Crisco, the issue her doesn't seem at all to be gold finishes but just finishes in general. Why couldn't there be raids that have 1hr silver times ? You can make gold 20 min or whatever. Sometimes a short raid is more fun than long raid. Sometimes someone can start a raid and never come back to help due to rl issues. Gold is not the issue here just the length of the raids. Have you ever wondered why sc , fs, anf wof were not run very often ?
Did VenN get it right this time? · page 5
I agree we aren't asking that gold is easy but since the patch my guild has completed ck once... we used to get silver most times. Gold every once in a while but never failed. We've failed probably 8 of 9... that isn't fun and a lot of people are frustrated.
My two cents. We are a top 50 guild barely. But we are spread over different countries. We have Canadians Americans British German and Australians. You think all of us can be on together. Never happens. We have 78 active members. Longest inactive right now is 3 days. Not one raid have we had 30 of us on at the same time. To crisco who says dump your e. leave and come back. Great idea. That's why I play this game to push buttons. Who cares if no one chats anymore. Not part of the game I guess.
1-2 hour raids were great. Once your over two hours it's a pain.
Second point. Is the merc limit. There were about 5-10 of us in our guild who would head out and "rescue raids" during our off times. It was a great way to meet people and build relationships with others which kept us coming back for more. I like the idea of a 60 limit cap but balance it in that for gold times max Mercs at 10 once gold failed you can add another 10 to get silver and then another 10 to get bronze.
This allows raids to be rescued and may help the smaller guilds survive
I could go on. But for now I look forward to changes to come. Btw I should be raiding vallus right now but I'm not super excited to do it like I usually am. That's a problem.
Thanks
1-2 hour raids were great. Once your over two hours it's a pain.
Second point. Is the merc limit. There were about 5-10 of us in our guild who would head out and "rescue raids" during our off times. It was a great way to meet people and build relationships with others which kept us coming back for more. I like the idea of a 60 limit cap but balance it in that for gold times max Mercs at 10 once gold failed you can add another 10 to get silver and then another 10 to get bronze.
This allows raids to be rescued and may help the smaller guilds survive
I could go on. But for now I look forward to changes to come. Btw I should be raiding vallus right now but I'm not super excited to do it like I usually am. That's a problem.
Thanks
Dirkstar wrote:My two cents. We are a top 50 guild barely. But we are spread over different countries. We have Canadians Americans British German and Australians. You think all of us can be on together. Never happens. We have 78 active members. Longest inactive right now is 3 days. Not one raid have we had 30 of us on at the same time. To crisco who says dump your e. leave and come back. Great idea. That's why I play this game to push buttons. Who cares if no one chats anymore. Not part of the game I guess.
1-2 hour raids were great. Once your over two hours it's a pain.
Second point. Is the merc limit. There were about 5-10 of us in our guild who would head out and "rescue raids" during our off times. It was a great way to meet people and build relationships with others which kept us coming back for more. I like the idea of a 60 limit cap but balance it in that for gold times max Mercs at 10 once gold failed you can add another 10 to get silver and then another 10 to get bronze.
This allows raids to be rescued and may help the smaller guilds survive
I could go on. But for now I look forward to changes to come. Btw I should be raiding vallus right now but I'm not super excited to do it like I usually am. That's a problem.
Thanks
I agree with everything dirk here said... very similar thoughts.
TieDyeTim wrote:All true. But what about the guild of 25? Screw them? Ok raid times are terrible but it's ok. I would prefer the suggestion someone made of a short medium and long duration raid but ok. All raids are to be 2-3 hours. I get it. Silver is now the normal and gold the exception. Ok, I'm good with that. But a guild of 25 toons can't finish any raid but gobblins? Why can't raid waves be balanced with the guild members?
Essentially, yes, screw them. That has always been the case.
A Guild that can only get a bare minimum of players to attend raids is ultimately going to fail, regardless of which raid it stalls at. This has been the fate of hundreds of Guilds prior to 1.6.1 (and prior to 1.5 too), regardless of membership numbers and desire of the players to hang together as a cohesive unit.
If your Guild is too small to complete the next raid, and that might eventually be too small at 50 members if you can't all be on at once, then you either need to expand the Guild by attracting new members, recruit mercs to help (as has been done since Guilds and raids began), or disband (or abandon) the Guild and join a bigger one that is doing the raids you need.
Nothing has changed in this regard, it's just happening sooner.
That seems less than ideal. Again I ask the question: why can't raid waves be balanced with guild membership? Seems like when you push the button to start raid a little math equation could run and set number of each wave to coincide with 10 seconds left of bronze. Add 10 Mercs you get silver, buy gs and burn you get gold. Maybe I'm an idiot, but being more inclusive rather than less seems common sense to me but I'm not a game designer.
I've been both mercing and raiding with my guild. Chat is dead except short greetings. Know why? Because when you're in a raid in a top 50 guild, you want gold and they want gold. Achieving gold is a constant burn because not everyone is max might and each class takes a different amount of time to kill. Heck each person takes a different amount of time to push the button. When my home screen loads, I push guild button to see 2 things, how much loyalty I have left to go, and how many are on: can we raid.
