Book of Heroes

RIP Karnak's Final Stand, or KFS

Aka KFC..

1. Thank you, Venan. 1.6 KFS is (was) a true gem. And thank you for introducing it despite the majority's rather indifferent, if not outright cold, approach to onslaught.. There were talks among onslaught fans about how great cv onslaught could be, but we never hoped to see one. But here we go.. Needless to say, I (and quite a few others) enjoy(ed) it immensely, but all of a sudden..

2. you just doubled the waves count in 1.6.1 ...which effectively seems to kill KFS (at least for those regulars whom I used to run it with, but speak up guys if you still believe its manageable). Uhh, what was that? Why?

KFS is indeed quite different from, say VG, or any other raids. The no. of players who run it regularly seems to be limited (MUCH less than those who attend VG), and much less affected by raid caps.. Even if you make raid cap of 100, 500 or 500000, the number of those participants who define the success of the raid (onslaught enthusiasts) is likely to remain roughly the same on any given KFS in any given guild... Now they have to do double work and, frankly, this seems impossible (as a sustainable event, not a majestic burn extravaganza). Moreover, with a merc cap of 10, it's likewise impossible to enlist meaningful external help...

I hope you reconsider these numbers. 1.6 KFS was quite tough already.. What warranted this insane wave increase? This isn't serious.

Again, since in-game communication greatly decreased, I would like fellow onslaughters to speak up here in the forum. What do you think guys?
I agree. The number of waves is completely excessive. Previously, based on the number of waves, it was impossible to achieve gold without burning gs in the 20 person raid cap. Now the number of waves are so excessive and decreased gold time, if players are unelixired or not gsing, it is a waste of e, especially if you die in raid.

I know it's not meant to be easy, and it was fun, but now it's just as much of a grind as portals.

Venan, you're killing your own game with these updates. Each update makes it more and more imperative to use gs to raid, and it's ridiculous. VG already had a 40 person cap, so why the increased waves and decreased gold time? This game has become a chore.
I agree they added too many waves in karnark.
I think Venan ignored the fact that not everyone perform the same in onslaught especially you need to have certain might to do a decent RPP per 10e, they should stick with the original karnak wave length. they cant raise karnak's wave the way the raise GK and VG because karnak is onslaught, it doesn't work like normal raid where total waves is 2000 and you need 4000 energy in total to finish it ( 2e per wave). In kanrak, most people(11k might) can only kill 3-5 waves per 10e .

KFS.jpg

We ran new karnak last night, had 56 members in raid ( 0 mercs) , finished phase 1 in 7 mins that it feels like speed run, but as soon as we hit phase 2, it starts slowing down because its onslaught. We finished it at the end in 58 mins within gold time. Gold is possible but it requires way too much effort (coordination, team work, participation, concentration etc...)
It will be hard for a guild to run karnak daily since it simply not worth the effort.

lets break down the rpp contribution in our karnak

20k RPP+ :2 people
10k-20k: 4 people
6k-10k : 7 people
4k-6k : 20 people
3k-4K : 11 people
100Rpp-3k : 12 people

you can see most people are doing 100 rpp -6k rpp. Im sure karnak isnt that enjoyable for most players out there and adding waves in it definitely not helping.
Let's take the just finished Kingdom KFS as another example. 58 raiders - it took 2:47:59. 12 minutes from failing. 4 people were in the 20to 35K RPP range. I'm sure these people were burning and had elixirs. On the other extreme, there are 14 people below 1K. I know that several of them joined the raid in P2/3, decided it was too hard (<15K might) and bailed.

Personally, I was trying to do this while eating lunch and walking my dog. The raid is just about unplayable unless you are 100% focused on it. Hardly a casual player raid.

So we have several immediate player limits:

1. The minimum might is insane which limits the players.
2. A lot of people hate onslaught. Even some people who like CoC hated SC.
3. You can't play this raid casually.
4. If you are a multiple toon player, it is hard to keep them all dumped in P2/P3 especially since you have to change strategies between classes.

On top of that, this is *NOT* a 40 person raid no matter what you claim. Also, death is common enough and too much of a penalty.

Finally, you need a specialized build for this raid (especially as a SW). I think Tiffy (or someone else) made a feature suggestion about this already.

It is a chore not fun. This is coming from someone who would voluntarily merc SC in 1.4.

As far as I am concerned, if you are VG might, there is only one raid in the game at this point. VG. GK is not any easier and badly pails in payout. My attitude towards GK at the moment is that it takes me anyway from portal farming which is more useful.... The second best raid for high might people may be CoC right now.

Darkhorse

Site AdminFri May 24, 2013 2:06 pm
Hi Everyone. We'll continue to mointor KFS results and make adjustments as needed.
Tiffy, Bbbb, thanks for sharing, guys!

