Book of Heroes

Did VenN get it right this time? · page 3

Im trying to stick with you, Venan...I really am! But this game is now a chore. Please lower the length of these raids to more reasonable numbers or cap it at 60 for Mercs and guild members and get this back pre 1.6 before we all lose our minds!
I find it okish, since silver is standard time, so if you want gold, you need to put extra effort (good coordination, team work, GS etc,) in raid. Gold is possible just hard to get at the moment, Venan sure needs to tune it down a little bit so people dont lose hope on gold.
Hero, thanks for your input, I think I agree mostly. The average player wants the hope of hitting gold enough to strive for it, but maybe not so easy that it is every time. But, the current tuning does not seem to embrace this, if gold is only attainable by the hardcore player, then I think many people will move on. In our modern society people loose interest real quick if there is not some kind of reward/payout. And all it really needs is some adjusting. Lower the waves, leave the caps off, will some guilds profit from this? Probably. But, looking at the CV raids yesterday, most guilds are fielding around 30 players, how often will they slam dunk a raid with 60? And if they do , so what, it's a game. Gold does not have to be unattainable for the average player.
I do want it to be clear. There are two separate issues being discussed here:

1. Raids being way too long in clock time/waves. Venan, please go back to the discussions we had last summer about 6 hour raids. You have repeated the same mistake again.

2. The gold time.

Some people are upset about one, the other or both. For me, it is only 1 that I have an issue with. I want the CV raids back around 1470 waves.

On 2, I am assuming that you all are keeping numbers and will adjust periodically to hit your 25% gold target.

Little_Mike

Site AdminFri May 24, 2013 10:36 am
Just looking at some preliminary numbers, there will probably be a few things we will need to address. However, to comment on the duration of the raids, we balanced for all raids to complete in silver within 2-3 hours. On average, raids are indeed completing within this 2-3 hour time period (some raids even less than 2 hours). The longest raid is averaging about 174 minutes. This doesn't mean that things are perfect, but things are not totally out of whack. In any case, we will gather more data over the weekend and will most likely make adjustments next week. Thanks for your comments!

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorFri May 24, 2013 12:29 pm
On average, raids are indeed completing within this 2-3 hour time period (some raids even less than 2 hours). The longest raid is averaging about 174 minutes. This doesn't mean that things are perfect, but things are not totally out of whack.

I think the point that all of the above people are trying to make is that is the time period itself that is causing people to view their raids as more of a chore than they should be. Honestly, the raid lengths were fine before, if more people turned up then your raid finished that much quicker! People loved the fact that you could finish CK in less than 30 minutes. Please take home the message that people do not like raiding for 2-3 hours. They like ~1hr that can be shortened by organisation and work.

Raising membership within guilds in the end does not mean you run raids together or that (post-raid cap) 100 members turn up to raids - when guilds were 60 members you never got them all turning up to raid together. Most guilds have at least some spread of timezones that players hail from.

Raid caps was the worst for me though and I'm glad that's fixed.
Little_Mike wrote:Just looking at some preliminary numbers, there will probably be a few things we will need to address. However, to comment on the duration of the raids, we balanced for all raids to complete in silver within 2-3 hours. On average, raids are indeed completing within this 2-3 hour time period (some raids even less than 2 hours). The longest raid is averaging about 174 minutes. This doesn't mean that things are perfect, but things are not totally out of whack. In any case, we will gather more data over the weekend and will most likely make adjustments next week. Thanks for your comments!

Average raid length should NOT be your metric. Take the average time for a raid in each guild that runs a particular raid, then average these times. Otherwise, the top guilds that run raids 3 to 5 times as often as other guilds will tilt the averages to appear shorter. The result is that 5-10% of your players experience the shorter than average raids, since they run them often, while the casual raiders experience raids longer than average, and the casual raiders are the ones who least like the long raids.

In the old days, guilds of casual raiders could be bolstered by merc groups who enjoyed the thrill of the rescue. Your merc cap of 10 has ruined this social, community-building aspect of this game.

If you lose the casual raider, you lose those word-of-mouth referrals that yield new GS-spending players, which keep this game thriving.
As there are three raids per valor tier perhaps one raid could be a short one with low payout but could be attained quickly and with low numbers for small guilds and casual gamers, one medium which is easy for big guild but challenging for small guilds wanting that bit more and whenthey have a good number online. keep one longer raid where it is a challenge for a big guild and would need lots of members on at same time or a few e burners, but rewards are slighty higher.
The big guilds would murder the easy raid but as payouts low would they bother, and if they did so what?
...I fail to see the fun of raiding anymore. Part of the fun of being GM was scheduling a variety of raids dependent on activity level. I'd place our VGs at our most active slots, our GKs at our medium activity slots, and fill in the gaps/dead hours with either CV, SV for loyalty, or random CoC/SC runs for onslaught variety.

Now, not only is there nothing setting gk and vg apart anymore than gives any incentive whatsoever to run gk once the guild is vg level, but the damn raids take so long to complete for all but the top couple guilds (we're only ranked 6/7th), that not only can we not run 24/7 raids like we were with merc help, but nor can we barely finish 4/5 CV raids a day (when we were once running 8...). We're a solid guild with 73 "mains"...we golded nearly every CV we ran until yesterday's patch.

Same lengths approximately, same time, same number of players... I was going to make the point last week that equalizing raid numbers around a set number of players is stupid...since it causes cookie cutter raids that all play out the same... but i held my tongue thinking, "venan is smarter than this. If they're equalizing player counts for raids, the diversity must come in the form of lengths. Raid A will take 40 people for gold but be 500 waves and 25 minutes long, while Raid B will take 40 people for gold but be 1500 waves and 95 minutes long, while Raid C will take 40 people for gold but be 2500 waves and take 165 minutes long."

But nope, guess I was wrong.


Maybe the strategy is that you've milked enough out of the current community, and a new wide-spread recruiting campaign on your part will bring in plenty of fresh blood willing to burn more on this game. Because more and more, that's what it's seeming like.