Book of Heroes

Matchmaking system needs to be improved · page 2

EricM wrote:
Nek_the_Red_traveller wrote:Spriher, thank you! You covered my concern and frustrations well.

As I see it, for an analogy, a highschool football team beats all the other highschool teams. Similar skills, talents, gear. But they can't be champions because the have to compete against the NFL teams, who of course out skill, gear, talent and spend them for all the best toys, etc. So they get stomped and have to settle for so so midrange thanks for participating trophy.

I see it as there needing to be peer categories or at least limiting the difference between opponents, and might is a good guage of ggear, gems, enchants and hero skills, to a +/- percentage range. Setting a 22k toon vs a 52k toon, I'll give you pretty good odds on what the outcome will be. And that there is a player's demoralizer.

But that's exactly what it is. Platinum = NFL, Gold = College Football, Silver = High School Football

When you start beating everyone in your league/division... what happens? you get promoted up to the next one. Of course it's going to be difficult. I don't get what the complaints are even about. If you face people your might, you'll win 99%+ of games... that's why it's promoting you up to a point at which you win ~50% of the time. Yes, that means you'll face mismatches... the answer to which is to go gear up, enchant up, play pve and come back if you want to keep progressing higher, else you'll start evening out in one league... and that's where you'll end up for your skill level + might.

Part of the problem is that for so long everything in the game was based off might that people haven't quite stopped thinking of everything in terms of it.

Your analogy is a bit wrong cuz we are all level 33 (as opposed to kids in high school who are younger than college kids, who are in turn younger that players in NFL) and the only thing that separates us is gear. That's like saying that you can't play in NFL cuz you have Puma sneakers and not Nike.

When you say that if you faced same might opponents, you would win 99% of time, that would mean you are on of the best PvPers in the game and dont you think that kind of player deserves to be in the top league or have really high ranking? Because I do think that. Players in top might range who win 99% of the time are at the top. Why should players with 30k might be any different?

At the moment, PvP is not about skill, it is about gear and that is an awful design.

You also say that people can't stop thinking of everything in terms of might. Well, you bet I cant when I get 2 shotted by 18k Piercing strikes and 20k Incinerates by a more that double my might players. And because of that, I guess they deserve to be higher ranked?

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorThu Jul 17, 2014 8:48 am
EricM wrote:
Nek_the_Red_traveller wrote:Spriher, thank you! You covered my concern and frustrations well.

As I see it, for an analogy, a highschool football team beats all the other highschool teams. Similar skills, talents, gear. But they can't be champions because the have to compete against the NFL teams, who of course out skill, gear, talent and spend them for all the best toys, etc. So they get stomped and have to settle for so so midrange thanks for participating trophy.

I see it as there needing to be peer categories or at least limiting the difference between opponents, and might is a good guage of ggear, gems, enchants and hero skills, to a +/- percentage range. Setting a 22k toon vs a 52k toon, I'll give you pretty good odds on what the outcome will be. And that there is a player's demoralizer.

But that's exactly what it is. Platinum = NFL, Gold = College Football, Silver = High School Football

When you start beating everyone in your league/division... what happens? you get promoted up to the next one. Of course it's going to be difficult. I don't get what the complaints are even about. If you face people your might, you'll win 99%+ of games... that's why it's promoting you up to a point at which you win ~50% of the time. Yes, that means you'll face mismatches... the answer to which is to go gear up, enchant up, play pve and come back if you want to keep progressing higher, else you'll start evening out in one league... and that's where you'll end up for your skill level + might.

Part of the problem is that for so long everything in the game was based off might that people haven't quite stopped thinking of everything in terms of it.

I agree with you mostly Eric. Another big problem is that some people are pushing might as some kind of completely irrelevant number like level. For the most part, if you face someone who has 50-100% more might, most of the time you will lose. It doesn't matter how long a 21k has been pvping, they will likely get destroyed by a 42k. That's what they're trying to say. Might is actually a very good gauge in that situation. There are exceptions, we get that.
I totally agree with Spriher and Ilyana, i mean even if i've played 1k+ pvp matches people with double my might still destroy me with 1or 2 shots so whats the point, it ends up in frustration and anger i dont understand why venan cant see that. Some mages killed me with 30k Incentrate and my health is 19.7k even if i put more health or magic resist gems in my gears i dont think i can survive that. So where is fun and testing your pvp skills in that....i am not playing pvp just for earning marks, i am looking for fun in it too and test my pvp skills in fair fight.
Yeah i get that, you will get marks even if you loose and keep playing & gearing up your char but It's not a short process and there is no fun and testing your skills in that.
I have numerous issues with PvP, but the matchmaking system is the one thing that I don't. After you get a decent number of matches under your belt, almost all the players will be winning right around 50% of their matches.

