Book of Heroes

mages are overpowered! · page 4

japster wrote:
Ilyana wrote:Exactly the kind of thing I expected from you, Japster. People who don't agree with you 'haven't had enough PvP experience'. The numbers disagree with you, so somehow the numbers must be wrong.

If you think you have a way of gathering 'qualitative' metrics in PvP, then go ahead and tell Venan. I suspect however that nobody does, so you have to fall back on good old-fashioned actual data that actually exists, rather than speculative 'qualitative' data that nobody can actually produce or reproduce.

People were left extremely disappointed with PvP thanks to the 2.0 changes (well, anyone who wasn't a WM player that is). This is an inherent problem with not separating the PvE and PvP sides of the game.

Suggesting that the data that shows WM being too far ahead (which it does) is down to people fighting in PvE specs is just flatly wrong. We get spikes in PvP uptake during lottery events, and that is truly when people fight in their PvE specs. One of the only other times was when PvP first arrived and people were still trying to figure out what to use in their PvP builds or hasn't gotten a 2nd spec yet.

Ceka is one of the most experienced pvpers out there, I think he's the one Venan should be talking to regarding PvP and WM balance. I think until the update we should all take his advice and just wait and see as this debate is clearly going nowhere. Until the balance is addressed, you will keep seeing posts with similar titles to this one...kinda tells you something. Feel free to jump in any time, devs, it would be nice to see one of you on here a little more :-)

And this is exactly what I would expect from Ilyana posting about PvP. You're always falling back on the almighty Venan quantitative data, except that if I ask you to describe such data to all of us, you're going to be lost for words besides Venan's simple answer of "WMs are slightly ahead".

Anybody who has studied basic statistics will know that's not even a proper answer in itself. How are WMs slightly ahead? What are the data/sample size used to make such a statement? What are the parameters and stratification? Are the players stratified in terms of whether they are using PvP or PvE builds? Unfortunately, Venan is absolutely mum about the details. Thus it is entirely justified for players to question the validity of their sweeping statements and be skeptical of their quantitative data. Why should we rely on Venan's words when they don't explain their data? Quantitative data has no predictive or explanatory power whatsoever if they are collected erroneously, and they certainly do not explain anything to people unless such data is made known. Hence why straw polls in the media are generally worthless because most don't even explain the sampling sizes or the confidence interval.

For example, if Venan's quantitative data was so perfect, they wouldn't have messed up on the difficulty level of HM vis-a-vis it's payout. If it was perfect, they wouldn't have messed up Ice Lance in the past (a few versions back), flip-flopping its knockback. I do not disagree that Venan makes corrections when they detect it, but to solely depend on quantitative data is to be balancing with blinders over one eye.

Venan should utilize statistics and maths for a broad picture, but they also have to look towards qualitative-types of data such as exploring individual characters/classes and seeing if a certain class or build does exceedingly well against another in particular circumstances, and question if such is intended. Venan has access to all our character toons. They can and they do use our toons to fight each other, at least that's what I know they did before PvP was even released. Thus my suggestion is that they should just pull up the top few JCs and pit them against the top few WMs, and try the rotations I mention. That's qualitative data for you in this context. Instead of balancing based on broad statistics, they could also experiment balancing by playing specific builds and matchups of active players of each class and might range, and ascertain for themselves the matchup players of each might range experience with various skill builds (e.g. pvp v pvp build, pve v pvp build, pve v pve build etc). Maybe Venan does do such qualitative testing, but they have been silent about it so we can only assume that they do not take such experiences into consideration, hence my post. Of course qualitative data is fallible too, just like quantitative. What's important is that we keep posting here, and hopefully Venan notes our views and takes them into consideration. And if we're lucky, Venan would actually be more willing to explain their methods, manners, and rationale. Although the recent knowledge of Venan nerfing hp may suggest that Venan is oblivious to high-end PvP, or maybe unconcerned about it at all, as explained excellently by Ceka in the above post.

Like I said earlier, the current PvP meta is one where WM chew up SW and JC chew up WM. I think SW have an edge over JC, but that's one matchup I lack sufficient real experience hence I make no certain comment on that. Nonetheless, is that the kind of rock-paper-scissors balance that Venan wants? It is a kind of balance no doubt, but is this what Venan wants? That's the original question which I posed that you have seemed to missed entirely.

