Book of Heroes

Did VenN get it right this time? · page 4

As I may quit BoH based on the direction it is heading, I figured I’d finally drop my two cents.

Let us begin with the very system the game is entirely dependent on, raids. In which it was said all raid can achieve gold without shielding. Taking VG as an example during 1.6 update, the maths required to achieve gold without spending gold shields is based on:

1) Maximum 40 cap raiders joining the raid the moment it is started.
2) All 40 raiders have maximum Guild Loyalty.
3) All 40 raiders returns immediately after energy regeneration.

The maths behind this:

Number of waves = 2,010 (Thanks to Denominatrix!)
Number of energy required = 2,010 * 2, = 4,020e
Number of energy per raider = 4,020e / 40 (raiders), = 100.5e
Time required for energy regeneration = (100.5 – 50) / 2 * 5 (minutes), = 126.25 minutes, = 2 hours 6 minutes 15 seconds
Time required for gold = 2 hours 5 minutes

Assuming the 0.5e per raider is ignored, only then will the VG raid achieve gold without shielding. Which means the number of waves for VG should only be 2,000 waves but so far, most reports more than 2,000. Which means, there is still some shielding required.

There is at no point this game should not generate revenue for its creators, however the manner in which this was executed and being executed is less than appealing. We as players are being forced to spend in order to have any sense of achievement for our guild and the game.

We were told that the raid wave adjustments are based on data gathered from the game but judging from the maths above, it does not seem much thought was put into it. Here are the few reason why:

1) Rarely do raids reach maximum cap raiders the moment the raid begins.
2) The number of players with maximum Guild Loyalty is still few and far between.
3) Rarely do all raiders return to dump.

Considering the pointers above are not unknown to the developers, it goes to question the manner in which these new wave numbers were even implemented. Moreover, the reason gold, silver and bronze were introduced in the first place was because guilds were having trouble completing the raids on time. (Was told by someone but can’t recall his name. So here’s a reference to you if you know who you are!) With these new wave numbers, we have gone back to square one. What will be next on the raid medals? Platinum? Titanium?

BoH is based on a Freemium platform with IAP and therefore should be playable without a single dime being spent to achieve all goals in the game. Only tougher (more time consuming, more effort, etc) but not impossible! The new maths not only seeks to ostracise freemium players but also the heavy purchasers as they are finding it more and more difficult to keep achieving gold raids (not only it is more time consuming but also more dedicated effort is required). This is detrimental to BoH since it is a community based game.

Since this post is already getting lengthy, I will get straight to the point:

(a) The wave numbers needs to be reviewed. With the participation cap now removed, it should ease the raid burden however this is under the assumption that all 100 raiders are able to join the raid. But the merc participation is capped, most of these might ready players are scattered between guilds and no one is awake 24/7.

(b) Limit the guild numbers based on playerbase. The issue for failing raids is due to lack of participation. For a time the guilds survived with mercs but as more guilds popped up unchecked from the Kabam initiative, the mercs were spread thin. Therefore leading to the cascade effect of players leaving due to raid failures and dying guilds.

(c) Remove merc cap. See pointer (a).

(d) Consider the psychological aspect of the game. When a game like BoH is based on and highly dependent on community and social interaction, the effect on the playerbase community has a cascading result. Be it a positive or negative effect. Therefore, before any changes is implemented, please consider the risks involved to losing the playerbase.

I do apologise should my post offend anyone as it is not my intention.

Two cents donated.
The social aspect was what built this game. Now it is starting to feel like work. A lot of people play to get away from work, stress, etc. and to socialize. You offer bigger guild #s, we rejoice. We can connect with friends we've made going back to GG. Then you cap raids. We complain about the caps because we have been in our guilds, on the outside of a capped raid, and felt like a kid looking through the window of a candy store that was closed. Your solution is to remove the caps and we rejoice. Great, it'll be fixed and all is forgiven. Then you greatly increase the waves and say you can merc only 10. The shame is, even if its not your intention, it looks like a $$$ grab. Remember it's a social game, but we don't have time to chat because of the increased waves. And because the raids are so long, we log off right after because lots of real life stuff happens during those multiple-hour raids that we have to tend to. You are gonna lose us if you don't fix it. I miss relaxed raids and the banter. That's what puts people in a spending mood.

