Book of Heroes

The Past Makes for a Brighter Future · page 3

I miss the madness of saving ailing raids or being in a saved raid.
All the time meeting new people. Of course I can still guild hop now, but it's only fun if everybody is doing it :-D
Mercing was fun.

Cletus

ModeratorMon Apr 7, 2014 5:18 pm
Ok... I will only start by saying that Cletus is not as smart as Eli and Bims but let me lend my two cents...

I think "a lot" (will not say most to avoid that argument) of end game players are slowly losing interest in the game and leaving. For months I have talked and exchanged ideas with friends that feel frustrated about the direction of the game.. People blame guild loyalty. People blame PvP. People blame lack of updates. People blame lack of communication from the devs.. Feel free to add any other complaints that you may have..

I honestly feel, after playing for over a year (yes I know I'm still a noob compared to some of you) that we have to realize that the game is limited to what it can give us. I mean really, just in case no knows (spoilers) the next update will have a new area, some new quests (doing the same stuff), a new dungeon, and maybe a new raid. What else would you expect? A new game???

Lets face it, we are grasping for anything we can to find a reason why BoH is losing old players. I don't say this to attack Venan, Its just the truth. Seems like everyday I hear that a friend is not playing any longer. It saddens me because the only reason "a lot" of us log in is to chat with friends. As this is the first MMO I have ever played it has really surprised me that I have made friends, all over the world, that I will call friend for the rest of my life.

So back to the original post. If guild loyalty disappeared tomorrow and we could roam freely without losing perks would it save the game?? In my opinion, No... You can say, I don't care about losing the 8e or the extra valor, but if that was true then what is stopping you? (BTW I only read like the first two lines of the original post cause I assume I know everything Eli will say :D )Venan doesn't say you have to stay in a guild, they say if you do, you get a bonus. Honestly, Eli my friend, I think we just long for the days when we enjoyed the game as much as we enjoy the people.

I don't know the answer and like I stated above this is my first and only MMO. I'm sure every game like this has a similar problem with end gamers.

- Cletus

***PAID ADVERTISEMENT***
~CLETUS 4 MOD 2015~
Well Cletus, Thanks you for adding fuel to both fires without trying to put one out.
It seems like the issue everyone is talking about could be fixed with a couple of minor changes:

1. Do away with the power bonus for completing a raid completely 'in house'.
2. Allow the guild to set the number of mercs much higher: 99 (or however many spots are left after 100 minus current raid participants).

That way, guilds no longer have a reason to close their raids (other than to keep the rpp for their members), and there's really no limit to how many toons can come in and help in a raid. People can roam all they want then, and keep their guild loyalty. Guilds then have the option to let virtually anyone in without having to accept their temporary membership.
While I personally like your ideas Nightcrawler, I don't think Venan is going to do the second one. I suspect they view the raider limit as a way to force more GS usage. Remember the horrible weeks where the total number of raiders was limited and we had to beg them to allow unlimited members in the raid.

Another thing that would help is to eliminate raid cool down. I have been playing almost 2 years now and I have never heard the reasoning about why cool down exists.

Marvel_Contest_of_Champions

Tue Apr 8, 2014 2:42 pm
Hai5 wrote:I agree power and prestige mean nothing nowadays. I remember when 1.3 was first introduced, for several months until 1.4, there was no such thing as merc. There was no auto-accept option. All players had to file application first before GM or Officers decide to accept them into the guild. There were competitions back then where power and prestige actually reflected how strong guilds were. It was fun and competitive. Good old days. Now, with mercs roaming around freely, guilds are advertising for mercs just so they can finish raids on time. Power and prestige mean nothing

Guild vs merc: time to decide

This game will never go back the way it was even if GL is removed. Good o' days...
If GL were removed, to me there wont be guilds, just bunch of game rooms

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorTue Apr 8, 2014 3:44 pm
Star_Citizen_Coming_Soon wrote:
Hai5 wrote:I agree power and prestige mean nothing nowadays. I remember when 1.3 was first introduced, for several months until 1.4, there was no such thing as merc. There was no auto-accept option. All players had to file application first before GM or Officers decide to accept them into the guild. There were competitions back then where power and prestige actually reflected how strong guilds were. It was fun and competitive. Good old days. Now, with mercs roaming around freely, guilds are advertising for mercs just so they can finish raids on time. Power and prestige mean nothing

Guild vs merc: time to decide

This game will never go back the way it was even if GL is removed. Good o' days...
If GL were removed, to me there wont be guilds, just bunch of game rooms

No. Things were never like that in 1.5, when people could merc and move about freely. The setup back then was very friendly, you had your 'home' guild but could flit to another to help out their raid.

I remember the horrendous start to 1.6. That happened because people weren't consulted. Nobody was asked whether GL was something that sounded like a good idea. If we had been, you would've seen a resounding 'no' (in my opinion). The perks are great, but the overall model still needs tweaking so the whole player base is satisfied.
Pls let me agree with Cletus, guys. Sure, GL is a convenient scapegoat, but let's face it, we are bored and want to re-enact our finest moments as if they never happened. This is hardly possible. I seriously doubt that removing GL will immediately bring back the good old days. K.. for a few days there could be some cheerful hopping from guild to guild (i.e. Lob to Lob, but that's what we're up to anyway) but then what? Same old.

My point is that a rollback like this is not going to work. What could work is something new. Something major like past innovations - introduction of guilds, gems, enchants, etc. Something of this caliber.

I just hope Venan is silent because they're up to smth big like this, not another boss / raid plus a bunch of quests..

Cletus

ModeratorTue Apr 8, 2014 9:16 pm
Grnm wrote:Pls let me agree with Cletus, guys.

LOOK!! Someone actually agreed with Cletus!! :) Thanks Grnm!!

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorWed Apr 9, 2014 5:11 am
Grnm wrote:Pls let me agree with Cletus, guys. Sure, GL is a convenient scapegoat, but let's face it, we are bored and want to re-enact our finest moments as if they never happened. This is hardly possible. I seriously doubt that removing GL will immediately bring back the good old days. K.. for a few days there could be some cheerful hopping from guild to guild (i.e. Lob to Lob, but that's what we're up to anyway) but then what? Same old.

My point is that a rollback like this is not going to work. What could work is something new. Something major like past innovations - introduction of guilds, gems, enchants, etc. Something of this caliber.

I just hope Venan is silent because they're up to smth big like this, not another boss / raid plus a bunch of quests..

GL is a raid issue that is causing problems and needs to be tweaked. It largely isn't responsible for malaise - that's something separate and nothing short of an entire rework of the game is going to cure bored people. New raids and quests don't seem to be doing it for them, nor is starting/returning to their lower might toons..