Book of Heroes

RIP Karnak's Final Stand, or KFS · page 3

Helmsman_Egomaniac

Wed May 29, 2013 5:16 pm
Unknown_Hero wrote:Karnak aurally requires less burning than Gk and VG IMO.
With similar total waves as Gk and VG, Karnak is mostly onslaught. So if you can kill more than 5waves per 10 e. I say you are already saving energy, some people are doing 18+ waves per 10 e... Highest I saw (screenshot) is 23 waves per 10 e so far.

plus in karnak, you don't really have enough time to burn that much gs within gold time unless you are extremely fast and skilled.
Think it as speed run, you maximise your raiders to finish a raid as fast as you can, that doesn't mean everyone burn lots of gs.

haste is required in Karnak but its over rated. Crit comes first in karnak and i think Justicar has lots of potential in Karnak.

I think it's very important that every members in that raid know what they are expected to do
For example, we told members who don't like onslaught to dump e in phase 1 as its normal raid, then they can sit out phase 2 if they want and regen for phase 3 (as phase 3 is easier than phase 2 to most people )
For onslaught lovers, if they want to save energy. They can casually hit phase 1 then focus on phase 2
But we encourage every members to at least give phase 2 a try as if you never try, you will never improve. Practices make perfect.

It's a lots of teamwork and coordination we put in our raid.
We have done more than 6 Karnak after 1.6.1 and they are all gold, some members comment they start to like Karnak and it's getting more enjoyable, some says they still hate it but they will do phase 1 to help their own guild.

Extremely accurate assessment regarding how we deal with Karnak. It takes incredible coordination within the entire guild to run KFS successfully.

Agree w/ Tiffy that Justicars have incredible potential in Karnak as it's my fav class to play in that raid.

As far as the raid itself goes...

I like P1
I despise P2
I love P3

Amazing raid and I'm somewhat shocked(not really...lol) that we're the only guild that can run it in gold since update

~ Ego
I agree about the Justicar.

But if you all try it as say an under 17K might player with no elixirs or pots, you'll have 100% different opinion. Most people can't get 5 kills. Even as your current toons without the haste elixir, I suspect it will half your kill total though I'd like to see your real data. One thing you miss about not having the haste elixir is that you have to waste time playing defense to not die because the health pots/interrupt runes don't cool down fast enough.

I am now thinking that next raid it is better to spend on the haste elixir than e pots and will try that on one toon. But honestly, I won't run it again until 1.6.2 as my guild isn't running it and I'd rather VG (the essence drops are so much better for the e). But if I have to buy an elixir for every time I want to run it, I will stay with VG. I am not so rich.

Mith and I did some experiments and decided that 2H is better than 1H on this raid. Do you all agree?

My two experience with running it (one 1.6 and one 1.6.1 - tiffy was in the second raid) were both bronze and took enormous burning to get there. Whereas we can do a silver VG with no burn. The 1.6.1 one had 56 raiders too.
Was into another KFC run.

33 ppl, top 3 over 30k rpp (top1 about 60k), burning, haste+might elixir, etc. NO WAY. Failure.

So... the raid is designed now strictly for 45+ participants at least. I can think of HJ, KOTOR.. possibly a few other top guilds. Which not only can handle this but are willing to do so.. occasionally.

Turns out all that work on new raid / content / artwork in 1.6.1 ended up being wasted on a very occasional playtoy for 1 to 3 top guilds.. Sweet...

Was that the intention? Seriously?

Np, then I guess Venan may take all the time in the world "monitoring KFS results", not just a few weeks, hehe. Take your time.. And then perhaps decrease the no. of waves by a few dozen, hehe. And then change a bit the artwork for Karnak's ring.. hehe. And add a few tweaks to Claude's quest line..hehe... to streamline experience..

Because that's the experience we need, not this "onslaught" bizarrerie.. Good job on removing SC, btw..
Another complaint about this raid. Tiffy said (sorry, don't remember if it was in the forum or on chat) that she had a specialty build for just Karnak that was pretty useless for VG. If swapping builds was free, it would be one thing, but at 5 GS a pop, that's a different story.
Bbbb wrote:I agree about the Justicar.
Even as your current toons without the haste elixir, I suspect it will half your kill total though I'd like to see your real data. One thing you miss about not having the haste elixir is that you have to waste time playing defense to not die because the health pots/interrupt runes don't cool down fast enough.

