Book of Heroes

RIP Karnak's Final Stand, or KFS · page 4

Tiffy wrote:
Grnm wrote:Was into another KFC run.
33 ppl, top 3 over 30k rpp (top1 about 60k), burning, haste+might elixir, etc. NO WAY. Failure.

Sounds like the other 30 people are doing nothing... :shock:
No Tiff.. they were doing their best..including mercs.. What we needed were 10 more ppl "doing nothing" like them..

I know its easy and entertaining being ironic when you are in a position when you got 40+ ppl available.. but
just for a moment imagine you don't, not funny..

My point was that 1.6.1 Karnak could be afforded by literally just a few guilds.. to be completed at all, I'm not speaking about easy gold.. if that was the intention then I rest my case..
enough said..
Grnm wrote:
I know its easy and entertaining being ironic when you are in a position when you got 40+ ppl available.. but
just for a moment imagine you don't, not funny..

My point was that 1.6.1 Karnak could be afforded by literally just a few guilds.. to be completed at all, I'm not speaking about easy gold.. if that was the intention then I rest my case..
enough said..

Total waves in Karnak now is 2255 waves. With 33 people, you said 1 did 60 k RPP, 2 did 30k RPP .
So to finish the raid, the rest of your 30 members need to each do 7k RPP Within 3 hours (bronze time)


So Venan says karnak is a 40 man raid. Let's break this down

Total waves in Karnak : 2255 waves
40 raiders standard.
2255 waves / 40 raiders = 56.37 waves per person. Let's just round it to 56 waves per person
Your first 11 waves give u 1375 RPP and after that each waves give 150 RPP
So each person is expect to do 8,125 RPP (56 waves) within GOLD time (1 hr 20 mins) or silver (2hours) or Bronze time (3 hours)
I understand what you are all saying - lots of good advice and I am not disagreeing with it.

Disguesting the points, the success (game wise) of the raid comes down the bottom line which is that:

1. Most players are not going to buy elixirs.
2. Most players are not going to farm the haste/dodge recipes and then farm all the needed materials.
3. Most players are not going to put into the effort to figure out all the tricks. Even Tiffy is saying her brain hurts.
4. Most players are not going to do specialty builds.
5. You can get the members that don't like the raid to help for a while but eventually they will get fed up and stop. This happened with SC in 1.4. At the end of 1.4, SC was almost exclusively run by people farming hero score (a couple of guilds would actually finish it - most would cancel it).
6. Some of the players who had bad experience with KFS already won't be back.
7. Even players like me who like onslaught can only do this raid when fully focused on it. Unfortunately, most of my available raid times I'm doing something else like walking the dog and hardly 100% engaged.

Venan has basically built a raid for a very limited number of hardcore players. This would be okay if we had enough other CV raids to choose from, but we don't plus GK is near useless to anyone who is CV maxed already. Also, onslaught raids due to their intensity need to be short raids.

I find it odd that SC gets canned from being unpopular yet this raid makes SC look like a walk in the park and won't be any more popular in the long run.

Personally, I wanted a really tough non-onslaught raid with double and triple behemoth waves. :D
Bbbb wrote:

Venan has basically built a raid for a very limited number of hardcore players.

I think it will be interesting to have top 40 might to raid Karnak together. :D too bad we can't organise this because of the Mercs system :(
Grnm wrote:
I know its easy and entertaining being ironic when you are in a position when you got 40+ ppl available.. but
just for a moment imagine you don't, not funny...

Of coz I know it's not funny, I'd be effing pissed if I did 60k RPP and the raid failed. :evil:
my suggestion is merc Karnak in a guild that's capable of finishing it if you truly wish to do Karnak.
Tiffy wrote:
my suggestion is merc Karnak in a guild that's capable of finishing it if you truly wish to do Karnak.

From Monkey's constant pleas, we see how many are run.....
Bbbb wrote:
Tiffy wrote:
my suggestion is merc Karnak in a guild that's capable of finishing it if you truly wish to do Karnak.

From Monkey's constant pleas, we see how many are run.....


Someone need to organise a Karnak for Mercs :)
Tiffy wrote: Total waves in Karnak now is 2255 waves. With 33 people, you said 1 did 60 k RPP, 2 did 30k RPP .
So to finish the raid, the rest of your 30 members need to each do 7k RPP Within 3 hours (bronze time)


So Venan says karnak is a 40 man raid. Let's break this down

Total waves in Karnak : 2255 waves
40 raiders standard.
2255 waves / 40 raiders = 56.37 waves per person. Let's just round it to 56 waves per person
Your first 11 waves give u 1375 RPP and after that each waves give 150 RPP
So each person is expect to do 8,125 RPP (56 waves) within GOLD time (1 hr 20 mins) or silver (2hours) or Bronze time (3 hours)

Yep, Tiffy, it looks so...

Also I re-read my post and it looked sort of rude to you - I apologize, did not really want to blame you or anything, sorry )))

Anyway, Venan has bigger problems now - security & hacking of client content. Hope theyre going to deal with this ASAP..
You can spend 5 seconds googling and find out not only what the hack was but who did it (some of them were dumb enough to post their IDs and guild on a public forum). The hack isn't the end of the world. It requires some technical expertise to pull off (the average player couldn't execute it).
I wouldn't call that a hack. Just cheat, they changed the data file that's store in your app when you download the game. I agree with Bbbb. Some people are dumb lol. And some even merc in other guild to cheat RPP. I mean if u want to cheat, why so obvious? Just dumb I'm glad Venan increases the transparency in raid finders, it's so easy for the community to find out if anyone or any guild is doing something abnormal, for example 1 member in raid. 97% gold kv raid in 10 mins etc....