Yes, you get matched against high might players ranking up initially every once in a while. You get dropped in ranking at which point you are fighting slightly easier opponents, it is to your advantage and you will get back to where you were.

I do think the real problem is one of the fundamental reasons I have always been anti-PvP, which is that it is a zero sum game. I feel like the toon that I am pvp farming with loses 75% of the time but when I go check the stats it is always right around 50% wins. Loses tend to be more painful than the wins good so it seems worse than it actually is.

I predict that over time you'll see more mismatching because the number of PvPers will drop due to boredom or PvP farmers (like me) have gotten what they need.
Bbbb wrote:I have numerous issues with PvP, but the matchmaking system is the one thing that I don't. After you get a decent number of matches under your belt, almost all the players will be winning right around 50% of their matches.

Yes, you get matched against high might players ranking up initially every once in a while. You get dropped in ranking at which point you are fighting slightly easier opponents, it is to your advantage and you will get back to where you were.

I do think the real problem is one of the fundamental reasons I have always been anti-PvP, which is that it is a zero sum game. I feel like the toon that I am pvp farming with loses 75% of the time but when I go check the stats it is always right around 50% wins. Loses tend to be more painful than the wins good so it seems worse than it actually is.

I predict that over time you'll see more mismatching because the number of PvPers will drop due to boredom or PvP farmers (like me) have gotten what they need.

But why is it good for everyone to be at 50%? This is PvP and everyone should have the same chance of proving themselves in it. Those who are better (those who tinker with spec, gems, enchants and 1h/2h weapons, as well as those who know attack patterns of their opponents and know how to retaliate) should be rewarded for their time put into PvP by higher ranking. Those who are not, they always have a choice to learn and become better, not by gearing up, but by thinking and practicing. Sure, PvP in this game is not a rocket science, but it's always possible to improve.

If the system works in a way that everyone should be around 50%, then whats the point of farming PvP gear in the first place? You will be at 50% with or without it. At the moment, the system works in a way which offers zero competitiveness (apart from top might players). Lets say you wanna reach that top might level where there is some competitiveness, you would need to play what, like 500 or even 1000 matches to get all the medals (while doing some raiding as well). So 1000 matches of mediocrity and boredom where you know that after you win few matches, you are gonna be obliterated in the next few by players with double your damage and ressists.

Basically progress is being punished and failure is being rewarded.

I agree with you. there are more issues in PvP (like maybe health nerf and matches being too short) but I feel this is the biggest one. Maybe its a shock to me cuz I have PvPed in beta extensively and matchmaking was much more fair back then. It was very rare to get matched with someone with 10+k might or 10k- might. Now its like every other game. Don Quijote comes to mind and fighting with windmills :)
Spriher wrote:Maybe its a shock to me cuz I have PvPed in beta extensively and matchmaking was much more fair back then. It was very rare to get matched with someone with 10+k might or 10k- might.

You're kidding, right? You had people deliberately dropping their might by unequipping everything except their T16 weapon for instance. They destroyed most everyone at the might level they were pvping at. Do they deserve to be ranked among the top ranked pvp players? Not in my opinion. One of the good things about the new system is those kinds of might games are not rewarded. Playing at anything less than your top might only ends up hurting you.
Spriher wrote:But why is it good for everyone to be at 50%? This is PvP and everyone should have the same chance of proving themselves in it. Those who are better (those who tinker with spec, gems, enchants and 1h/2h weapons, as well as those who know attack patterns of their opponents and know how to retaliate) should be rewarded for their time put into PvP by higher ranking. Those who are not, they always have a choice to learn and become better, not by gearing up, but by thinking and practicing. Sure, PvP in this game is not a rocket science, but it's always possible to improve

Your second sentence sentence seems to contradict everything else you're saying. Better gear and enchants lead to higher ranking, as does skill in playing, A little luck helps too. You seem to be saying that great skill should trump all, but how much skill is really required? There are only 7 or 8 moves for each class. If you and I are equal in skill and you have 40k might to my 24k, then I expect I should lose most of the time.

I think the new pvp just needs a new mindset. My SW who I played a ton in the pvp beta won 80% of his matches back then and rarely faced a challenge. Now every fight is a challenge and I lose as often as I win. But I don't worry about the losses - I understand why it's happening. And those rare times I pull off a win against an opponent who has much greater might than me - I treasure those the most.
Yeah I remember people PvPing naked in Beta. And as much as it was lame and frustrating, it was rare. At least much more rare than today's miss matches.

