Just catching up on discussions as I have been out.
My 2cents here...KFC is a great end-game raid, but it is a play thing only for top guilds.
I think Crzy has many thoughts that I agree with:
That being said....
KFC will never be playable for most guilds as it currently stands, reason I say that is several fold:
1. ...because the realistic might req is much higher than what is listed (Bbbb has commented on this several times and he is right).
2. It takes coordination of a guild full of at least 30, >20k Might, players. There are not too many guilds around with that kind of membership to regularly coordinate...we can all name them on 1 hand.
Note that the vast majority of players commenting on this thread are >25k might. Where are all the <20k players comments on KFC? I will tell you you...they don't do it or have died by the wayside. This is a problem of Survivorship Bias. In fact this whole thread is an epitome of survivorship bias.
That being said, I think KFC is a great raid, but like Karnak's ring, its an endgame item for those of us with nothing else to do at the top. It is not a raid that we will see run to completion by 98% of guilds, on a regular basis, in my opinion; but that is not a reason to tank it.
Separate note: If you don't know what survivor-ship bias is then you need to look it up...it is a very real phenomena that affects everything you perceive in life. Mith's lesson of the day.
great introduction article: http://youarenotsosmart.com/2013/05/23/ ... ship-bias/
My 2cents here...KFC is a great end-game raid, but it is a play thing only for top guilds.
I think Crzy has many thoughts that I agree with:
CrzyHopper wrote:... Dodge pots help a lot as well and you can use those along with haste pots. It's all about preparation for the raid.
The biggest thing about KFS that i can't preach enough is, it takes committed guild members. .....
...Venan stated from the start the new raid will take a guild effort and it does. Granted, it's more difficult than it was before but it can still be done as HJ has proven.
...Realistically Venan does need to nerf the raid a bit if they want guilds other than the top 5 to be able to run it and complete it. However with good guild management and coordination it can be done. Maybe not as an everyday raid.
I think the extended p1 is to keep players from farming onslaught raids since the CoC controversy. I also think KFS needs to go back to pre 1.6.1 to make it playable for the majority of the guilds. I hope Venan listens because it truly is a great and challenging raid for onslaught fans and I want to see more guilds running it so I can merc it.
That being said....
KFC will never be playable for most guilds as it currently stands, reason I say that is several fold:
1. ...because the realistic might req is much higher than what is listed (Bbbb has commented on this several times and he is right).
2. It takes coordination of a guild full of at least 30, >20k Might, players. There are not too many guilds around with that kind of membership to regularly coordinate...we can all name them on 1 hand.
Note that the vast majority of players commenting on this thread are >25k might. Where are all the <20k players comments on KFC? I will tell you you...they don't do it or have died by the wayside. This is a problem of Survivorship Bias. In fact this whole thread is an epitome of survivorship bias.
That being said, I think KFC is a great raid, but like Karnak's ring, its an endgame item for those of us with nothing else to do at the top. It is not a raid that we will see run to completion by 98% of guilds, on a regular basis, in my opinion; but that is not a reason to tank it.
Separate note: If you don't know what survivor-ship bias is then you need to look it up...it is a very real phenomena that affects everything you perceive in life. Mith's lesson of the day.
great introduction article: http://youarenotsosmart.com/2013/05/23/ ... ship-bias/