Book of Heroes

The Past Makes for a Brighter Future

Eli_Snugglesworth

Sun Apr 6, 2014 1:21 pm
Having seen all the changes and unnecessary changes over the last two years Ive noticed one subject that keeps resurfacing... Thats the freedom to move from guild to guild without repercussion or recourse. MOST players loved being able to move around and if you are hoping that all the vets will quit so all the new players never knew those days existed try again! At first we had 50% of our GL taken away and then it was tweaked to now where its at 500 points lost for moving to a new guild. Why make a deterrent for leaving from one guild to another... Who are you fooling? It doesnt stop anyone it just irritates them!! I understand that at one point maybe the GvG concept was the reason behind GL but how about until you actually launch GvG in an update you leave things alone!!! Id be willing to give up the 8e to be able to help other guilds freely. I dont know the logic in the decision of hindering players from helping or mercing freely but I actually enjoyed helping a guild who was struggling in a raid or saving gold or silver cause their own members were asleep or had to work etc. Hate to say Venan but you took away our freedom from that aspect, and if you are tired of reading these threads in the forums now we have something im common cause im tired of writing them!!

Eli Spoon
For the record, I don't want to give up my perks, be they stat boosts or energy, so people can go say hi to each other without losing a perk they want to take away from everyone.

"Most" players is an unquantifiable statement. Many end-game players may resent Guild Loyalty because of the restrictions, but many non-end-game players appreciate the boosts, and non-top-tier guilds appreciate the extra effort their members put in to get higher levels of loyalty, or to unlock the next perk.
DreamingDaemon wrote:
"Most" players is an unquantifiable statement. Many end-game players may resent Guild Loyalty because of the restrictions, but many non-end-game players appreciate the boosts, and non-top-tier guilds appreciate the extra effort their members put in to get higher levels of loyalty, or to unlock the next perk.

As having some non-end game toons, it is even worse. The low/mid-tier guilds die all the time and you have to switch guilds.
Why not just have players pick a default guild and no matter how many times they leave they don't lose loyalty unless they choose a different guild as a default. You lose the favors going to other guilds but get them back when you're "home"
B4Play wrote:
DreamingDaemon wrote:
"Most" players is an unquantifiable statement. Many end-game players may resent Guild Loyalty because of the restrictions, but many non-end-game players appreciate the boosts, and non-top-tier guilds appreciate the extra effort their members put in to get higher levels of loyalty, or to unlock the next perk.

As having some non-end game toons, it is even worse. The low/mid-tier guilds die all the time and you have to switch guilds.

They'd die even more often if players had no investment into the guild. New players are much more fickle, and many would jump ship at the first bronze raid to another guild if there was no incentive to stay.
Any player 'stuck' in a dead guild knows they're not going to progress, so they have to move if they wish to do so. Having the loyalty penalty reduced to a maximum 500pts means that this is pretty easily regained - a few days, a week at most in an active new guild.

For all the people who want to take Guild Loyalty away (from everyone!) - if you don't like it, and don't want it in the game, why don't you just ignore it and move around as you like? Why is it such a big deal that everyone else has to lose it too? If the bonuses counted in PvP, I'd understand more, but seeing as they don't, I'm at a loss. It's not like there aren't a bunch of ways to communicate with people.

Eli_Snugglesworth

Sun Apr 6, 2014 4:15 pm
DreamingDaemon wrote:
B4Play wrote:
DreamingDaemon wrote:
"Most" players is an unquantifiable statement. Many end-game players may resent Guild Loyalty because of the restrictions, but many non-end-game players appreciate the boosts, and non-top-tier guilds appreciate the extra effort their members put in to get higher levels of loyalty, or to unlock the next perk.

As having some non-end game toons, it is even worse. The low/mid-tier guilds die all the time and you have to switch guilds.

They'd die even more often if players had no investment into the guild. New players are much more fickle, and many would jump ship at the first bronze raid to another guild if there was no incentive to stay.
Any player 'stuck' in a dead guild knows they're not going to progress, so they have to move if they wish to do so. Having the loyalty penalty reduced to a maximum 500pts means that this is pretty easily regained - a few days, a week at most in an active new guild.

For all the people who want to take Guild Loyalty away (from everyone!) - if you don't like it, and don't want it in the game, why don't you just ignore it and move around as you like? Why is it such a big deal that everyone else has to lose it too? If the bonuses counted in PvP, I'd understand more, but seeing as they don't, I'm at a loss. It's not like there aren't a bunch of ways to communicate with people.