I can remove my personal remark of "good pvp experience", but that doesn't change the bulk of my post, to which you have failed to answer at all. Qualitative data exists. It's here in this forums. It's there in Venan's test server. With regard to Ceka, I agree that Ceka is an experienced PvPer, and I will concur with his post subsequent to my previous, insofar that I did not mention the WM best case scenario.

But I put it to Ceka, and to public for the record, that I do not disagree at all that a WM can beat a JC. But Ceka (please correct me if I am wrong) is of the experience that he wins about 60-70% of the time as a 2hand WM against top JC like Purao. I flatly disagree. I have had no such experience and I cannot fathom a proper rotation that would achieve that with the current statistics. I can win Purao too, but certainly not within even a 50/50 range, and once he throws on status resist gear, it's almost impossible.

I did state in my first post that the win rate in a WM-JC matchup is probably about a 70-30 chance in favor of JC. Why? Because as Ceka himself has implicitly admitted, the crux to winning as a WM is DODGE. Dodging that crucial seismic at the start especially. Therefore a WM's win rate against a JC is dramatically improved based on his chance to dodge. I.e. his dodge stat directly increases his chance of winning. 30% dodge = 30% chance of winning by dodging crucial KB attacks. Even if we ramp dodge stat to 40% with almost all yellow and white slots with dodge (which is about 11 dodge gems, the closest to a realistic max dodge stat without sacrificing hp), it's still not even a half chance of 50%.

The best case, as Ceka rightfully pointed out, is to dodge seismic + resist the stun (let's keep it simple without calculating the probability of the JC resisting our debuffs out of jugg if he's wearing status resist gear). If the WM has approximately 30% dodge and resist (which is probably an easy average, although the better geared will be at 35% dodge/resist), the odds of both of that happening would simply be about 9%. What are the odds of that?

And like I said, once the JC throws in status resist gear, your chance of winning as a WM drops dramatically even if you do dodge the crucial seismic or brutal, because you have to factor in the JC resisting your crucial slows/stuns/fractures/magma etc. And when you stack dodge…don't get me started on 9k backswing crits when the JC has 3 vengeance. It's the perfect way for the JC to pull the fight to the end when a WM finally gets control after taking over 30k damage to his hp.

I don't create my personal experience out of thin air. The 70-30 skew exists because it not only feels right from personal experience, but it corresponds roughly to my dodge stat. I await PvP replays in the next patch, and will eagerly watch if Ceka does indeed best Purao 7 out of 10 times like he claims, instead of the reverse (assuming nothing major changes to the meta balance). Ceka has agreed to show me such, and I anxiously await mind-blowing fights from a top-notch PvPer like Ceka. I know the tactic of going into defend nearing the end of the timer, but it really doesn't guarantee much from experience, and I get painful backswings in my face.

P.S. Ilyana, I've mentioned various top JC names. I've unmasked the "mystical" JCs who do well against WMs. Please go talk to them and ask them if they do think they get an edge over WMs in general. I don't mean that they must thrash WMs 100% of the time, but I think they would all agree they can dish out 30k hp to a WM and leave 2 to 3 bleeds on them at least half the time before a WM can even use his snapcast/icy grasp effectively, or land a negative status effect. That IS the main reason why WMs have to stack hp in the current meta if not we wouldn't stand a chance whatsoever.