True, with my 40k might and yours 24k might, I should be winning most of the times. But why would we be playing against each other in the first place? For me, that match up provides no challenge and for you it provides only frustration. Sure, you might win a rare one and you say you treasure those matches. Well, I dont really, cuz I know that those wins happen only because of extreme luck and for the next 10 or more matches that kind of luck wont be there again.
Speaking of mismatch... With this ELO system (this version not all) has no loss cap. So if I fight someone in Gold I in plat II (or silver I when I was in plat III) if I lost connection by my fault and not the server's, and my auto attack doesn't come through, I lose HEAPS
Spriher wrote:Yeah I remember people PvPing naked in Beta. And as much as it was lame and frustrating, it was rare. At least much more rare than today's miss matches.

True, with my 40k might and yours 24k might, I should be winning most of the times. But why would we be playing against each other in the first place? For me, that match up provides no challenge and for you it provides only frustration. Sure, you might win a rare one and you say you treasure those matches. Well, I dont really, cuz I know that those wins happen only because of extreme luck and for the next 10 or more matches that kind of luck wont be there again.

...but might isn't as important as rotation and build. Anecdotal example- my justi is 34k might. It's hovering in the top 50. There's only like 2-3 pvpers up there under 40k might. So every match is a might mismatch. But I'm still going 50/50 because my rotation is on par with those 40k's. Sure, I'm matched up vs 52-53ks... Nearly a 20k mismatch. But I'm still 50/50 vs them. Haven't had too many crushing defeats- they're all relatively close because the game is trying to match up for skill.

The inherent problem is when you get demolished, the first thing you go check is how much higher your opponent is. But just as easily, they could be significantly lower. My 21k wm took 200 hp in a match vs a 42k might. Point I'm making is that while mismatches exist, the game is pairing you up with players who play at or around your skill level, not your might.

So if there's a 53k'er who's matched with you, take it as a compliment. The game thinks that you have at least a reasonable chance of success from your past matches and their past matches.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorFri Jul 18, 2014 12:26 pm
EricM wrote:
Spriher wrote:Yeah I remember people PvPing naked in Beta. And as much as it was lame and frustrating, it was rare. At least much more rare than today's miss matches.

True, with my 40k might and yours 24k might, I should be winning most of the times. But why would we be playing against each other in the first place? For me, that match up provides no challenge and for you it provides only frustration. Sure, you might win a rare one and you say you treasure those matches. Well, I dont really, cuz I know that those wins happen only because of extreme luck and for the next 10 or more matches that kind of luck wont be there again.

...but might isn't as important as rotation and build. Anecdotal example- my justi is 34k might. It's hovering in the top 50. There's only like 2-3 pvpers up there under 40k might. So every match is a might mismatch. But I'm still going 50/50 because my rotation is on par with those 40k's. Sure, I'm matched up vs 52-53ks... Nearly a 20k mismatch. But I'm still 50/50 vs them. Haven't had too many crushing defeats- they're all relatively close because the game is trying to match up for skill.

The inherent problem is when you get demolished, the first thing you go check is how much higher your opponent is. But just as easily, they could be significantly lower. My 21k wm took 200 hp in a match vs a 42k might. Point I'm making is that while mismatches exist, the game is pairing you up with players who play at or around your skill level, not your might.

So if there's a 53k'er who's matched with you, take it as a compliment. The game thinks that you have at least a reasonable chance of success from your past matches and their past matches.

Eric that's the exception, not the rule and you know it. You said above there's only 2-3 PvPers under 40k might in the top 50, that's exactly what we're saying is happening. Might has a huge impact because the might comes from superior HT, gems, enchants and gear. Virtually all of the top 50 aren't there accidentally - they have the might and have also figured out the best rotations and are most skilled. There's a synergy there but might plays a huge part.

You keep saying 'build' as if its somehow a separate thing entirely. It's fairly easy to pick abilities. Build comes from gems, gear, enchants...all of which have a direct effect on your might.

Maybe it just needs to rephrased. The higher your might, the more significant that might is when fighting a lower ranked opponent, based on the HT, gear etc etc that both toons likely have available.

I agree though that perhaps we should take it as a compliment. Maybe if the system took might into account for rank gains and losses things would feel more fair to the toons lower down, where if anything the might mismatches are even worse. Come and play in Gold III (my alt is scrapping at that level) sometime with a 10-15k toon and you'll see what I mean.