Book of Heroes

RIP Karnak's Final Stand, or KFS · page 6

Fizzbears just did it in gold.

Time taken: 1:00:33

62 people in raid

2 @ 20k-23k
2 @ 18k-19k
4 @ 12k-14k
2 @ 8k-10k
3 @ 7k-8k
17 @ 4k-6k
10 @ 3k-4k
13 @ 1k-3k
10 < 1k (5 @ 0 or 10)

Thoughts...

It's definitely a rough raid, but definitely easier than it was when 1.6 came out. In its' current state, it'll probably never become a daily raid for most guilds outside of the top 5-10. Even for us, a good deal of it was just extremely good coordination. It's exciting to do once in a while though. If that's what Venan was going for, I think they did their job. But if they were hoping more guilds would do it... lowering the wave counts might be necessary.

Possessed_Mithrid

Sun Jun 2, 2013 8:56 pm
Fizz_Eric wrote:Fizzbears just did it in gold.

Time taken: 1:00:33

62 people in raid

2 @ 20k-23k
2 @ 18k-19k
4 @ 12k-14k
2 @ 8k-10k
3 @ 7k-8k
17 @ 4k-6k
10 @ 3k-4k
13 @ 1k-3k
10 < 1k (5 @ 0 or 10)

Thoughts...

It's definitely a rough raid, but definitely easier than it was when 1.6 came out. In its' current state, it'll probably never become a daily raid for most guilds outside of the top 5-10. Even for us, a good deal of it was just extremely good coordination. It's exciting to do once in a while though. If that's what Venan was going for, I think they did their job. But if they were hoping more guilds would do it... lowering the wave counts might be necessary.

Eric is just confirming what many of us on this thread have stated, KFC as it stands is currently a good raid, but a difficult raid, that will require great guild effort to do...and probably be for special occasions or special time slots.

As has been said as well, It is also an endgame raid, for maxed guilds to have fun with...I think as it is it can work for the game IMAO.

I think people just need to accept that it will be above the reach of most guilds, is that a problem? (I'm not arguing one way or the other...I think that becomes an opinion statement).
Mithrid wrote:I think people just need to accept that it will be above the reach of most guilds, is that a problem? (I'm not arguing one way or the other...I think that becomes an opinion statement).

Personally I'm cool with it. I think the game needs a variety of raids, some easier, some more challenging, some onslaught (for the lovers of that like myself), and some stretch raids that are possible, but just barely. I do agree however that the pretty much across the board increase in waves isn't good. We also need ones that can be accomplished by a smaller number in a shorter timeframe. It is after all, as may have said, an iPhone game.

Denrael
I wouldn't have an issue with having a hard raid if we had enough other CV raids but we don't.

Possessed_Mithrid

Mon Jun 3, 2013 6:49 pm
Bbbb wrote:I wouldn't have an issue with having a hard raid if we had enough other CV raids but we don't.

This I understand... :|
Mithrid wrote:
Bbbb wrote:I wouldn't have an issue with having a hard raid if we had enough other CV raids but we don't.

This I understand... :|


Noted. I agree. Even one more would help. That and now that vg drops flux/ess, its significantly better than GK, leading to no one feeling like doing GK anymore.

Not that I'm complaining about the flux/ess drops, but you basically phased out GK and replaced it with an extremely difficult cv raid. Maybe something higher than vg without the flux/ess drops so that the rewards are better than vg, but no flux/ess?

Possessed_Mithrid

Wed Jun 5, 2013 5:17 pm
Fizz_Eric wrote:

Noted. I agree. Even one more would help. That and now that vg drops flux/ess, its significantly better than GK, leading to no one feeling like doing GK anymore.

Not that I'm complaining about the flux/ess drops, but you basically phased out GK and replaced it with an extremely difficult cv raid.

I'm kind of bummed about this. GK is a great raid, one of my favorites but I too have noticed now that VG drops essence, there is little incentive for people to Wang to GK unless they just don't have the might for a VG.

I don't want to see VG touched, I love that it drops a little essence but hasn't relegated portals to the trash heep; but I would like to see something in GK that makes it still an attractive raid bedsides just the CV.

Or maybe well just learn to accept it as it is, but it's such a fun raid and hard to see players starting to avoid it because they are saving e for a VG.
Hi Mith,

I'm giving you my first forum post - hope you enjoy it ;)

Just as an FYI about KFS being an endgame raid. The Council just finished their Vallus runs and opened WoF. Our new challenges are to run Wof 10 time to open GK and KFS - which means VG is still considered the endgame raid by Venan, not KFS.

My thinking is that it doesn't make sense given the story timeline, but that's me looking at it.

HY
HaleYeiko wrote:

Our new challenges are to run Wof 10 time to open GK and KFS - which means VG is still considered the endgame raid by Venan, not KFS.
HY

Karnak is places before VG in guild challenge because its might requirement is same as GK, lower than VG. I think 11k might can enter Karnak to do p1 and enjoy the drop rate , don't do p2 and p3 If they can't handle it.

Possessed_Mithrid

Wed Jun 5, 2013 10:46 pm
HaleYeiko wrote:Hi Mith,

I'm giving you my first forum post - hope you enjoy it ;)

Just as an FYI about KFS being an endgame raid. The Council just finished their Vallus runs and opened WoF. Our new challenges are to run Wof 10 time to open GK and KFS - which means VG is still considered the endgame raid by Venan, not KFS.

My thinking is that it doesn't make sense given the story timeline, but that's me looking at it.

HY
Woot! On a roll for collecting cherry forum posts!!
Hey HY!! I just realized I haven't visited the council in weeks...will need to fix that.

That being said, yes according to the raid requirements and might requirements, KFC is not intended as the endgame that VG is suppose to be, your point being spot on...
... however considering it from a storyline as you mentioned, and more importantly from the practical raiding standpoint (and pending tomorrows update), KFC is still a very challenging raid for most toons under 20K. Most of the toons I know who regularly look for KFC raids and enjoy KFC raids are the >20k individuals...most toons less than 20k are preferring to raid VG. Which from a practical standpoint, KFC definitely is the endgame raid. :)