Book of Heroes

Did VenN get it right this time? · page 7

Marcon wrote:I know you're trying to be funny but this is beyond ridiculous, and no player thinks along these lines. Here's the point everyone is trying to make, and hopefully it doesn't fall on deaf ears. No one complained about raids in 1.5. They were balanced and fun. Now it just feels like a bunch of button pushing....and if thats what you like then by all means keep defending it and acting like we are all a bunch of idiots for wanting the old gameplay back. I really like most of what Venan has done with the update but the raids still need reworking. This type of long drawn out gameplay is not for most people.

The point is that people aren't happy even if they get what they ask for and every suggestion on here has a downside that will rub people the wrong way, often the very people who suggested it in the first place, because in general people are pretty bad about anticipating the consequences of their own suggestions.

For the record, I've said multiple times that I want Gold to be easier to attain and my reasoning for why they should make it so. So I'm not defending them. I think their idea that it should be 25/50/25 G/S/B is not very well thought out to be quite honest.
I actually like the idea of doing away with gold/silver/bronze and implementing a decaying rewards system. Just have it decay from like +35-40% to -35-40% depending on time. Scale rewards, prestige, power, etc accordingly.
Fizz_Eric wrote:I actually like the idea of doing away with gold/silver/bronze and implementing a decaying rewards system. Just have it decay from like +35-40% to -35-40% depending on time. Scale rewards, prestige, power, etc accordingly.
Have it be based on time remaining in raid timer. If your raid finishes 30 seconds before the timer ends, you'd get about 50% of the possible reward. The faster you get it done (up to the fastest possible w/out shields or epots) the closer you get to a full 100% reward. And if a few people pop epots and your team gets it done faster than the "Ideal time" your team can recieve more than 100% rewards (depending on how much faster). This would allow fully diciplined guilds to recieve higher rewards and lower or smaller guilds to still finish the raid in their own time and be rewarded accordingly. Not saying indefinate raid timers, but a reasonable end timer so that ~70-80% of all raids can finish based on X number of participants at Minimal e-pools for the level of might required to enter the raid. Nevermind basing the amount of reward on how many participants there are, just reward them for the amount of RPP they achieved. That should be the simplest way to make everyone happy, or the most people happy anyway.
Maybe I don't quite understand what's being suggested, but how does decaying rewards change that raids are long and people are unsatisfied with non gold rewards? Replacing bronze rewards with 30% rewards doesn't seem to address anything unless you JUST missed a reward tier. And I don't think anyone was complaining about that. They just think raids drag on forever and rewards aren't very good for taking long and it's no longer fun. That wouldn't change in decaying rewards.
The sad truth is, there is no easy answer here. I salute Venan for their efforts to make the game fun and challenging. Just jiggering raid times I suspect is never going to work for all because needs are different. Some guilds like to keep things in family so to speak, and not use mercs. Other guilds are all about frequent high attendance raids and welcome mercs.

Perhaps two tiers of raids based on if mercs are allowed in or not might be a starting point. I still don't know all the game mechanics, so I'm just tossing out thoughts. Perhaps a greater disparity in raids with some geared to be shorter, but with a smaller cap.

I think another piece of the puzzle is the guild formation itself. I'd like more thought put into guild recruiting and management. Perhaps look at the median membership per guild, and set the price of starting new guilds higher when the median is low. That way more people might be tempted to look into joining a guild.

Is it perfect now? No. Do I still enjoy the game, yes. Do I think Venan really wants to make the game fun and challenging? Yes. Balancing the dynamics is hard, and I'm willing to let them keep tweaking things a bit more.

Denrael
I think the game sucks now and I came here to tell Venan all about it.

Why balance the game to the top 10 guilds? Venan you have killed the guilds that do not play hardcore. Do you think getting bronze or failing raids is fun? Do you think 4 hour raids are fun? He'll no!

People in my guild (roughly rank 40 in power and prestige) are struggling, they are finding it harder and harder to log on.
Guilds do not want casual players anymore, only the hardcore will survive.

You can pull up the raids and clearly see guilds are not getting the number of players participating. Most raids i see are under 40 players and that includes 10 mercs, most do not stay for the duration of the raid, most do not enter the raids with full e or even half e for that matter, most dont start the raid on time, a lot dump what E they have and then log out never to return.

