Book of Heroes

The Past Makes for a Brighter Future · page 2

Eli_Spoon wrote:

It seems apparent to me you are overly opinionated. As opposed to junking up peoples threads by saying the same thing 3 times why don't we use that energy and apply it to maybe something in the form of you writing your own thread as to why you feel that GL should stay. In regards to the "most" argument for example, until you actually get an answer from every player you arguing that "most" is unquantifiable means about as much as me saying "many" people is a specific number. Whats "many" 10? 20? of the thousands that played and quit these last 2 years. Trying to make yourself sound overly intelligent by making claims that have no credibility and hold no apparent evidence is a waste of energy. As I said anyone can come on a thread and bash it sure. However what Ive seen from you thus far is you have made no positive suggestions and have given no recommendations or ideas that support your argument. I myself don't respond to other peoples threads by saying this sucks and i hate this ! At least have a point! Saying my idea isn't in your best interest isn't a "point"...So to entertain your comment about how you argue the myriad of threads why don't you make it a point to be pro-active and start a thread of your own instead of being counter productive in voicing your opinion on all the threads cause it isn't self serving.


Well gee. That told me. I'll be sure to keep my opinions to myself in future... in an open conversation on a public forum...

To address your specific points before I withdraw from this thread in the face of the hostility I seem to be provoking with my disagreement...
- "overly opinionated": Maybe. Willing to disagree or agree publicly? Definitely. I support ideas, or I disagree with them. That's what these threads are for. IMO, of course.
- I didn't intend to "junk up" a thread. I made my initial post. Then I responded to people directly addressing me.
- "Most" is defined as over 50%. It's defined, and cannot be proven in this instance. "Many" indicates only a substantial number, but an undefined and deliberately vague one. Lots of people aim for, and discuss GL and guild perks, therefore I believe "many" is not out of place or inappropriate.
- I haven't made any suggestions because I personally believe the GL system works ok. If anything, I personally believe that the 10% penalty is too low, and would like to see more perks, but that's another topic.
- "Trying to make yourself sound overly intelligent..." I was trying to do no such thing. I was simply stating that I believed your claim of "most players" to be misleading.
- I did not respond to this thread saying "This sucks! I hate this!" - I responded that I disagreed and gave reasons for my disagreement.
- I haven't voiced my opinion in any of the other threads on this subject. I've started to write a few times, and been distracted before posting.
- I haven't made an "I like GL thread", but maybe I will - thanks for the suggestion.

I'll post no further, in order to avoid BJ having to write "Keep it civil!" in the title.
DreamingDaemon wrote:
They'd die even more often if players had no investment into the guild. New players are much more fickle, and many would jump ship at the first bronze raid to another guild if there was no incentive to stay.

I bought up 3 toons in the pre-loyalty world and it was much, much easier. Guilds survived just fine. The only reason didn't seem that way was in late 2012, BoH was bleeding players right and left.
As far as the most point goes, I have spoken to dozens of old players on this topic. You are the FIRST to disagree with the stance. Now, I am beginning to wonder if you really even disagree or just trolling.

I won't use the word most on this topic. I would use the phrase ALMOST ALL and feel quite good about that as being accurate.
Lets poll it...Let everyone speak for themselves.

I for the record do not like the current guild loyalty structure. I would like to see a change as described in my previous post.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon Apr 7, 2014 4:43 am
I don't think GL is the real issue here. People used to guild hop with free abandon, to merc or just visit. But the main reason anyone had to hop guilds was to join another raid, whether in their own alliance or at a friend's guild.

Then came the war on mercs and a active campaign to make things more difficult for them. I merced a lot in 1.5 before finding a home guild and IMO that system worked very well. I'm sick of hearing that raids were 'too easy' in the old guild system...so what. If they're too easy, make them harder but leave the old guild system intact.

The loyalty system gives you great perks. I don't think that should be sacrificed in the name of guild bouncing. However what should happen is giving players the option of more easily 'dropping in' on their friend's guilds. Make the mercing system more friendly. In addition, someone should be able to search for a guild, select that guild's chat, and jump in depending on that guild's preferences (completely independent of whether that guild is actually raiding).

Generally in the old system, you had to know when a raid was about to begin in order to jump in and raid with that guild. This is the same now, except that if you miss the open slots - tough on you, no joining that raid unless you take a loyalty hit.

Please, please fix the merc system. Give control of it back to the guilds and people can drop in for a friend's raid again like we did in 1.5. Sometimes I get the feeling that things that aren't broken in this game are getting 'fixed' while genuine problems aren't.

Eli_Snugglesworth

Mon Apr 7, 2014 4:58 am
Ilyana wrote:I don't think GL is the real issue here. People used to guild hop with free abandon, to merc or just visit. But the main reason anyone had to hop guilds was to join another raid, whether in their own alliance or at a friend's guild.

Then came the war on mercs and a active campaign to make things more difficult for them. I merced a lot in 1.5 before finding a home guild and IMO that system worked very well. I'm sick of hearing that raids were 'too easy' in the old guild system...so what. If they're too easy, make them harder but leave the old guild system intact.

The loyalty system gives you great perks. I don't think that should be sacrificed in the name of guild bouncing. However what should happen is giving players the option of more easily 'dropping in' on their friend's guilds. Make the mercing system more friendly. In addition, someone should be able to search for a guild, select that guild's chat, and jump in depending on that guild's preferences (completely independent of whether that guild is actually raiding).

Generally in the old system, you had to know when a raid was about to begin in order to jump in and raid with that guild. This is the same now, except that if you miss the open slots - tough on you, no joining that raid unless you take a loyalty hit.

Please, please fix the merc system. Give control of it back to the guilds and people can drop in for a friend's raid again like we did in 1.5. Sometimes I get the feeling that things that aren't broken in this game are getting 'fixed' while genuine problems aren't.

Definately 2nd the above... And definately need re-tooling on the search engines. A couple friends I searched for took quite a while before I found them just to find they had stopped playing. I know this sounds ridiculously simple but i almost guarantee that if you were to bring back the ease of moving around within all the numerous guilds (pre 1.5) it would promote longevity in players. (Especially veteran players) !! This game is personalized and very fine-tuned to the player in every way. If there is going to be so much detail involved with specs and enhancements and percentages then filtering names shouldnt be much to ask. Just saying If there could be a simple filtering system as well that would be awesome !!
Hi im salad and Raiden cured my guild hopping.... (Took away the leave guild button) Oh well.... Happens but going back to this thread i do like the perks but 8 extra e and 10% more valor isnt worth the fun times i had pre Gl I dont know how many of yall were around at the time but PoF speed Ck runs ^_^ and invading guilds as mercs, it was a total blast. I know venan and they are a good company but, im about 90% sure that Gl will be here forever.

_Salad
Eli_Spoon wrote:Id be willing to give up the 8e to be able to help other guilds freely.
Eli Spoon

Let me get this straight, you are willing to lose 8e but you aren't willing to just leave your guild for a bit and only lose 4e :roll: . This is just senseless sir, there is no reason to remove GL and lose all the benefits. If we leave it and you leave your guild, at least you get to keep some of those benefits.
Bimbosigliere wrote:So I was driving to work today and I got a wee bit exasperated with trying to get past level 7 in candy crush, so I thought to myself, "hey, check out what's been going on in your old BoH game!" After spending a few minutes to get my main to level 33, since it must have been accidentally overlooked by shekka, I decided to check out my old forum stomping grounds. Sadly I see no current posts by Mith, which says to me he must have gotten as bored with it as I had. I gave some thought to trying out the new raid, but then decided against it, since I've been playing vicariously through Ciazanna for awhile now, and since he seems to have reached max might (congrats cia!!) I therefore have nothing else to play for!! So instead I took a poll of 273,485 current players to ask them their opinion on the GL system currently in place. I bypassed noobs, people on my ignore list, and hypocritical self righteous toons. I discovered that 97.4% of people would like to be able to freely roam the expanse of Glenfort. Now, my IQ is hardly above the required 9+ of global, but I'd believe that percentage meets the definition to be quantifiable for either "most" or "many." Therefore, Eli wins, and should therefore be considered the emperor of the forums in the absence of Mith and myself.

Okay, I'm almost at work now. Gonna give level 7 another shot!! Wish me luck!!

P.S. I also took it upon myself to poll on who thinks Canadians should be barred from the game until they take back Bieber. Sorry, Shekka, but the masses have spoken!! Try candy crush!!


You already can roam freely, that is what the noobs, and a couple of us end-gamers are saying. You just lose SOME of the benefits that you are proposing we lose ALL of. It truly is a purposeless endeavor.

Oh and good luck.