This is exaggerated, elixir is 15% haste I'm at 75% haste most of the time during Karnak (with urgency triggered) even if I lose 15% haste. I will be at 60% haste. I doubt It will be half my total kill.
*i have count how many urgency I get per 10 e, average 8-10 urgency triggers per 10e (I have 3 T6 defence enchant defence is over 50% so my strategy is just let the boss hit me so I can get urgency, I only stun or delay attack when I have urgency triggered)
Bbbb wrote:One thing you miss about not having the haste elixir is that you have to waste time playing defense to not die because the health pots/interrupt runes don't cool down fast enough.
I don't have a problem with cool down, because I use smokebomb. The only issue I have is if I raid Karnak when I'm tired, I will end up using cleansing pot once I see 'steal weapon' then end up losing weapon and no cleansing pot lol
* SW can use smokebomb or ensnare to delay or stun enemies attack. And they are fast!
** also you can use caltrop or frost runes to slow enemies down
*** some people use knock back resist enchant in Karnak (I actually not very sure what it do exactly) but they say it reduces your timer getting knock back so save you time even if u get hit.
I use whatever I can to maximise my performances in Karnak, if you say losing a 15a% haste elixir is gonna reduce my total wave count by half, that's impossible unless I'm tapping button without paying attention to every single attack.

Lastly assume a 15% haste really can double up my total wave count, then sounds like elixir is sooooo worth it lol :D
Bbbb wrote:
I'd rather VG (the essence drops are so much better for the e). But if I have to buy an elixir for every time I want to run it, I will stay with VG.
The more Waves you kill in kanark the more loots you get, also try wearing a piece of luck enchant in Karnak, you will be surprise of the double loot you get every 10e.
Bbbb wrote:
My two experience with running it (one 1.6 and one 1.6.1 - tiffy was in the second raid) were both bronze and took enormous burning to get there. Whereas we can do a silver VG with no burn. The 1.6.1 one had 56 raiders too.
I run about 2 Karnak daily. For my home guild's Karnak. I give it my best shot, I will kill as fast as I can without stopping.
For other guilds' Karnak. Im more relax coz I'm just farming for HS :p so yes I will join a Karnak even if it's bronze or gonna be a fail, I do it coz it's fun, challenged, good loot for me and great for HS.

* one thing I want to add, most guild's Karnak seem to have 1 common issue : their members don't come back or most bailed coz its too hard for them, so even if they have 40+ raiders in Karnak. But it's pointless if only 14 members stays in the battle, a Karnak with all 30 raiders staying would do so much better. Also why you don't get to burn as much within gold time, you are burning in a bronze because you let it run too long and no one else is coming back.
Bbbb wrote:Another complaint about this raid. Tiffy said (sorry, don't remember if it was in the forum or on chat) that she had a specialty build for just Karnak that was pretty useless for VG. If swapping builds was free, it would be one thing, but at 5 GS a pop, that's a different story.

Don't worry Dual spec is coming ;)
Grnm wrote:Was into another KFC run.
33 ppl, top 3 over 30k rpp (top1 about 60k), burning, haste+might elixir, etc. NO WAY. Failure.

Sounds like the other 30 people are doing nothing... :shock:
Unknown_Hero wrote:
** also you can use caltrop or frost runes to slow enemies down

Which runes do you think are the best for this raid? Each seems to have benefits. My gut feeling is that Nature is the weakest although for the SW only it has additional benefits.

I am 3xT4 on Defense but I actually have some resist gems :o so we may be even on defense. I haven't died, but I've come darn close. Before someone rants about that, crit power gems barely move the needle on the % so I think I have 3 of each blue gems. But anyway, we both have more defense than most players.

I've spent much more time in this raid with Mage and Justicar than SW since I slacked opening it up on my SW. That's probably not helping me figure out strategy as I am trying to figure out three sets at once....

A non-SW question, is it better to be speced as Fire Mage and a Bleed Justicar? I'm thinking it is. I want to respec once and only once and try to find a happy medium ground performance wise. If dual spec comes, then problem solved. I think I will wait for the next rebalancing to see if I will be running KFS much.

On an unrelated note, the recent Justicar changes greatly improved their CoC performance.
Bbbb wrote:

Which runes do you think are the best for this raid? Each seems to have benefits. My gut feeling is that Nature is the weakest although for the SW only it has additional benefits.

