Book of Heroes

Mega Topic: Low RPP Mercs/ Mercs Trapped in Raids · page 8

Bj_Knows

ModeratorSat Oct 5, 2013 11:55 am
From iPhone
Stub- Merc Setting Default

Current Default
Mercs Allowed= 50% Merc Cap
Password= "" (none)

Suggested Default
Mercs Allowed= 0
Password= Length$(String$(GuildName),10). First 10 letters of your Guild's Name's Name, Ex: "Warrior of" for "Warrior of the SPOON"
Bimbosigliere wrote:There is also inherent dangers in this by clueless vet, officers and gms. In another thread someone listed a player as a skunk than later said they raided there again and dropped full e, a one time occurrence does a skunk not make, but obviously some people will just jump to conclusions. People might go into raids with best of intentions then get called away by any number of things: work, children, connection issues, illness etc etc etc... Then you'll start reading posts about guilds who kick you from raids for no valid reason. So some thought really needs to go into what can be done.

I agree. There is any number of reasons someone might be a one or two time offender of being an accidental skunk. But there are those names that you come to recognize over and over and over again as being one hit wonders. Those people need to be stopped.

Perhaps it's a three strikes rule. You can only "mark" someone as a skunk on the specific raid they've skunked. After 3 strikes, they're added to the blacklist for your guild and cannot join in your raids.

Thoughts? Venan?
I've seen plenty of suggestions about how to deal with those persistent squatters which have probably annoyed most of us at some point. Some suggestions are better than others, but most seem to have a drawback or two, so here's my idea.

Every player has a merc rating. This could simply be a normalised value based on your historical mercing performance. I have ideas about how that could be calculated, but I guess anyone can come up with that, as long as if you do well in a raid your rating goes up, if you do badly (1 hit) it goes down a bit.

Then when a guild sets up raid options, there's a new option to set the minimum merc rating that they want, if any.

This way, people won't really be penalised for those odd times when your battery dies, your boss wants a word, or the wife/husband/partner makes an offer you can't refuse. However, those idiots who constantly one hit a raid will soon find they have no raids to join :D

There would, or course, also be bragging rights for a merc rating of 100, however it is calculated!

Famous_Fella_O_Nutella

Fri May 9, 2014 11:29 pm
That's a really great idea and makes it easy and fair. I really hope they consider it, it can't be that hard to implement.
merc rating isnt bad idea. but the question is indeed how it's calculated. for example there's at least one guild atm which isn't happy with me as a merc probably bcoz of my raiding style. despite my high rpp (near mvp spots generally ;)
so this guild will remain unhappy despite introducing merc rating which technically comes to serve them.

from the other side if u give the guild option to rate mercs manually they getting too much power vs mercs (in addition to password option)
john12345 wrote:merc rating isnt bad idea. but the question is indeed how it's calculated. for example there's at least one guild atm which isn't happy with me as a merc probably bcoz of my raiding style. despite my high rpp (near mvp spots generally ;)
so this guild will remain unhappy despite introducing merc rating which technically comes to serve them.

from the other side if u give the guild option to rate mercs manually they getting too much power vs mercs (in addition to password option)

Our raiding style is not well liked by several guilds. lol

But, I do like the merc rating.
I think that one should be able to abandon a raid they are mercing for, we should be able to cut our losses and run rather than having to wait it out or carry another guilds raid because THEY are doing bugger all.
I think the community would benifit from this overall.
all the guilds who do not participate in their own raids, thereby costing everyone energy, will fail to continue to benifit from the mercs who would otherwise move on to a successful raid, in essence penalizing the guild for lack of participation.