Book of Heroes

RIP Karnak's Final Stand, or KFS · page 2

Bj_Knows

ModeratorWed May 29, 2013 11:37 am
Grnm wrote:I hope you reconsider these numbers. 1.6 KFS was quite tough already.. What warranted this insane wave increase?

Raid Cap for Karnak Raid was 20, now it is balanced for 40, so waves would have been doubled.
Bj_DWR wrote:
Grnm wrote:I hope you reconsider these numbers. 1.6 KFS was quite tough already.. What warranted this insane wave increase?

Raid Cap for Karnak Raid was 20, now it is balanced for 40, so waves would have been doubled.

I think Grnm's point was more that Karnak was hard enough to attempt/complete with 20 people, let alone now with 40.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorWed May 29, 2013 11:42 am
Rockstar wrote:Darkhorse, I personally would like to toss out the suggestion that you guys take another look at onslaught in general. When onslaught first launched, my guild was in the SV tier. CoC was fantastic and a lot of fun. It was so much fun, in fact, that we stopped running Zuur and ran CoC instead to gear up for Helion. A casual player with a little skill could achieve a much better payout on the same energy.

When Onslaught was first launched, Venan had this response to Justicar complaints:
Lord_Venan wrote:
We didn't think that this round of changes would bring everything in balance, but we wanted to see if it would help at all. In case you're wondering prior to this last patch, the breakdown was something like this for onslaught raids:

SW - 1.25 encounter per energy
Mages - 1.09 encounters per energy
Just - .90 encounters per energy

Really these numbers need to be all in the same vicinity, or onslaught just doesn't work. And for reference, the normal number is .5 for traditional raids (hence the move to trying 6 energy). I agree it's a bit much though, so we'll be backing that down again most likely.

We don't have any absolute answers yet, but I wanted you to know we hear your feedback loud and clear and we'll continue to make adjustments until the game experience is what we think it should be (namely, fun!)
Server Maintenance - August 10, 2012

The first attempt in v1.4.0 resulted in an average of +20% Rewards for Mages and +38% Rewards for SW vs the Just class.

In version 1.4.1 through 1.6.1, Venan continues to tweek Onslaught:
Bj_DWR wrote:Subject
Shadowy Rep or The Shadow Comes annoyed Justicars
Shadowy Rep or The Shadow Comes annoyed Justicars
Bj_DWR wrote:
Grnm wrote:I hope you reconsider these numbers. 1.6 KFS was quite tough already.. What warranted this insane wave increase?

Raid Cap for Karnak Raid was 20, now it is balanced for 40, so waves would have been doubled.

A proper balancing is not a doubling. That may what they did but that would be based on a flawed usage model.

Also, please don't repost old numbers from August. All the classes have been seriously overhauled and they are misleading at best. Additionally, the raid has retuned several times since then. The 1.5 Mage changes and the 1.6 Justicar changes had to help them some.
Fizz_Eric wrote:

I think Grnm's point was more that Karnak was hard enough to attempt/complete with 20 people, let alone now with 40.


We did Karnak last night with 39 people. Finished in 53 mins! :D

Bj_Knows

ModeratorWed May 29, 2013 12:23 pm
Bbbb wrote:
Also, please don't repost old numbers from August.

Original posted edited for emphasis.

Helmsman_Egomaniac

Wed May 29, 2013 2:27 pm
Unknown_Hero wrote:
Fizz_Eric wrote:

I think Grnm's point was more that Karnak was hard enough to attempt/complete with 20 people, let alone now with 40.


We did Karnak last night with 39 people. Finished in 53 mins! :D


Yes we did, didn't we! :roll:
How many people had haste elixirs and how many e pots/gs burned?

Run it without those and tell us how you did.
Karnak actually requires less burning than Gk and VG IMO.
With similar total waves as Gk and VG, Karnak is mostly onslaught. So if you can kill more than 5waves per 10 e. I say you are already saving energy, some people are doing 18+ waves per 10 e... Highest I saw (screenshot) is 23 waves per 10 e so far.

plus in karnak, you don't really have enough time to burn that much gs within gold time unless you are extremely fast and skilled.
Think it as speed run, you maximise your raiders to finish a raid as fast as you can, that doesn't mean everyone burn lots of gs.

haste is required in Karnak but its over rated. Crit comes first in karnak and i think Justicar has lots of potential in Karnak.

I think it's very important that every members in that raid know what they are expected to do
For example, we told members who don't like onslaught to dump e in phase 1 as its normal raid, then they can sit out phase 2 if they want and regen for phase 3 (as phase 3 is easier than phase 2 to most people )
For onslaught lovers, if they want to save energy. They can casually hit phase 1 then focus on phase 2
But we encourage every members to at least give phase 2 a try as if you never try, you will never improve. Practices make perfect.

It's a lots of teamwork and coordination we put in our raid.
We have done more than 6 Karnak after 1.6.1 and they are all gold, some members comment they start to like Karnak and it's getting more enjoyable, some says they still hate it but they will do phase 1 to help their own guild.
I just check my elixir. Not sure how do you take it off
Will have to wait 600 hours for it to expire.