Why the hell then would you balance your raid waves and guild participation numbers so high then?
Venan has the unenviable task of trying to balance a raid system between "hardcore" guilds that are super high might and spend lots of money regularly, and "casual" guilds that are people who like to play when they have the time and spend money rarely if at all.

Ideally, the balance would be somewhere in the middle. The 1.5 raid system seemed to be well liked by all. All that is except Venan. For some reason they've decided that players thinking Gold finishes are to be expected every raid, every time is a bad thing. They would like most raids to finish silver, with a few gold and bronze. So they retooled to make raids harder.

Now the Hardcore Elite just decided they would spend some more cash, and remain at the top of the game. And they have, without so much as a blip. The casual guilds however have been severely and negatively impacted.

The system can never be balanced. Not the way it is now. There is no way a small guild can compete with large guilds on the same field. There is no way casual gamers can compete with the hardcore.

This system worked only so long as Venan accepted that it was broken. Accepted that raids would not be particularly challenging and that Gold is the standard. So long as this Jihad against easy raids is waged, casual guilds and gamers will fall by the wayside.

Venan must implement a sliding difficulty system as has been proposed on these forums, or just accept that this is a CELL-PHONE game, not an epic MMORPG. It's supposed to be a source of quick fun and interaction, not frustration and disappointment. Please Venan, get over yourselves and make the game fun, light and enjoyable again at the risk of having your raids not falling within your ideal bell curve. Or just give up and go back to Space Miner.

I didn't start out to be critical and harsh, I really didn't. But there it is, my true feelings. Feelings I suspect reflect a lot of your customers. Here's another truth. If I wasn't invested in the game and my guild, I would not be a (paying) customer. You are somewhat insulated against your own bad decisions and ineptness as SO many players are like me. Not wanting to give up all their progress. With so much invested, we are loath to just give up. So you stumble, and you fail, and you don't see your user base declining. So you think things are allright. They are not. Trust me.
While I agree with you, it is a cell phone /tablet game, it shouldnt be as hard as it is, I also understand that without a challenge, no one would enjoy this game. If everyone knew that every raid was always a win with gold, why have silver and bronze? Why even have the raid take more than one person to complete? I do think they need to come up with a way to make it possible for casuals to raid and enjoy the game, even at a lesser level than hardcore players (they are never on the same level as each other in any game, no matter what people tell you) and still provide a challenge for all that is possible to overcome without NEEDING to spend money. I think they are close from what I read on the forums and see in the game, they just need a little fine tuning for the higher raids and the merc system/raid cap issues.
Just to clarify one point. Every raid was NOT guaranteed gold in 1.5. Many times you saw guilds (mostly the smaller ones) with S.O.S. messages in global asking for assistance. It was a challenge to get gold for small and medium guilds, just not for the top tier ones. And this new raid structure is not a challenge for them either.

My point I want to make is Venan appears to be trying to tune to game so that it is more difficult for those high might/top tier guilds. All it is really doing is upsetting and killing off the small ones.
You hit the nail on the head Sadaar, the only reason I haven't left is the people that I play with. The comparison with 1.5 is important because that's when everyone was happy. The raids were fun and SHORT.

Me, personally? I'm a heating and air guy and it's summer. I'm busy. I've been working 7 days and barely have time in the evenings to finish a raid.

Please do something! Make a short medium and long raid or base raid waves on attendance and increase them everytime someone joins. Something, anything!

If you hadn't noticed, those players who are might maxed STILL PLAY. They still raid. You guys need to realize a wee bit of psychology here - gold makes people feel like they accomplished something, hell even pulling off a gold 3 hit gobblins made people happy. When people are happy, they keep playing and spending. I'm just saying, why on earth wouldn't your attitude be to have everyone have gold all the time? I do not consider myself a hardcore player, I set a goal and go after it hard core but I'm not on here but a few hours a day and that's more than a lot of people.

Understand that most of the people that do play this game are adults and as adults 3 hour chunk of time is tough to commit to for a raid.

If you want to come up with true balance numbers? Drop all the numbers from the top 5 guilds and top 10 players and balance the rest.