! Thank you, SniperBms

Only players that participated in the event will receive rewards. Even if you are in the guild, if you were not in that particular raid, you will not receive rewards. If you think there is still an error, please send us a customer support email and we will look into it.
Sinphil wrote:
The issue was not with Venan, and you tried to provide a level playing field by creating pools based on existing guild standings according to existing roster. Players should not need to be told changing an entire team in a pool event is considered cheating in every sport and gaming competition in world. It's not rocket science to be told that ringing in a team of pro ball players into a college division is cheating. That putting a group 1 horse into a group 5 event in another horses racing colors is cheating. Is a very big difference between filling a few spots in team with replacements and substituting entire roster.

And when did raiding become a sporting event -_-

On any given day, I do maybe 2 GK raids and anywhere from 6-12 CoC raids (13.5k might). If I had to choose, I'd say the raid my character is built best for is onslaught... aka... CoC. Therefore, I don't see why its cheating for me to want to participate in "my" raid as opposed to in a raid for my might level that i'm barely qualified and not built for.

Atleast with the onslaught raids, its a small group of like minded individuals from a host of different high level guilds that enjoy doing CoC. Our guilds themselves rarely run them, so we have to merc for them occassionally.

If anything, the main reason I liked this so much was not for the guild loyalty, but for the mixing of players and guilds. I see and interact with my guild daily. It's a rare opportunity that I get to go raid with multiple high level players from multiple guilds...
Oda_tennischamp5 wrote:
Sinphil wrote:
The issue was not with Venan, and you tried to provide a level playing field by creating pools based on existing guild standings according to existing roster. Players should not need to be told changing an entire team in a pool event is considered cheating in every sport and gaming competition in world. It's not rocket science to be told that ringing in a team of pro ball players into a college division is cheating. That putting a group 1 horse into a group 5 event in another horses racing colors is cheating. Is a very big difference between filling a few spots in team with replacements and substituting entire roster.

And when did raiding become a sporting event -_-

On any given day, I do maybe 2 GK raids and anywhere from 6-12 CoC raids (13.5k might). If I had to choose, I'd say the raid my character is built best for is onslaught... aka... CoC. Therefore, I don't see why its cheating for me to want to participate in "my" raid as opposed to in a raid for my might level that i'm barely qualified and not built for.

Atleast with the onslaught raids, its a small group of like minded individuals from a host of different high level guilds that enjoy doing CoC. Our guilds themselves rarely run them, so we have to merc for them occassionally.

If anything, the main reason I liked this so much was not for the guild loyalty, but for the mixing of players and guilds. I see and interact with my guild daily. It's a rare opportunity that I get to go raid with multiple high level players from multiple guilds...

As said any sporting or gaming contest. Try switching places with someone in ranked poker tournament and see what happens. Is same principal, you are ranked by your skill level and by switching out team and bringing in mass of high players you are cheating the whole ranking system. If you can't understand such basic principal you clearly justifying your actions and in denial. And please you can't tell me level 30s with 20k might regularly do squires honor raids. The rules clearly tiered players by highest raid they do and people cheated by moving entire guilds into shell of a much lower guild. You took away prizes from noobs and kids no matter how you try justify it to yourselves. Wonder how players displaced to make room feel about been used like they have been and just finding out their promised rewards aren't coming.
Sinphil wrote:
And please you can't tell me level 30s with 20k might regularly do squires honor raids. The rules clearly tiered players by highest raid they do and people cheated by moving entire guilds into shell of a much lower guild. You took away prizes from noobs and kids no matter how you try justify it to yourselves. Wonder how players displaced to make room feel about been used like they have been and just finding out their promised rewards aren't coming.

Firstly, I know at least half a dozen level 30s with 20k might that regularly do CoC... It happens to be one of the quickest ways to obtain hero training in the game... Secondly, the whole premise of merc-ing (which thus far is supported by Venan) is to hop around guild to guild to do raids that either your own guild doesn't do or isn't doing. Yes, I was part of the group that completed CoC and SC in the fastest times, but because I have 13.5k might, it's cheating? That means any CoC I take part in throughout the normal day to help out smaller guilds is cheating :/ Thirdly, I took prizes away from no one. I earned 2k hero training and 2k knights valor from taking part in a well-planned, brilliantly executed raid. There's no need to justify anything... both the hero training and the knights valor I can use. 1/3 of my gems are still T3 (soldier-tier), My armor is still T10 (also soldier-tier)...