Can't say what's the best runes for this raid, different build diff class diff stat all influence what's the best runes for individual

For myself. Here is the list of runes and pot I bring:
3500 health pot
Cleansing potion - remove up to 3 negative effect
Minor break runes - interrupt attacks
Minor purge runes - remove 1 beneficial effect from enemy
Minor fire runes - do Fire damage and deal fire dam over time
Minor blight runes - deal Nature damage and decrease enemy damage
Minor spirit runes - deal sprit damage and decrease enemy defense

For phase 1 I use poisons cloud and blight runes ( I pick blight runes because I can deal big damage with it since I'm a hybrid toward poison in Karnak with 3 T6 Nature enchant) you might ask why don't I use spirit runes to soften the mob's defense then hit with poison cloud, i don't use spirit runes in p1 coz I'm saving spirit runes for the bosses

P2 start battle with spirit runes to decrease boss's defense, throw a caltrop to slow them down and halve their dodge chance, then use a nature attack (acid spray or toxic blade) I poison my enemies to increase my crit chance

My crit is 40% from gems, hero training and guild favor, +15% crit chance (neurotoxin, if enemies are poisoned), + 20% crit chance (critical eyes, for physical attack), + 25% crit chance (piercing strike ability )
So assume if I poisoned my enemies, I have 55% crit chance for any of my magic attacks (poison cloud, acid spray and toxic blade)
If I poisoned my enemies and use a regular weapon attack, my crit chance is 75% (basic attack, caltrop DoT)
If I poisoned my enemies, and use piercing strike , my crit chance for piercing strike is....100%

So it's very important for me to soften enemies defense then poison them, just to increase my crit chance :)
I rotate Toxic blade and pricing strike , because toxic blade is nature attack, it will keep the enemies poison at all time ( which reduce enemies Nature resistance up to 45%, 15% each stack I think. Correct me if I'm wrong)

For me I'm doing 17-19k damage from toxic blade crit, 11k dam from piercing strike crit. (I crit a lot with this build and gems set up) I'm happy with what I can do so far but I feel like I can still improve.

As for blue gems, I have t5 10 Crit power, I don't have any room to buy resist gems. I'm happy with my defense. I never hit below 3k health, probably becoz I can kill enemies before they do that many hits on me and with the defense enchant taking up the damage.

I have tried with different builds in Karnak. I'm most comfortable with hybrid toward poison, I'm very OCD about the DoT I stack lol I HAVE to stack them or I feel naked.
I always stack DoT from caltrops, poison clouds and Fire runes. Fire runes's DoT are yummy when you stack up to 3.
As I mention above, I start battle with spirit runes, but after I have posited my enemies and stack poison cloud's Dot, I will start using fire tunes for the rest of my waves.

I use Purge runes to remove beneficial effect from boss ( mostly in phase 2, forgot what's that effect called. Something stance... Lol it increases the boss's crit chance and damage on players) I normally don't care about the bleed effects I get as it only do 99 damage to me.

For smokebomb, I aim to use it a a stage where I'm at 75% haste, all runes in cooldwon... Try to maximise the benefit of smokebomb. There are still times I wasn't 100% focus and use smokebombto delay enemy's attack and when my runes not in cooldwon, I feel like I wasted my SB :(

That's all I can think of so far... Brain hurts now lol
One thing I want to add is, in normal raid. Even in Cv raid, no matter how crap your build is. You can still punch it through the battles without thinking or any skill to get RPP.

But in Karnak you need a specific build and lots of decision making and concertration during the battles to maximise your performance. this is what makes karnak so unique and challenged. :)
I have done Karnak without a Haste Elixir as it ran out mid raid. It DOES NOT cut your kills in half. I can still get 288-306 HS WITHOUT the elixir. You just have to prepare your build specifically for the raid. With the elixir I have hit 360-414 HS. (Screen shots for non believers) So yes the elixir does make a difference. For those that can't afford the elixir I reccomend farming for haste pots and using them. Dodge pots help a lot as well and you can use those along with haste pots. It's all about preparation for the raid.

The biggest thing about KFS that i can't preach enough is, it takes committed guild members. Don't think of yourself, think of the team. You may not like the raid but every little bit helps in this raid. Over half of the members that raid Karnak in HJ don't like onslaught but they tough it out to help the GUILD. A guild will not be successful if its full of members only caring about their progress and not the guild as a whole. Venan stated from the start the new raid will take a guild effort and it does. Granted, it's more difficult than it was before but it can still be done as HJ has proven.

If you've only got 15 members in the raid all you will end up doing is farming it. My suggestion is to rally the troops. Also find 10 committed mercs to help you from the start if needed. The more players the less needed to burn. My first 10 e in p2 takes up 26-28% of the phase to end. So it's much less burning if you have the numbers.

Realistically Venan does need to nerf the raid a bit if they want guilds other than the top 5 to be able to run it and complete it. However with good guild management and coordination it can be done. Maybe not as an everyday raid.

I think the extended p1 is to keep players from farming onslaught raids since the CoC controversy. I also think KFS needs to go back to pre 1.6.1 to make it playable for the majority of the guilds. I hope Venan listens because it truly is a great and challenging raid for onslaught fans and I want to see more guilds running it so I can merc it. :)