If anyone of you posters can say the overall game is better than Pre 1.6, I challenge you to do so. The attitudes of people have changed, the sociability has changed. I used to hang out with full e for an hour and not do anything, just chat. That doesn't happen anymore.
I've been both mercing and raiding with my guild. Chat is dead except short greetings. Know why? Because when you're in a raid in a top 50 guild, you want gold and they want gold. Achieving gold is a constant burn because not everyone is max might and each class takes a different amount of time to kill. Heck each person takes a different amount of time to push the button. When my home screen loads, I push guild button to see 2 things, how much loyalty I have left to go, and how many are on: can we raid.
If anyone of you posters can say the overall game is better than Pre 1.6, I challenge you to do so. The attitudes of people have changed, the sociability has changed. I used to hang out with full e for an hour and not do anything, just chat. That doesn't happen anymore.
Chat is dead....hardly. Every raid I have merced in post 1.6.1 has had the same amount of chat. This includes GK and VG raids. I still have friends I communicate with between guilds, requesting for help with a raid, seeing how their families are doing...etc. Yes, the overall "feel" of the game has changed and I am not sure it is all good, but to say it has ended the social aspect of the game is a farce. The current merc limit of 10 does kind of suck, but even with it my guild currently in 58th place overall has not failed a raid. Mostly silver, several bronze, and one gold on a Vallus. Organization of your guild, an active recruiting effort, and not over-reaching your guilds abilities is what it takes. I am by no means an expert and may even be a bit too tentative as a GM, but we do not try the next tier raid unless half of our members have the might to run it. If you are having troubles completing raids as a small guild, I suggest looking for a like minded guild to merge with. Several guilds I have been in since guilds started have merged with others. Cyborg Heroes merged with Starcess, Starcess merged with Helmsman Alliance, then Helmsman Alliance merged with Jacuzzi and Sauna and became the top guild in the game Helmsmans Jacuzzi. Do you lose members along the way...yes you do, but as shown strong guilds can be formed from these mergers. Just give the update a chance is all I am trying to say. Adaptation is the nature of the world.
Chat is not dead but it is weakening because merry mercing is largely dead. Can anyone remember the last time I Merced their guild? Pre-1.6, I was socializing in different guilds and new people daily. Now everything is set up to discourage that and it is.
HJ is the exception. Most mergers don't make a difference or fail. FT-Spoons, Bladeworx-Mustache, Slyver-ARC, ARC-TCG, TCG-KGW, etc. However, without a total rehaul of the entire raiding system, GMs have limited other options - recruiting is the other.
HJ is the exception. Most mergers don't make a difference or fail. FT-Spoons, Bladeworx-Mustache, Slyver-ARC, ARC-TCG, TCG-KGW, etc. However, without a total rehaul of the entire raiding system, GMs have limited other options - recruiting is the other.
Perhaps you guys are right and it's just me. I'm irritated at the long raids and little rewards. I did a constant e burn on a gk today on 3 toons for a bronze finish and about 300-600 valor for each. I spent close to 3 hours of my time and it's just not worth it. Most of the chat was nervousness about stepping it up, failure etc.
To me, personally 1.5 raid times were perfect. The mood was lighthearted and motivating, and if you didn't want to use potions or gs, it was no big deal. On the flip side if you did want to rack up the rpp we cheered you.
I'm taking a break for a few days to evaluate my own perspective. I suppose if I want to succeed and have a good time, some guild will have to merge with ours or we theirs, after all it's the way of the world. I can only change me, so a break is what I'll do.
To me, personally 1.5 raid times were perfect. The mood was lighthearted and motivating, and if you didn't want to use potions or gs, it was no big deal. On the flip side if you did want to rack up the rpp we cheered you.
I'm taking a break for a few days to evaluate my own perspective. I suppose if I want to succeed and have a good time, some guild will have to merge with ours or we theirs, after all it's the way of the world. I can only change me, so a break is what I'll do.
TieDyeTim wrote:Perhaps you guys are right and it's just me. I'm irritated at the long raids and little rewards. I did a constant e burn on a gk today on 3 toons for a bronze finish and about 300-600 valor for each. I spent close to 3 hours of my time and it's just not worth it. Most of the chat was nervousness about stepping it up, failure etc.
Back in 1.4, this happened with my first and second guilds. I was personally having to run 3-4 toons constantly to make raids succeed. In the first case, I had been made GM (against my will - long story) and ended up merging into my second guild. The second guild was stronger for about 6 weeks and then the cycle started repeating (player attrition in 1.4 was really bad). Another month after that, I left that guild (I wasn't GM this time) to go to a stronger one where I didn't have to hold raids together constantly.
If you are in that situation, reassess things and find a stable/enjoyable situation for yourself. Some of my best friends back in those days quit playing because they burned out from doing this.
Note: in no way am I defending the raid length here. Just some personal advice for Tim based on past experience.
Finally, I mentioned failed mergers earlier. I never know how to rate the merger I am discussing this time. It worked for a few weeks but in the end it just delayed guild death.