Book of Heroes

Speed Run Event · page 11

Once again in daily raids there are no limits placed on raid you choose but in event it was very clearly stated a guild only eligible to do the highest tier of valor they completed. This was the method used to pool guilds. To try justify the mass migration in event by raids normally done is fundamentally flawed as is comparing it to normal mercing. I have given numerous sporting and gaming examples where this type of player substitution is considered cheating yet not one of the people hating me have come up with single game or sport where it is acceptable. I done debating point, if you seriously can't see difference between mercs in normal play and moving guilds into a low tier shell or displacing members of feeder guilds in a skill based pool event. If you can't see that it is fundamentally bad gamesmanship then I am wasting my time.
Sinphil wrote:Once again ...

Yeah, again and again. It took you 8 messages in this thread to try to prove your point, but still there are people here who dare not to share your opinion. Ingrats and cheaters, perhaps not worth preaching.

Actually, you made your point and it was heard, and it was not totally without merits. Its just quite exaggerated and full of rightful anger (?) which neither the topic nor the participants deserve. And at some point Venan said that 1.6 will rework the guilds so that future speedrun events are likely to be more like what you (and many others) want them to be. So what was the point in pursuing the topic further?

There is nothing wrong about trying to prove your point and if it takes 8 messages, well, no problem. The problem is that at some point you started.. how shall I put it.. lecturing us on, uh, moral issues. This isn't looking good..

Finally, are you absolutely sure you got enough game experience to be able to easily judge whats fair and whats not in this game? Just think of it.

Dont get me wrong, your opinion means as much as mine or everybody else's, but lecturing is indeed a waste of time.
Grnm wrote:
Sinphil wrote:Once again ...

Yeah, again and again. It took you 8 messages in this thread to try to prove your point, but still there are people here who dare not to share your opinion. Ingrats and cheaters, perhaps not worth preaching.

Actually, you made your point and it was heard, and it was not totally without merits. Its just quite exaggerated and full of rightful anger (?) which neither the topic nor the participants deserve. And at some point Venan said that 1.6 will rework the guilds so that future speedrun events are likely to be more like what you (and many others) want them to be. So what was the point in pursuing the topic further?

There is nothing wrong about trying to prove your point and if it takes 8 messages, well, no problem. The problem is that at some point you started.. how shall I put it.. lecturing us on, uh, moral issues. This isn't looking good..

Finally, are you absolutely sure you got enough game experience to be able to easily judge whats fair and whats not in this game? Just think of it.

Dont get me wrong, your opinion means as much as mine or everybody else's, but lecturing is indeed a waste of time.

Lol and what is this? Also what does play time or experience have to do with a universally accepted moral position? Should we only listen to people over 30 with 12 months experience and blue eyes now?

Celestial_Cavalier

ModeratorWed Mar 13, 2013 6:56 pm
Seriously guys can we stop this bickering because it will not change the outcome of the speed contest.

Everyone is entitled to his or her own opinion as long as we don't forget civility.
Come on everyone. Can we plz take this a bit more serious? This is serious stuff here. For goodness sake this was a speed run event. Is there anything more important than running a speed run event in BoH. Hellls no. So no more joking around. Thx :)))))))))
I actually agree with sin that the event was flawed and broken from the outset, and I understand the complaint about that.

However, it's a game, and damn the CoC and SC speed runs were FUN!!! Great people raiding and having a great time. For most of us who competed in CoC and SC also ran a few GK and VG's but probably not a lot in lower raids. And IMO not too many of the SV or KV guilds were going to use CoC or SC as their primary run.

Yes it was flawed, but was it bad? I don't think so. We got a few low might toons to the parties and I'm sure they appreciated basking in my glory ... Oops, I mean the awesome raid.

Oh well, lost my train of thought ...
Just a suggestion - may be the guild loyalty can be "enforced" of a kind?

What if there is introduced some new kind of in-game currency, let's call it - "guild entry token" (GET) and one can enter a new guild only by paying one token to enter a new guild of choice? Two free token shall be awarded to player for competing a quest or just reaching lvl.4 (the one you are able to join a guild) and two more free GETs - at lvl.10 - where you decide to join a guild and create a new one. After that GETs can drop from some dungeon bosses at the rate tier.4 gems (gems - NOT shards!) drop from Ice Dragon/Hunter/GK, etc.

Also GETs shall be available for a some amount of GS AND a high amount of captain's valor from Majerio AND from grey market. Thus it will be POSSIBLE to change your guild at any time, but at a cost.

How does this sound?
EJ_Neeeky wrote:Just a suggestion - may be the guild loyalty can be "enforced" of a kind?

What if there is introduced some new kind of in-game currency, let's call it - "guild entry token" (GET) and one can enter a new guild only by paying one token to enter a new guild of choice? Two free token shall be awarded to player for competing a quest or just reaching lvl.4 (the one you are able to join a guild) and two more free GETs - at lvl.10 - where you decide to join a guild and create a new one. After that GETs can drop from some dungeon bosses at the rate tier.4 gems (gems - NOT shards!) drop from Ice Dragon/Hunter/GK, etc.

Also GETs shall be available for a some amount of GS AND a high amount of captain's valor from Majerio AND from grey market. Thus it will be POSSIBLE to change your guild at any time, but at a cost.

How does this sound?

Awful. That's exactly what we don't want. Mithrid had a really good solution over here:
Guild Loyalty - Suggested System

It's about halfway down on the first page.