Book of Heroes

Mega Topic: Low RPP Mercs/ Mercs Trapped in Raids · page 7

WeleaseWoderwick

Fri Sep 27, 2013 6:06 am
As well as a black list, it would be useful for Vets and above to have an instant "Kick from Raid" button if a skunk is spotted. This would free up the precious merc slot. The kicked person would lose all RPP and any contribution towards their raid participation feats.
100% for a black list. I would think for officers and GM. Raid kick sounds good, but could lead to problems on the other side where a player could get kicked for no valid reason other that the person that kicked them is just being an ass. There would have to be more to it than kick when you want.
I am all for the black list.. but.. kick.. might not be fair to the merc if some guild decided to kick all merc out so that the raid become "guild only" at ending. Some will have the opinion that the reputation might get bad that nobody will want to join the guild merc anymore..but.. well words might not really spread faster than the number of merc "con" for their efforts.. thus.. for all fairness, blacklist is the best option. At least the guild will only be con once by 1 user.. should be by user id and not toons.. :)

Is Venan going to take this suggestion seriouslY?

Bj_Knows

ModeratorSat Oct 5, 2013 9:12 am
Subject
Low RPP and Trapped or "Auto Join" Guild and Merc Issues (Posts 1- 8)

DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT

Overview
Raid Finder Tweaks would help reduce the problems caused by "Auto Join" for Guilds and Mercs,
Raid Ante requires 10e (or 20e) to enter a Raid with no password,
0 RPP after 30 minutes, refunds energy and removes Merc from Raid,
Intentionally Doomed Raids allow a Merc to Forfeit Raid after 30 min if <=675 RPP,
Less Guild members ready to Raid, or active in a Raid, temporarily lowers Merc Cap,
Add a "Read Chat" button to the list in Raid Finder,
When Gold Finish Expires, Merc Cap doubles,
When Silver Finish Expires, Merc Cap becomes 50.

Body
Raid Ante Option
To initially enter a Regular Raid in Raid Finder, with no password, requires 10 energy for squire Valor/ Soldier Valor Tier Raids and 20 Energy for Knight Valor/ Captain Valor Tier Raids. This Raid Ante would give you 5 (or 10) Combat Encounters before you had to pay additional energy. The initial cost is based on current Dungeons and Sigils in the game.

Purpose
The Raid Ante is to prevent Mercs from using "Auto Join" button to join 3 random regular Raids for 6 total Energy (3* 2e), then spending their remaining energy in Portals, Dungeons & Quests. They can still join multiple Raids, but this will encourage them to finish 5 (or 10) combats before leaving the Raid.

Details
A blurb will be required. Ex: "Enter 10e (2e x 5 combats)" or “Raid Ante requires 20e (2e x 10 combats)”. Alternatively, you could call it a Raid Bank. Ex: "Raid Bank requires 10e (2e x 5 combats)".

Once Silver Finish Raid Timer expires (2 or 3 hours based on Raid), the Raid Ante would be removed. At that time, a Regular Raid, with no password, would cost 2 Energy to Merc. This would allow characters with any amount of energy to join and attempt to save the Raid.

Raid Ante is removed if the Raid requires a Password to join. The Guild should only give the password to players it wants to bypass the Raid Ante.

Guilds that dislike the Raid Ante could password all their Raids, but place their password on the Guild Info page, which is visible to all players.

Raid Ante does not apply to Crypt of Corruption (all Onslaught) and Karnak's Final Stand (mostly Onslaught). These Raids are less dependent on Sigils and Energy Regeneration to complete the Raid.

continued in next seven Posts.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorSat Oct 5, 2013 9:12 am
Subject
Post 2

0 RPP Timer Option
A Raid would be checked every 5 minutes for 0 RPP Mercs. If any Merc has an RPP of 0, and has also been in the Raid longer than 30 minutes, the 0 RPP Merc would be refunded their initial energy and removed from the Raid.