This being said, I do understand your bitterness as it does feel unfair for a group of high level players to jump into a dead/dying guild and complete a raid in the fastest time. However, venan has said 1.6 will see the arrival of guild-specific events, so none of that should happen. It was a speed run event, not a guild loyalty event. However, the point of this event was speed -> to see the absolute fastest times these raids can be completed. And I think that was accomplished pretty well. Also, I don't necessarily understand the prizes I took away from you that you "deserved"... For all the speed raids I took part in, we announced them via global chat atleast 30-45 minutes in advance, and kept announcing it. Anyone who wanted could join, of any might. Even with all those that joined, the two I was in still had space for more...this wasn't some secret new player witch hunt.
... Wo kann ich mich denn mal in deutsch auskotzen?
Ich kann und will nicht nachvollziehen, warum die Zeit bei Vallus nicht gezählt wird. Ich hab ePots, wie andere auch, in diesem Fight verbraucht und die Zusammensetzung der Gilde war zum Großteil total unterschiedlich. Und jetzt bekommen die, die nicht genug Macht haben gar nichts, nur weil die, die sowiieso größer sind jetzt belohnt werden....

Super tolles Event, wofür ich ja noch mal Geld ausgebe... /Ironie off
Oda_tennischamp5 wrote:
Sinphil wrote:
And please you can't tell me level 30s with 20k might regularly do squires honor raids. The rules clearly tiered players by highest raid they do and people cheated by moving entire guilds into shell of a much lower guild. You took away prizes from noobs and kids no matter how you try justify it to yourselves. Wonder how players displaced to make room feel about been used like they have been and just finding out their promised rewards aren't coming.

Firstly, I know at least half a dozen level 30s with 20k might that regularly do CoC... It happens to be one of the quickest ways to obtain hero training in the game... Secondly, the whole premise of merc-ing (which thus far is supported by Venan) is to hop around guild to guild to do raids that either your own guild doesn't do or isn't doing. Yes, I was part of the group that completed CoC and SC in the fastest times, but because I have 13.5k might, it's cheating? That means any CoC I take part in throughout the normal day to help out smaller guilds is cheating :/ Thirdly, I took prizes away from no one. I earned 2k hero training and 2k knights valor from taking part in a well-planned, brilliantly executed raid. There's no need to justify anything... both the hero training and the knights valor I can use. 1/3 of my gems are still T3 (soldier-tier), My armor is still T10 (also soldier-tier)...

This being said, I do understand your bitterness as it does feel unfair for a group of high level players to jump into a dead/dying guild and complete a raid in the fastest time. However, venan has said 1.6 will see the arrival of guild-specific events, so none of that should happen. It was a speed run event, not a guild loyalty event. However, the point of this event was speed -> to see the absolute fastest times these raids can be completed. And I think that was accomplished pretty well. Also, I don't necessarily understand the prizes I took away from you that you "deserved"... For all the speed raids I took part in, we announced them via global chat atleast 30-45 minutes in advance, and kept announcing it. Anyone who wanted could join, of any might. Even with all those that joined, the two I was in still had space for more...this wasn't some secret new player witch hunt.

I am not bitter or low level player. I was invited to join two of these migrations but declined because it stank of poor gamesmanship. Again as stated is a big difference between recruiting mercs as replacements and to fill up spaces, it is a totally different matter to replace majority of guild with members from much higher guilds. The point you chose to overlook is normal play the guilds are not broken into tiers, in the event the guilds were carefully pooled by skill standards and the mass migration was a clear attempt to bypass the whole point of creating tiered pools to give low players a chance, a chance you took away from them. Also as clearly stated the competition was targeted for your highest raid level not your farming level or your favorite level so again your argument holds no water. The rules were clearly circumvented even though rules clearly showed intentions. Even the VENAN comment earlier makes it clear that the mass migrations clearly against spirit of event, spirit made clear in rules. The fact you need a rule book written for event just so you know what fair play is is very sad.
Also you quote the message about 1.6, did you not also see the acknowledgement that players were not competing in correct might tiers as planned and that you have forced them to make changes to event to prevent it happening again before is run again????
Just don't complain if mercing is totally nerfed after this event because a cool down between changing guilds is usual solution to this in most games. So when we can't merc in future don't blame venan look in mirror and blame your attempts to get around clear intent of rules.