Book of Heroes

Mega Topic: Low RPP Mercs/ Mercs Trapped in Raids · page 9

CrzyHopper wrote:I agree however, this would only be fair if guilds could boot mercs that skunk raids.

Only downside to this is if i merc somewhere and they dont like me then im just screwed
It's a catch 22 situation.

But my opinion is, allow both leaving a raid when mercing (only mercing, not your own guild raid), and as a guild the GM should be allowed to boot deadbeat Mercs.

The only issue is that we can't control RL, so if something happens and a person has to stop playing for whichever reason, they will feel screwed, but at the same time, as a guild we can feel screwed because that toon isn't performing.. That's where the catch 22 comes in..

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorFri Jun 27, 2014 12:00 pm
Quite a few people have suggested that in order for 'booting' skunk mercs to be fair, there should be some targets set on what the merc must do.

Eg. One guild might set a minimum rpp of say 3500 (easily one energy bar for most folk), or a minimum number of total hits in the first few minutes. It should be a guilds prerogative to set a high or low target.

At the same time a merc should be able to abort his/her participation if s/he feels the need, but again within acceptable parameters such as only being able to bail out within the first 5-10mins. There should also be a set period within which a merc can't be summarily kicked just because the toon is that of a player a particular guild officer doesn't like (this would happen, lets not pretend it wouldn't). I'd suggest the first 10mins be an untouchable period that gives the merc a chance to hit the minimum while also giving them a window to free up the spot.

With a combination of these rules, it could help to address the problems some guilds see with skunk mercing.
Ilyana wrote:Quite a few people have suggested that in order for 'booting' skunk mercs to be fair, there should be some targets set on what the merc must do.

Eg. One guild might set a minimum rpp of say 3500 (easily one energy bar for most folk), or a minimum number of total hits in the first few minutes. It should be a guilds prerogative to set a high or low target.

At the same time a merc should be able to abort his/her participation if s/he feels the need, but again within acceptable parameters such as only being able to bail out within the first 5-10mins. There should also be a set period within which a merc can't be summarily kicked just because the toon is that of a player a particular guild officer doesn't like (this would happen, lets not pretend it wouldn't). I'd suggest the first 10mins be an untouchable period that gives the merc a chance to hit the minimum while also giving them a window to free up the spot.

With a combination of these rules, it could help to address the problems some guilds see with skunk mercing.


Very eloquently put and point well made
Yes, this is similar to the Sabotage Merc thread however I believe my suggestion will prevent abuse as well (such as kicking people, maintaining raid status and allowing "cycling" of mercs).

The theory is allowing GM's the ability to kick inactive mercs, with only specific criteria: after X amount of time (let's say 1 hr, perhaps adjustable per valor level) and < X RPP.

If a merc is not doing their part in a raid, would they not be considered deadweight? At least 1 full e dump should be, at a minimum, expected if you enter a raid scenario.

What I suggest allows GM's, and/or the Veteran responsible for the raid, to trim that deadweight. I would not even be opposed to a rollback of the minimal RPP or % of contribution, that the kicked raider was responsible for. Again, in efforts to prevent "cycling" or abuse of the system.

I know guilds who in-house raids care little about this, but for fledgling guilds who do rely on merc contribution, it is a serious matter when multiple mercs come in and are unwilling to reach even a minimum of 2k rpp. It could be the difference between a pass or fail.

Food for thought, please consider.

-GM_Konstantin of The Brass Tax
When mercing, it is always a crap shoot as to whether to join a guild's raid or not. When I merc, I go in not expecting to have the raid go gold, but hopeful. Most frequently, a raid will start strong only to have the guild members abandon it, leaving it to the mercs to finish it. I would like to see a stat on the raid selection page, showing the mean per centage (most common, not average) number of raids gold/silver/bonze and the mean total member contribution. The reverse side of this coin is to allow the guild to allow a merc to enter by showing the mercs number of raids and median rpp achieved.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorSat Jul 19, 2014 2:46 pm
This and other skunk merc options have been discussed a fair bit elsewhere (doesn't make it any less valid).
I agree. I've merc'd a lot and have run into this more often lately. I quit helping low valor guilds as well due to being left to finish the raids solo.
Honestly when my main mercs (which isn't very often) im in it for essence not valor so i could care less if the raids gold or fails