Purpose
0 RPP Timer Option would open a Merc Slot if a player joins a Raid and then has communication issues or has to exit the Client Software due to real life. Since the slot is open, and the Merc's energy is refunded, if the Merc resolves their communication issue, they can still rejoin the Raid. Their RPP equals 0, so the Merc loses no Raid Rewards. The RPP is < 100, so the Guild cannot cycle alternative characters, and friends, through a Raid which has reached the Raid Cap or Merc Cap.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorSat Oct 5, 2013 9:12 am
Subject
Post 3

Forfeit Raid Merc Option
30 minutes after a Merc joins a Regular Raid in Raid Finder, with no password, the Server will check to see how much progress has been made on the Raid's Total Percentage Complete (RT%C). If it is less than 16%, and the Merc has <=675 RPP, then the character is given the option of exiting the intentionally doomed Raid. A "Forfeit Raid" button appears above "Leave" button and "Enter X (Energy)" button. "Forfeit Raid" button remains there for the rest of the intentionally doomed Raid.

Purpose
If a Merc joins a Raid, with no password, they can discover it is only for Guild Loyalty, or Material Drops, and be trapped in an intentionally doomed Raid for 4.5 hours. Since the Guild has no intention of finishing, the Raid will continue to trap the Merc, until the Bronze Finish Timer expires or a character in the Guild cancels the Raid. This is a bigger issue for Mercs using the “Auto Join” button since the algorithm is not as good as players in identifying Intentionally Doomed Raids. This also happens when a well-regarded Guild accidentally starts a Raid, since a Merc has to join the Guild to have access to Guild Chat.

No password, Intentionally Doomed Raids can have multiple causes- players not understanding Merc Setttings, a child accidentally starting a Raid on their parent's smartphone, new Veterans not understanding the benefits to their Guild reputation of putting a password on Raids they do not intend to finish.

30 minutes after the Merc joins, the Server will check the RT%C, if it has decreased 16%, or more, the Merc is locked into the Raid. If the merc has >675 RPP, the Merc is also locked into the Raid. 675 RPP represents the first 12 Energy spent in a Raid, or a normal character's Energy regeneration for 30 minutes. These qualifiers will help discourage Guilds from cycling alternate characters, and friends, through a Raid which has reached the Raid Cap or the Merc Cap.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorSat Oct 5, 2013 9:12 am
Subject
Post 5

Guild Chat Preview Option
Add a "Read Chat" button to the Raids listed in Raid Finder,
Password protected Raids would require the password to view Guild Chat in Raid Finder,
Players cannot post chat messages while viewing Guild Chat in Raid Finder,
Once a character joins a Raid in Raid Finder then they can post in chat.

Purpose
Read Chat in Raid Finder will give players more information. Often Guild Chat announces Guild Loyalty only Raids, Material Drop only Raids, Accidentally started Raids, etc.

This will also help Mercs who dislike Guild Chats with X-Rated language, dismissive of female gamers, or other chat behavior they find unacceptable.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorSat Oct 5, 2013 9:12 am
Subject
Post 6

Help Option
Once the Gold Finish Raid Timer expires, the Merc Cap is doubled.
Once the Silver Finish Raid Timer expires, the Merc Cap is raised to 50.
A message would appear in the Guild’s Officer Chat when it is doubled and again when it is raised to 50.

Purpose
Raising the Merc Cap allows more friends to help a struggling Raid. After the Silver Finish Timer expires, the Merc Cap is raised to 50% of the Raid Cap (50 Mercs).

Note: While I would prefer the Merc Cap increasing significantly after both Timers expire, Venan has expressed the desire for 25%/ 50%/ 25% balance of Gold/ Silver/ Bronze Raid Finishes. Many variations of the Help Option involve static scaling or dynamic scaling of Merc Cap to let Venan best maintain the desired ratio.

Bj_Knows
AKA Bj_the_SPOON AKA Bj_DWR AKA BjofCJandBj

In game FORUM button is poor. It is a mobile version with no search and limited lists. Good for reading Post #1 of a Sticky or Quoting a Post for copying text into an in-game Guild mail, but those two uses are it.
OR
Desktop computer or laptop computer and login to full web version with multiple searches and SEARCH for your question (quest solutions, known bugs, temp bug fixes, class builds, etc) at https://Venan.com/boh_forum/search.php

:geek:

DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT