Book of Heroes

Matchmaking system needs to be improved · page 4

And this idea that you are rewarded for winning....by moving up a league just does not float, not when the next league up is populated by toon 10k might over you. You just keep getting beat down and it's a piss poor circle.
So then what's a good solution to make things fairer without making wait times ridiculously long?

Some of my toons are already waiting 6-7 minutes per match.

I wouldn't particularly mind might caps (say +/- 5k) for matchups but then what happens to those in a league with no one in their might range? Let's take ily. 34k might in a league full of 40k+ mights. Since she's not within 5k, she'd never get matched up with anyone. After a long wait, it's constantly match her down with players in gold I and II since they're the only other ones in her might range. But since their rating is so much lower, she's get one point on a win, and lose 30+ on a loss.

Right? There's major issues with any implementation.
EricM wrote:So then what's a good solution to make things fairer without making wait times ridiculously long?

Some of my toons are already waiting 6-7 minutes per match.

I wouldn't particularly mind might caps (say +/- 5k) for matchups but then what happens to those in a league with no one in their might range? Let's take ily. 34k might in a league full of 40k+ mights. Since she's not within 5k, she'd never get matched up with anyone. After a long wait, it's constantly match her down with players in gold I and II since they're the only other ones in her might range. But since their rating is so much lower, she's get one point on a win, and lose 30+ on a loss.

Right? There's major issues with any implementation.

Thats the reason i suggested even 10k might cap is fine but might gap of 25k+, dont you think thats too much and its not like you are always matched up with people in same league, i am in league gold II but i got matched up with people from gold I most of the time and few times with people from platinum III, so competing against people from other leagues is not the issue as long as they are in reasonable might range.
About the points, you can hardly win from those who are 10-20k might higher than you...so you are loosing the rating points anywayz whenever you compete against those people.
I just love how Eric has been the number one commenter on this topic and his might is 52k. Good Lord he has no credibility.
Steeld wrote:I just love how Eric has been the number one commenter on this topic and his might is 52k. Good Lord he has no credibility.

I don't see what having a high might toon has to do with anything, let alone my credibility lol. But if you'd prefer, I'll stop posting in this topic after this. If anything, I'd argue that having toons of all three classes ranging from 21k - 52k might- all of whom pvp would give me a reasonable amount of credibility :p More so than most.

But like I've said over and over, it's very easy to point out that a problem exists. I'm not denying might mismatches are frustrating or annoying. I'm all for a might cap or a solution if it can't be abused. All I'm saying it's much easier to say "hey fix this" and much harder to have a solution that doesn't open the game either to exploits or worse problems (in this case - long wait times or artificially lowering might to farm rewards). Especially as someone who's played the game for so long and weathered through multiple "exploitable" systems, the last thing I want to see is something that tries to force a solution and ends up backfiring (Case in point - the merc system and guild loyalty ruining guild hopping).

And GabZ- regarding the might cap, wouldn't the same problem happen? If a 29k might somehow reaches platinum, and no one is within 10k, he'd have no way to progress. His/Her wait timer would go on and on until someone within 10k and platinum comes on. Else he'd be matched with players in lower leagues and get zero rewards. I feel like getting +1 rating for a win is a lot more painful than losing a might mismatch that you can rationalize you would have lost anyways.

Steel - I may have a differing opinion from the majority, but I have been civil about it, and I'd appreciate likewise. The point of this forum is to have logical discourse regarding pvp, not to deviate into bashing other players. Thanks ;)
One word .. carebears. I was in gold 1 sitting at 34k and beat the pordo the number 1 guy on PvP. It's not always might not gear, it's how the dice roll on your attacks for resists and dodges. It's all in percentages some get lucky some don't.
EricM wrote:
Steeld wrote:I just love how Eric has been the number one commenter on this topic and his might is 52k. Good Lord he has no credibility.

I don't see what having a high might toon has to do with anything, let alone my credibility lol. But if you'd prefer, I'll stop posting in this topic after this. If anything, I'd argue that having toons of all three classes ranging from 21k - 52k might- all of whom pvp would give me a reasonable amount of credibility :p More so than most.

