Book of Heroes

Did VenN get it right this time? · page 6

Patch 1.6.2

Venan: We've listened to feedback and made raids shorter!
Players: OMG raids are done before I get a chance to log in! I have a real life! Give me time to log in and help my guild! You are so greedy! We can't get enough people online quick enough to meet Gold and we have to burn!! What about small guilds?!?!?!
Venan: ...



Patch 1.6.3

Venan: All raids are gold with no time limits. Happy?
Players: OMG no one wants to let mercs in anymore waaaahhhh!! Mercs are not needed, the community is dead forever! Why even play anymore!?!!?
Venan: ...



:roll:
I think most people would be happy with a reversion to the way 1.5 handled raids and if Venan just made gold harder to get.
Bbbb wrote:I think most people would be happy with a reversion to the way 1.5 handled raids and if Venan just made gold harder to get.

The only difference that I can think of now is more waves and less mercs.

So you want to go back to 1.5 but make gold harder. To make gold harder you create more waves and/or limit participation. Which is what they did. And they upped the rewards and energy pools to help compensate some.

So I don't think that's true. People actually want Gold to be easier and they want to be free to rely on mercenaries more.

The prevailing mindset is still "Gold = Success; Anything else = Complete and utter failure, lets just go back to CK for the rest of our lives".

The mindset that Venan wants and has indirectly said they wanted is that Silver is okay; it's the norm. That's why we now get greater rewards from Silver.

The problem with Venan's image it's that infuriating to win anything less than Gold if you have spent real money on the raid. It's even more infuriating if that is the accepted norm.

As long as Gold is available but out of reach to the average player/guild, they aren't going to be very happy about it if they are trying everything they can and Gold always remains elusive. Unhappy players don't really enjoy themselves.

From what I can tell, THAT is the problem.
AoW_McLovin wrote:
Bbbb wrote:I think most people would be happy with a reversion to the way 1.5 handled raids and if Venan just made gold harder to get.


The only difference that I can think of now is more waves and less mercs.

So you want to go back to 1.5 but make gold harder. To make gold harder you create more waves and/or limit participation. Which is what they did. And they upped the rewards and energy pools to help compensate some.

So I don't think that's true. People actually want Gold to be easier and they want to be free to rely on mercenaries more.

The prevailing mindset is still "Gold = Success; Anything else = Complete and utter failure, lets just go back to CK for the rest of our lives".

The mindset that Venan wants and has indirectly said they wanted is that Silver is okay; it's the norm. That's why we now get greater rewards from Silver.

The problem with Venan's image it's that infuriating to win anything less than Gold if you have spent real money on the raid. It's even more infuriating if that is the accepted norm.

As long as Gold is available but out of reach to the average player/guild, they aren't going to be very happy about it if they are trying everything they can and Gold always remains elusive. Unhappy players don't really enjoy themselves.

From what I can tell, THAT is the problem.

What about simply reducing the time for gold to be reached ? That way we can still have casual under 3 hour silver raids.
Contingency wrote:I miss when raiding was fun rather than stressful.


This just about sums it up.
They could make the Gold, Silver, Bronze classification go away and just go with a flat Raid Timer and progressivly decaying rewards. In other words, if you complete a raid faster you get more valor, without a cutoff time. For example, lets say Kraken raid: the raid end timer might be 1h 15 minutes, if your guild finishes in 55 minues they would recieve a better RPP to Valor conversion than a raid that finished in 56 minutes, even if its just a slight difference, but that would scale through the whole timer for each minute of the raid duration, no matter how many participants there are. No more worrying about gold timers. Then all they need to do is set the End timer for a decent length, decide if they want to impliment raid caps or merc caps (I would think 25% to 50% merc cap would be sufficient, any guild needing more than 50% to be mercs needs to go back to earlier raids and increase Might) and then make it work. They could even add the "Challenge Mode" to the raids to allow a tougher challenge for the higher guilds, and to grant other rewards.

Removing those raids (FS and SC) wasn't really nessicary, but I get why they did it. Why leave a pair of raids that only 1 or 2 guilds tries to raid when they can just change the Might level for a different raid and keep everyone in the same 3 instead of spreading out to the ones no one really likes.