Poppa out
Little_Mike wrote:Just looking at some preliminary numbers, there will probably be a few things we will need to address. However, to comment on the duration of the raids, we balanced for all raids to complete in silver within 2-3 hours. On average, raids are indeed completing within this 2-3 hour time period (some raids even less than 2 hours). The longest raid is averaging about 174 minutes. This doesn't mean that things are perfect, but things are not totally out of whack. In any case, we will gather more data over the weekend and will most likely make adjustments next week. Thanks for your comments!


This weekend, being a double valor weekend, is going to throw up non-standard raid attendance. It's also a holiday weekend in the US. You need to take a larger sample, over a couple of weeks.

I remember the six hour raids. Those nearly killed me, and certainly reduced my enjoyment of the game. 2-3 hours seems a breeze in comparison.
I think the biggest complaint at this point is - Raids are more of a chore than fun. No one wants a 3 hour raid. Reduce the time for gold, or reduce the rewards, but give us shorter raids.

Also, I may be cynical, but basing your raid data on a holiday weekend, with double loyalty, and the energy pots from the new quests... I wonder which way the data will slant :/

LUNABELLA

ModeratorSat May 25, 2013 5:50 am
Data from special events must be excluded. That means no quick fix. I wonder what is the timeline, if there is a fix (at all) I guess it won't happen before Friday next week. Devs please bring back 1.5. Recruit about 100 players of different might as testers & have them running whatever you want to for a month. It will give you much better data as the average guilds are not as homogeneous as the top 5 guilds. So please stop factoring in the top 5 guilds, stop trying to make life more difficult for them because that just makes it unbearably impossible for the rest. I understand probably the top 5 guilds include your best buyers and you want to provide incentives for them to buy more. Making the game be a pain & not fun should not be the way. You are killing it for the rest of us. The promise of a fix for 1.6 kept us waiting and hoping, it is frustrating that you think you have done it right and it is also frustrating that you need to now collect data out of this mess to provide a fix that may or may not happen, and worst of all, seeing how 1.6.1 is even worse than 1.6, I have lost faith that next fix will even be a fix, now I fear it will make it even worse!!!!
I have to chime in now. Thank you Venan for trying to appease this herd of cats you have here, and here is my 2¢. Yes raids are longer, but those of you that complain about having to commit 2-4 hrs to your device and this game must love to watch paint dry also. Your energy regens at the same rate whether you are watching it or not. Dump your 42-50e come back in an hour and dump what has regenned. You have achieved the same rpp with 10 mins of dedicated time as you would have if you sat on your device burning e as it regenned. So, unless you are burning shields/pots in a 2-4 hr raid you only need to commit ~30 mins of RL time to it. I know what you are thinking..."but I want my easy gold finish or I feel like I have wasted my time". My thoughts are, Venan made it too easy to get gold in the first place, and now that it is hard to do people want to whine. Raids used to be succeed or fail. Can Venan balance the game to where everyone is happy AND they make money.....IMPOSSIBLE. The shear variety of player personalities in this game make that an unachievable goal. I feel they are doing what they can to make the majority of players happy and make mistakes doing it. Such is life get over it. Venan has never (IMO) let this game down in terms of trying to appease us. My guild is only a top 60 guild and silver finishes with the occasional gold are the norm. I have been playing BoH for over a year now and still enjoy it. Thank you Venan....rant over

LUNABELLA

ModeratorSat May 25, 2013 11:36 am
Hey cristo, you play with one toon only right? I have To empty 3 To help my guild, try 4 PR 5 like some do and then you let me know about regen and stuff. And btw even with one toon you won't help a raid finish in time if you disappear for 1h50 till your e is full, you are actually helping the raid take 3 hours.
Actually I have 5, and all are from 12000-19000 might.I run all of them in all guild raids. I should have clarified, I sit on raids almost the entire time but I am the GM so I feel it is my responsibility to do so. Do I need to do that? No, I could burn through all 5 toons e in 30 mins, leave come backin 30 burn through in 5-10 mins then repeat until raid is done.
All true. But what about the guild of 25? Screw them? Ok raid times are terrible but it's ok. I would prefer the suggestion someone made of a short medium and long duration raid but ok. All raids are to be 2-3 hours. I get it. Silver is now the normal and gold the exception. Ok, I'm good with that. But a guild of 25 toons can't finish any raid but gobblins? Why can't raid waves be balanced with the guild members?