It is still doable.. somehow... but how sustainable are these efforts? I doubt such a carefully designed raid was meant to become just a one-time experiment for a few major guilds and then be abandoned...
I agree with Unknown_Hero. Yes HJ was able to complete the raid in gold but the average guild will probably not even be able to complete the raid. It was very difficult before the update and now it seems close to impossible. You can't factor in top guild numbers because most aren't like the top guilds. A lot of guilds are still struggling to get past CK. I'm sure guilds were struggling with this raid before the update so the numbers you came up with are puzzling. Please keep in mind MOST players do not like onslaught so there will be a much, much shorter turnout for that raid. Also, I think the merc cap at least for CV raids should be raised to a minimum of 20. Most guilds now close doors to CV raids so there aren't that many available to merc. They also help fill holes of guild members that can't make the raid due to time zone differences, real life, etc...
Darkhorse, I personally would like to toss out the suggestion that you guys take another look at onslaught in general. When onslaught first launched, my guild was in the SV tier. CoC was fantastic and a lot of fun. It was so much fun, in fact, that we stopped running Zuur and ran CoC instead to gear up for Helion. A casual player with a little skill could achieve a much better payout on the same energy.

Then after about a week, someone got the idea that onslaught needed tweaking. The energy requirement increased and the monsters got significantly tougher. It was not the fun that we enjoyed that first week. And now no one in our guild really cares for onslaught anymore.

I understand that there is a need for skill and difficulty, but let's be realistic here. This is a game I play on my cell phone to relax. The difficulty should never reach the level of frustration. I think with the coding change to remove hero score from trivials, you have accomplished what you intended by the difficulty increases. Consider making onslaught a touch easier again with the original energy requirements. Nerf the silver out of it if you have to. As long as it is fun and has a good valor payout, everyone will be more apt to try it.
Rockstar wrote:Darkhorse, I personally would like to toss out the suggestion that you guys take another look at onslaught in general. When onslaught first launched, my guild was in the SV tier. CoC was fantastic and a lot of fun. It was so much fun, in fact, that we stopped running Zuur and ran CoC instead to gear up for Helion. A casual player with a little skill could achieve a much better payout on the same energy.

Then after about a week, someone got the idea that onslaught needed tweaking. The energy requirement increased and the monsters got significantly tougher. It was not the fun that we enjoyed that first week. And now no one in our guild really cares for onslaught anymore.

I understand that there is a need for skill and difficulty, but let's be realistic here. This is a game I play on my cell phone to relax. The difficulty should never reach the level of frustration. I think with the coding change to remove hero score from trivials, you have accomplished what you intended by the difficulty increases. Consider making onslaught a touch easier again with the original energy requirements. Nerf the silver out of it if you have to. As long as it is fun and has a good valor payout, everyone will be more apt to try it.

I really have to agree here.

Onslaught has potential. In fact it is such a good conceptual design, I personally think Gobblin' Goblins should be an onslaught raid, so new players know just how fun raiding in this game can be.

Make Onslaught the powerhouse it should be. Offer it as a better, cheaper and faster method of grinding valor. Even a casual player would enter a 1e per round onslaught if it meant they could finally buy that awesome helmet they have been drooling about.

To expand on this... I believe there should be an onslaught for each valor tier. Just sayin.
Evologist wrote:Gobblin' Goblins should be an onslaught raid, so new players know just how fun raiding in this game can be.

Make Onslaught the powerhouse it should be. Offer it as a better, cheaper and faster method of grinding valor. Even a casual player would enter a 1e per round onslaught if it meant they could finally buy that awesome helmet they have been drooling about.

To expand on this... I believe there should be an onslaught for each valor tier. Just sayin.
Gobblin Goblins turning into an Onslaught raid could be a major turn off for beginer raiders, but I do agree, each tier should have an Onslaught raid, maybe Overseer could be one for Squires. I dont see an issue with the e cost for Onslaught as you have the potential to earn more RPP with 4e than is possible with 2 rounds of 2e in a regular raid. The only issues I have with it is the realivly small payout per RPP, and the difficulty of the monsters. My lvl 30 SW at 11k Might can get through 4-6 waves easily, 7 if he gets an early Urgency, or a Riposte or two, or back to back crits. But obviously he is out gearing that place, toons that are around the level and might they should be for that raid are not going to clear enough mobs in the 6 seconds to gain enough RPP to make the 4e cost worth while. If the mobs were slightly easier, it would allow smart, well Spec'd players to clear 3 to 4 waves, which for that level would be (in my opinion) ideal. You pay more to raid it, you should be able to get more out of it. At 2e normal raids (once your bonus stacks) grant 150 RPP every time, but with Onslaught, you pay a bit more, like a gamble, to see if you can make it worth your while and gain more than 150 per 2e. I just think Venan overshot the difficulty of Onslaught just a bit.