First off id like to ask you to read the post a little closer. In the first place it wasn't written specifically for you so being so defensive is a tad pointless. Secondly i said "most people LOVED" referring to players who have quit this past year, and lastly i said i would be "willing" to give up my 8e to do this not that i just want to! Its all good to have a rebuttal to a thread but please at least know what you're reading before you make a stand opposing it ! Thanks!
Eli_Spoon wrote:
First off id like to ask you to read the post a little closer. In the first place it wasn't written specifically for you so being so defensive is a tad pointless. Secondly i said "most people LOVED" referring to players who have quit this past year, and lastly i said i would be "willing" to give up my 8e to do this not that i just want to! Its all good to have a rebuttal to a thread but please at least know what you're reading before you make a stand opposing it ! Thanks!

I did read the post. You referenced other posts on the same subject in your closing - so did I.
I never indicated it was written specifically for me. I stated my opinion on the matter - that I don't consider it a worthwhile sacrifice of my guild perks (for my toons in guilds) for what seems to be a small number of end-game toons to swap guilds multiple times a day without losing that same perk that they want everyone to lose. Not particularly defensively, imo, but I guess that's subjective on the part of the reader.
You said "most people loved" - I stated that use of the word "most" is unquantifiable. You have no way of evidencing that aside from what some people say now. I said that "many players..." because it's quantifiable, many people DO like the GL system, as evidenced by the people taking part in it. I won't say "most" because I can't evidence it.

In conclusion, I'd say I was rebutting both against this OP, and the myriad of other threads saying that Guild Loyalty should be removed from the game.
Thanks!
Having played the game now for just about 1 year I personally feel we should go back to the way it was when everyone was free to come and go as they pleased without fear of losing 8e, the point made in the first reply about losing the"perks" does not stand because when you joined a guild you received the lvl favours that guild was on, the only thing player's would lose is 8e, but at the time max e was 42 anyway. Indeed it is with the lvl the guild is at for the "perks" they would gain and the only way to gain them was to be successful in raids therefore having end game players coming into a guild to help would gain that guild extra power to open new area's. So birng back the old ways and im sure more guilds would see success.

Eli_Snugglesworth

Sun Apr 6, 2014 5:06 pm
DreamingDaemon wrote:
Eli_Spoon wrote:
First off id like to ask you to read the post a little closer. In the first place it wasn't written specifically for you so being so defensive is a tad pointless. Secondly i said "most people LOVED" referring to players who have quit this past year, and lastly i said i would be "willing" to give up my 8e to do this not that i just want to! Its all good to have a rebuttal to a thread but please at least know what you're reading before you make a stand opposing it ! Thanks!

I did read the post. You referenced other posts on the same subject in your closing - so did I.
I never indicated it was written specifically for me. I stated my opinion on the matter - that I don't consider it a worthwhile sacrifice of my guild perks (for my toons in guilds) for what seems to be a small number of end-game toons to swap guilds multiple times a day without losing that same perk that they want everyone to lose. Not particularly defensively, imo, but I guess that's subjective on the part of the reader.
You said "most people loved" - I stated that use of the word "most" is unquantifiable. You have no way of evidencing that aside from what some people say now. I said that "many players..." because it's quantifiable, many people DO like the GL system, as evidenced by the people taking part in it. I won't say "most" because I can't evidence it.

In conclusion, I'd say I was rebutting both against this OP, and the myriad of other threads saying that Guild Loyalty should be removed from the game.
Thanks!

It seems apparent to me you are overly opinionated. As opposed to junking up peoples threads by saying the same thing 3 times why don't we use that energy and apply it to maybe something in the form of you writing your own thread as to why you feel that GL should stay. In regards to the "most" argument for example, until you actually get an answer from every player you arguing that "most" is unquantifiable means about as much as me saying "many" people is a specific number. Whats "many" 10? 20? of the thousands that played and quit these last 2 years. Trying to make yourself sound overly intelligent by making claims that have no credibility and hold no apparent evidence is a waste of energy. As I said anyone can come on a thread and bash it sure. However what Ive seen from you thus far is you have made no positive suggestions and have given no recommendations or ideas that support your argument. I myself don't respond to other peoples threads by saying this sucks and i hate this ! At least have a point! Saying my idea isn't in your best interest isn't a "point"...So to entertain your comment about how you argue the myriad of threads why don't you make it a point to be pro-active and start a thread of your own instead of being counter productive in voicing your opinion on all the threads cause it isn't self serving.
I'm of mixed thoughts on this one, but I agree. GL seems to have provided a solution to a problem that didn't exist. While I really dislike the arbitrary limits set on certain areas of the game and would like to see an expansion on the loyalty system (in the same way I'd like to see captain's and champion's sigils, or a ht cap increase), I do enjoy the ability to visit other guilds just to catch up and chat. I still do, but the annoyance caused by losing loyalty and/or forcing the guild to open a baby raid with passworded merc slots is just a hassle. I agree with Eli and especially with crzy's solution. It would be nice to have a "designated" home guild for the purpose of favors, bonuses, and guild vs. guild events one day, while retaining the ability to visit other guild chats.