I don't think the social aspect is broken. It's not the same as it was, but Global chat and Whispers still work, as does the ability to talk to a guild you are mercing with. Add your friends to friends list with Hero codes and keep in touch, don't be lazy if you really care about staying in touch.

Venan has done a decent job improving the game as far as I can tell. There are a few tweeks here and there I would hope they impliment soon, like changes to the raid times and payouts, but having been a gamer for most of my life, I know that all we can do is hope. There is no guarantee that they will listen to what we want, even if we see it as the right way.
As Bbbb has said...and is the simplest solution...give the consumers what they want...1.5 raid length in current 1.6.1 framework...make gold very hard! (We honestly don't care what you make it) you've also made CK at the knight valor stage unbearable..the reason it was so great was it was over in an hour at most..ppl want a short raid option at each level (currently there are none at CV level) if you set Karnak to 20 ppl (as it was at 1.6) you'd hear a lot less complaints and have more ppl seeing it as a fun challenge.way long ago venan made raids 6 hours...and should have learned their lesson...BUT if they insist on some long raids each valor level needs a shorter raid available..you will find you put the fun of the game right back into it...so to be ABSOLUTELY CLEAR: venan at the CV level

Karnak: waves designed for 20 ppl (1.6)
GK: 1.5 levels or about 30 ppl
VG: 1.5 or about 40 ppl

For smaller guilds of KV and below I'd go back to 1.5 levels and allow these guilds a shot at one day making it up the leader boards instead of stifling them in the current system
AoW_McLovin wrote:Patch 1.6.2

Venan: We've listened to feedback and made raids shorter!
Players: OMG raids are done before I get a chance to log in! I have a real life! Give me time to log in and help my guild! You are so greedy! We can't get enough people online quick enough to meet Gold and we have to burn!! What about small guilds?!?!?!
Venan: ...



Patch 1.6.3

Venan: All raids are gold with no time limits. Happy?
Players: OMG no one wants to let mercs in anymore waaaahhhh!! Mercs are not needed, the community is dead forever! Why even play anymore!?!!?
Venan: ...



:roll:

I know you're trying to be funny but this is beyond ridiculous, and no player thinks along these lines. Here's the point everyone is trying to make, and hopefully it doesn't fall on deaf ears. No one complained about raids in 1.5. They were balanced and fun. Now it just feels like a bunch of button pushing....and if thats what you like then by all means keep defending it and acting like we are all a bunch of idiots for wanting the old gameplay back. I really like most of what Venan has done with the update but the raids still need reworking. This type of long drawn out gameplay is not for most people.
Ferocee wrote:As Bbbb has said...and is the simplest solution...give the consumers what they want...1.5 raid length in current 1.6.1 framework...make gold very hard! (We honestly don't care what you make it) you've also made CK at the knight valor stage unbearable..the reason it was so great was it was over in an hour at most..ppl want a short raid option at each level (currently there are none at CV level) if you set Karnak to 20 ppl (as it was at 1.6) you'd hear a lot less complaints and have more ppl seeing it as a fun challenge.way long ago venan made raids 6 hours...and should have learned their lesson...BUT if they insist on some long raids each valor level needs a shorter raid available..you will find you put the fun of the game right back into it...so to be ABSOLUTELY CLEAR: venan at the CV level

Karnak: waves designed for 20 ppl (1.6)
GK: 1.5 levels or about 30 ppl
VG: 1.5 or about 40 ppl

For smaller guilds of KV and below I'd go back to 1.5 levels and allow these guilds a shot at one day making it up the leader boards instead of stifling them in the current system

Venan tried making it harder. There are two ways of doing so.

Option 1: Raid caps. People raaaaaaaged over this one.
Option 2: Shortened time limits. People raged here.

The problem is people don't want to spend hours on raids that aren't even going to be Gold. So maybe they should reduce time limits and waves and probably cooldowns too since guilds are pretty big now and if you make the raids small mini-events you won't really get to participate very much before its over, particularly in big, active guilds.

Shorter raids more often basically. Worth a shot.