Book of Heroes

RIP Karnak's Final Stand, or KFS · page 5

Possessed_Mithrid

Sat Jun 1, 2013 11:14 am
Just catching up on discussions as I have been out.

My 2cents here...KFC is a great end-game raid, but it is a play thing only for top guilds.

I think Crzy has many thoughts that I agree with:
CrzyHopper wrote:... Dodge pots help a lot as well and you can use those along with haste pots. It's all about preparation for the raid.

The biggest thing about KFS that i can't preach enough is, it takes committed guild members. .....
...Venan stated from the start the new raid will take a guild effort and it does. Granted, it's more difficult than it was before but it can still be done as HJ has proven.

...Realistically Venan does need to nerf the raid a bit if they want guilds other than the top 5 to be able to run it and complete it. However with good guild management and coordination it can be done. Maybe not as an everyday raid.

I think the extended p1 is to keep players from farming onslaught raids since the CoC controversy. I also think KFS needs to go back to pre 1.6.1 to make it playable for the majority of the guilds. I hope Venan listens because it truly is a great and challenging raid for onslaught fans and I want to see more guilds running it so I can merc it. :)

That being said....
KFC will never be playable for most guilds as it currently stands, reason I say that is several fold:
1. ...because the realistic might req is much higher than what is listed (Bbbb has commented on this several times and he is right).
2. It takes coordination of a guild full of at least 30, >20k Might, players. There are not too many guilds around with that kind of membership to regularly coordinate...we can all name them on 1 hand.

Note that the vast majority of players commenting on this thread are >25k might. Where are all the <20k players comments on KFC? I will tell you you...they don't do it or have died by the wayside. This is a problem of Survivorship Bias. In fact this whole thread is an epitome of survivorship bias.

That being said, I think KFC is a great raid, but like Karnak's ring, its an endgame item for those of us with nothing else to do at the top. It is not a raid that we will see run to completion by 98% of guilds, on a regular basis, in my opinion; but that is not a reason to tank it.


Separate note: If you don't know what survivor-ship bias is then you need to look it up...it is a very real phenomena that affects everything you perceive in life. Mith's lesson of the day. :lol:
great introduction article: http://youarenotsosmart.com/2013/05/23/ ... ship-bias/
This reminds one of the CoC chasing days

At the beginning barely ANY guild run CoC to finish because it's difficult to most people, I have to go to different guilds to ask them to start it for me and told them I guarantee I can finish it on my own or I will bring some friend's to help finish... I get tired of searching CoC at one point and made a few guilds to build them up just so I can start CoC myself...lol

After the big controversy of CoC farming and wh0re incident on forum. All the suddn CoC ad is all over global and CoC became one of the most popular raid. I see CoC running in a lots of guild, and get whisper invite to do CoC everyday.
Some people even found CoC enjoyable after a few try.

IMO when people don't know how to do onslaught, they give up.
people just need time to learn how to do Karnak.
but of coz Karnak is way harder than CoC and take more concentration.

People are still learning the raid, with Venan increasing its difficulty by adding more waves isn't helping.
This will only discourage players to run Karnak.
Also people don't want to have to change their raid gear just to do KFS. From what I've seen tiffy and crzyhopper have to respec every time just to efficiently do KFS...I can easily change gems to onslaught but paying 5 gs each time to respec seems crazy!
My first guild (and many others) was running CoC all the time (we had two winners in the onslaught competition there once was - I was excluded due to a might limit in the rules) from when it was introduced and we were might appropriate at that point in time. I have always been able to find one when I looked.

The reason CoC has become more popular on global because it has turned into low level guilds (not saying all but many) who don't have the horsepower to run it in house count on a couple of high might people to show up and bail them out. They don't have the same success with Kraken, Zuur or Helion. Note: I am not saying anything needs to be done about that situation.

I enjoyed CoC the first time I ran it. I can not say the same for Karnak. It's closer to the SC situation. The guilds who would run it usually would have to beg members and mercs to show up. Right around the time 1.5 was released, HJ was running SC successfully daily but then again Hai, Mich, Derrin, Amy, myself and a couple of others would show up to carry the raid. Maybe (or not) one or two other guilds were but that was all. The thing is that with a toon with a standard build sucks much worse at Karnak than SC even after factoring in the might differences. We need to look at SC for our history lessons not CoC. Right now the history lesson unless something changes is that Venan is going to remove it from the game in a few months for lack of use.
91Romeo wrote:Also people don't want to have to change their raid gear just to do KFS. From what I've seen tiffy and crzyhopper have to respec every time just to efficiently do KFS...I can easily change gems to onslaught but paying 5 gs each time to respec seems crazy!


I finally come up with a build that I like Can use it in any raid ... CoC, normal raid or Karnak..:)
Tiffy wrote:
I finally come up with a build that I like Can use it in any raid ... CoC, normal raid or Karnak..:)

O.O Impossible

Possessed_Mithrid

Sun Jun 2, 2013 3:09 am
Fizz_Eric wrote:
Tiffy wrote:
I finally come up with a build that I like Can use it in any raid ... CoC, normal raid or Karnak..:)

O.O Impossible

What Tiffy fails to mention is the sacrifices/compromises she has made...I can raid KFC for instance with my current build just fine, but it will not earn me the best RPP per 10e...likewise if I adjust it so it is optimized for KFC, then my VG raid will suffer.

So the question is...are we discussing an optimal spec or just a balanced functional spec? ;)
Mithrid wrote:
Fizz_Eric wrote:
Tiffy wrote:
I finally come up with a build that I like Can use it in any raid ... CoC, normal raid or Karnak..:)

O.O Impossible

What Tiffy fails to mention is the sacrifices/compromises she has made...I can raid KFC for instance with my current build just fine, but it will not earn me the best RPP per 10e...likewise if I adjust it so it is optimized for KFC, then my VG raid will suffer.

So the question is...are we discussing an optimal spec or just a balanced functional spec? ;)


I tried this build is VG, Gk and Karnak, 60k RPP in VG, 85k RPP in GK, 45k RPP in Karnak. All within gold time.
I'm happy with it. I don't feel like I'm suffering in anything
Tiffy wrote:I tried this build is VG, Gk and Karnak, 60k RPP in VG, 85k RPP in GK, 45k RPP in Karnak. All within gold time.
I'm happy with it. I don't feel like I'm suffering in anything
Not that I'm anywhere near ready for those raids, just out of curiosity, what spec are you running?