Ilyana wrote:Couldn't agree more. Honestly Eric's ideas make the most sense. Nev says the same thing every time - where are these mythical Justicars that have 'got it right' and are trashing mages? I suspect they only exist when fighting certain players 
Basically the justicars that have gotten it figured out. Cool, Purao, Leaxia, Kieran, Aphrodite, Mac, Muddz. Naming a few at 30k or higher might range. Can't comment on any lower.
A WM simply does no significant damage if there's no negative status on the enemy. No chill/stun = no control/no decent damage on shattering force. No fractures/magma = no damage multiplier. No burning = no dot dps, and lousy fireblast damage. WM are most reliant on status effects for damage, unlike the other two classes (I mean they do need some negative statuses too, but by far they need it less than a WM).
Any justicar who knows that he has to start with jugg and use heroic will to keep jugg up consecutively with/after stunning blow to prevent a wm from landing any chill/stun/fracture/burning until ALL the justi's cooldowns are done, will be able to dish out 30k damage (with a 2hand wpn) and probably a 2 or 3 bleed stack before a WM can even land a proper negative status effect like chill, or a setup a painful attack like 2 to 3 fire fractures + incinerate. Just pick up your justicar at any might range (I've tried with my 18k might justi and it works out fine) and do an opening rotation where jugg is kept up consecutively in between stuns/kb. It's as simple as that. You get a huge advantage over the WM easily. Throw in status resist gear to cover the JC during downtime of jugg (which has a laughably low cooldown of 4 seconds + affected by heroic will) and it's the PERFECT counter to a WM.
The problem is JC have a significant advantage vs WM, just like how WM have a significant advantage versus SW. Of course I'm not saying it's a 100% win rate, but the skew makes it close to like 70-30 chance of winning in the matchup. It's the cold hard truth. Anybody who disagrees, I'll just humbly say, that you lack sufficient good pvp experience. I am not truly complaining, in the sense that, if the meta stays this way I'm fine. I'll just earn my wins off SW while JC will earn their wins off me. Since there are generally more SW pvping than JC, I'll come out better ahead any way. But is this the kind of rock-paper-scissors balance that we want, or do we want balance that's more holistic? That's something Venan has to decide and work on.
The data is skewed only because there aren't enough pvpers of a certain class for the truth, or that people aren't playing with the right gear/specs/rotation. Quantitative data is far from accurate in explaining the way data turns out the way they do. In such situations, qualitative data is better than quantitative. There's no point collecting quantitative data to justify results if half the server isn't specced right, or bothered to figure out proper pvp rotations. You won't get true balance if you're basing your data off bad fights.
My personal view is that WMs tend to start off more easily now in the current PvP meta because their tools for pve are largely ok in PvP. This is alot like the previous pvp meta when SW were mostly dominating the PvP leaderboard at the start. Back then, 1 hand weapons were the KEY to PvP (before 2h mastery skill came out), and thus SW could easily enter PvP with an edge without changing enchants/gears.
Hence similarly, in the current meta, more WMs win when they begin pvp as opposed to the other 2 classes because 2hand specs are entirely viable, and WMs skills in PvE are useful in PvP as well. E.g., I would be surprised if a JC has 3 points jugg and heroic will in his PvE build; this is something you have to purposely spec for in pvp. This causes JC and SW new pvpers to get turned off and quit instead of building up a proper pvp spec. Hence the data skew.
The WM vs JC matchup can be improved tremedously with one simple change. Choose any of the 3 options below.
1. Make snap cast usable right at the start like heroic will/jugg, so a WM can try to slow the JC immediately before he starts his horrible jugg/knockback chains

But that would make SW cry that much harder lol.
2. Alternatively, slap a 1 second starting cooldown on juggernaut as well, so that a JC has less "invulnerability" at the start, and forces him to use his heroic will even earlier.
3. Or, prevent juggernaut from being affected by heroic will.