But like I've said over and over, it's very easy to point out that a problem exists. I'm not denying might mismatches are frustrating or annoying. I'm all for a might cap or a solution if it can't be abused. All I'm saying it's much easier to say "hey fix this" and much harder to have a solution that doesn't open the game either to exploits or worse problems (in this case - long wait times or artificially lowering might to farm rewards). Especially as someone who's played the game for so long and weathered through multiple "exploitable" systems, the last thing I want to see is something that tries to force a solution and ends up backfiring (Case in point - the merc system and guild loyalty ruining guild hopping).

And GabZ- regarding the might cap, wouldn't the same problem happen? If a 29k might somehow reaches platinum, and no one is within 10k, he'd have no way to progress. His/Her wait timer would go on and on until someone within 10k and platinum comes on. Else he'd be matched with players in lower leagues and get zero rewards. I feel like getting +1 rating for a win is a lot more painful than losing a might mismatch that you can rationalize you would have lost anyways.

Steel - I may have a differing opinion from the majority, but I have been civil about it, and I'd appreciate likewise. The point of this forum is to have logical discourse regarding pvp, not to deviate into bashing other players. Thanks ;)

Actually eric i am not that well aware of how does matchmaking system really works atm, i mean what does it look for before it puts 2 opponents against each other. Can you enlighten me?
Rambles wrote:One word .. carebears. I was in gold 1 sitting at 34k and beat the pordo the number 1 guy on PvP. It's not always might not gear, it's how the dice roll on your attacks for resists and dodges. It's all in percentages some get lucky some don't.

Well, that doesnt happen all the time. It's just if you get lucky, i've beaten some people of 45k might with my 20k sw but it really depends on your luck. Like in my case i resisted that guy's caltrops and gained urgency when i got hit by reflex strike after and i was able to put caltrops on him, so with faster attacks i was able to take him down and same happened with one 40k+ mage.....but it's very rare for that to happen.
Instead of trying to quote everyone, let me just sum up some points.

1. I agree with almost everything Eric says and I do PvP with a 14K might toon.
2. One statement he makes that is probably true for him and other top players is the long wait time now. It's not true for lower ranked players though. Hanging around Silver I/Gold III, I get matches instantly to maybe 90 seconds at most. IMHO once the newness wears off and people have farmed what they want the wait times are going to get longer.
3. Gabz, the matching system tries to find you a player close to your PvP Rating. If you want to learn more about the system, read this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elo_rating_system
4. Because everyone starts out in Bronze III, high might toon have to get their rating up. That is what some percentage of the might mismatches come from. Over time, there won't be many high might toons that do not have a PvP rating so this problem should mostly go away. Also, the might cap might kill the new high might PvPer because they may never get their first match or have to meet someone in Platinum and get killed repeatedly.
5. I'm not getting matched with people too far away I guess. Every gain/loss I've seen is in the 12-18 point range with most 15-17.
6. The mismatches do not harm you in the long run. That is one of the features of the system. If you do not understand that, please learn how the system works.

One of the problem is that Venan picked a rating and payout scheme that is taking a long term view of PvP and many players are taking the short term view. Note: I am not saying either is fundamentally right or wrong. The hardcore PvPers should appreciate the long term view but I can see where it is annoying for the casual player.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon Jul 21, 2014 3:13 pm
Steeld wrote:I just love how Eric has been the number one commenter on this topic and his might is 52k. Good Lord he has no credibility.

That was rather uncalled for. Saying he has no credibility is about as wrong as you can get.

And thanks for the above Eric, I honestly hadn't thought about it that way round. I still don't know how the might differences could be improved, but either way I'm still hooked for the moment.
Ilyana wrote:
Steeld wrote:I just love how Eric has been the number one commenter on this topic and his might is 52k. Good Lord he has no credibility.

That was rather uncalled for. Saying he has no credibility is about as wrong as you can get.

And thanks for the above Eric, I honestly hadn't thought about it that way round. I still don't know how the might differences could be improved, but either way I'm still hooked for the moment.


My pint is, Eric has previously been a big proponent of a system that let's huge moght matchups happen. With him being at 52k might, it really sways his viewpoint and loses him credibility. Now he says he is all about a might cap, that hasn't always been what he supports. People with the highest mights defending a system that lets huge might discrepancies occur do lose credibility......in my opinion.