Right between the eyes! Japster says pretty much what I think, spot on. Kudos for truth, japster!
Just. Nevla trolls everything and repeat always the same thing. Never take seriously what nevla said. You can have a headache if you continue to discuss ilyana :D
Didn't read any of this thread but the first page and Nevla said Justi is op and i laughed Nevla you do have 54k hp thats ridicoulous .... Just saying
Yeah, Jugger OP. It should be nerfed to 35 percent status resist, if that. Snap cast should be available at the very beggining of the fight to compensate for this, and spell cast through snap cast should ignore status resist. That way the slow effect would be applied at the beggining of the fight and make it fair.
Alternatively, the cooldown could be reduced to 1 sec or 1.5 sec, keeping the ability of ignoring status resist mentioned above. Status resist on gear grants an advantage to the other classes over WM, which depends on status effects, thus leaving the Wm at a disadvantage. Such a change will counter this.
Ice lance knockback should be improved. It only allows a timeframe for icy grasp, if succesful. It should be at least one second, just like the other classes.
Time void is pretty ok; although it wouldn't hurt anyone if it were to be made instant.
Also, the ice mastery skill should slightly improve the passive stun rate it has now, since heroic will and smoke bomb refresh the stun abilities of the other classes.
Oh, almost forgot. Ice Armor should be amped and retaliate significantly more damage than it doea now; maybe three or four times more. This will compensate the health nerf :).
I think this will balance everything out and alot of players will stop complaining about this class or the other.
Because they will all be war mages.
Ceka wrote:Just. Nevla trolls everything and repeat always the same thing. Never take seriously what nevla said. You can have a headache if you continue to discuss ilyana :D

The old rule: When you disagree, shout "troll".

I do agree with Azmodias that you have a "quesionable" attitude, though. :D

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorFri Jun 27, 2014 5:22 am
Ceka wrote:Just. Nevla trolls everything and repeat always the same thing. Never take seriously what nevla said. You can have a headache if you continue to discuss ilyana :D

Very true. He's been shouting for Venan to nerf everything but himself for months, so it's not like this is a new thing :lol:
Unfortunately this forum has a mob mentality, where people who shout/troll others loudest and come up with the best pseudo-scientific justifications seem to hold sway. Thankfully I think Venan are getting inured to it now...

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorFri Jun 27, 2014 5:26 am
Azaelish wrote:Yeah, Jugger OP. It should be nerfed to 35 percent status resist, if that. Snap cast should be available at the very beggining of the fight to compensate for this, and spell cast through snap cast should ignore status resist. That way the slow effect would be applied at the beggining of the fight and make it fair.
Alternatively, the cooldown could be reduced to 1 sec or 1.5 sec, keeping the ability of ignoring status resist mentioned above. Status resist on gear grants an advantage to the other classes over WM, which depends on status effects, thus leaving the Wm at a disadvantage. Such a change will counter this.
Ice lance knockback should be improved. It only allows a timeframe for icy grasp, if succesful. It should be at least one second, just like the other classes.
Time void is pretty ok; although it wouldn't hurt anyone if it were to be made instant.
Also, the ice mastery skill should slightly improve the passive stun rate it has now, since heroic will and smoke bomb refresh the stun abilities of the other classes.
Oh, almost forgot. Ice Armor should be amped and retaliate significantly more damage than it doea now; maybe three or four times more. This will compensate the health nerf :).
I think this will balance everything out and alot of players will stop complaining about this class or the other.
Because they will all be war mages.

:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:
Ilyana wrote:
Azaelish wrote:Yeah, Jugger OP. It should be nerfed to 35 percent status resist, if that. Snap cast should be available at the very beggining of the fight to compensate for this, and spell cast through snap cast should ignore status resist. That way the slow effect would be applied at the beggining of the fight and make it fair.
Alternatively, the cooldown could be reduced to 1 sec or 1.5 sec, keeping the ability of ignoring status resist mentioned above. Status resist on gear grants an advantage to the other classes over WM, which depends on status effects, thus leaving the Wm at a disadvantage. Such a change will counter this.
Ice lance knockback should be improved. It only allows a timeframe for icy grasp, if succesful. It should be at least one second, just like the other classes.
Time void is pretty ok; although it wouldn't hurt anyone if it were to be made instant.
Also, the ice mastery skill should slightly improve the passive stun rate it has now, since heroic will and smoke bomb refresh the stun abilities of the other classes.
Oh, almost forgot. Ice Armor should be amped and retaliate significantly more damage than it doea now; maybe three or four times more. This will compensate the health nerf :).
I think this will balance everything out and alot of players will stop complaining about this class or the other.
Because they will all be war mages.

:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:


Don't listen to them, Azaelish. You have a valid opinion and Ceka or Ilyana won't agree with anything you say, because they have already made up their mind about the good guys and the bad guys! If you don't say that PvP is totally balanced, you're a bad guy. :mrgreen: