I think we just need to give the matchmaking system more time to get acclimated. I personally think that the matchmaking system is awesome. My Win:Loss ratio is very close to 50% and I'm constantly getting more marks in order to build a better toon.
My main is an 18K Might SW in Gold II and has been there for 2 weeks now. My opponents normally range in the 25k-45k range. Agreeing with Eric, I take it as a compliment that I'm fighting other players that have more Might and am still maintaining a 50% ratio. My job is to either get stronger (increasing my might) or get knocked down into a lesser league.
My take is, if you're in a strong league that has a higher average Might than you (check your ranking and the players around), expect to fight people that have greater Might than you. They're in the same league as you because:
1: They have similar Might to you and fight just as well as you.
2: They have less Might than you but are just as good or better with PVP skills (Timing, Build, Rotation, etc...).
3: They have more Might than you but aren't good with PVP skills and keep getting knocked out of higher leagues.
4: They've recently started PVP and are bulldozing through everyone to get to the league they should probably be in.
As a player, you can:
1: Grow your toon, Might Up, and PVP to develop a better sense of timing and skills to be more competitive.
2: Lose a whole bunch so that you're in a lower league and then win a bunch (eventually going back up to the higher league and complaining some more).
Once we have more players and the ELO system is more acclimated maybe I won't be Gold II. Maybe I'll eventually get knocked back to Silver. That's fine because the people above me will either have better skills and hopefully better Might. I say "hopefully better Might" because if they have the same might as me, that just means they're a better PVPer.
PVP isn't just about winning and playing matches against similar might players. It's about matching wits and looking for holes in the defense and skills of your opponent while ensuring you're playing defensively and offensively at the same time.
I'd rather be matched with people that are challenging. Sometimes, that match may be with a person who has 30k more might than me. Obviously, if we're both in the same league, there's a reason he's there. He probably doesn't have good timing or understand the skills that the opponent has. If that's the case, my toon, even though he has 18k might, has a chance of winning. That's the challenge.
So what's an acceptable solution? Stratify leagues by might? Bronze = those under 33, silver = those <20k, gold = <35k, platinum = anything goes? and then have separate leaderboards for each one?
Meh too easily abused.
Inherently, I fail to see the problem with rewarding might. Isn't that the very point of the game? Boh has never been chess. Everyone isn't playing on the same board with the same pieces. Raiding has been the primary way of gaining might and progressing in the game and I see no reason that progress shouldn't be granted an advantage.
That's akin to running a speed run and complaining you didn't win cause your might is too low. So why should you be on the top of the leaderboards if you can't beat the others at the top.
Sounds like you guys are wanting to only be matched vs your might. So you're Lv 33 and 8k might and can beat every other 8k might in the game... You have every right to be proud and brag about it. But of course you aren't going to beat the 20k might or the 30k mights. So why expect to be higher ranked than them?
Would you prefer to only be matched with those at your might or lower and get 0 points per win? Because that's the only fair alternative. If you can't beat those in say platinum... You should be in gold, etc etc. No matter how good are you, that's where you're at for your might. And there's full reason to take pride in that. My 21k wm is in gold II. I know I can't get to platinum unless I might up. But that sounds perfectly reasonable to me. I may lose a few fights against other golds who happen to be higher might, but I'll also win a few vs lower toons and trade off vs toons my might. And all in all, I'll stay around that league until I get good enough or strong enough to keep progressing.
So what's the solution? Go raid, go grab more gems, enchants, etc and come and try again. Why pvp then if you're not going to progress meanwhile? For the gear if you'll use it, for the gems if you won't.
Ily- it's only around 100 fights per t6 gem at your rank. If you don't want to raid to grow, that's a solid alternative.
Also- when I say rotation, I mean move set used in a match. Of course it's easy to copy someone's gems and ability set but learning to play that particular build in game is a lot more challenging. Purao or taci havn't stayed on top by just bashing the same rotation over and over. The best pvpers have always been those willing to experiment, try new things, and accept they're not always going to win. Yes it's frustrating, yes it makes you want to pull your hair out on a mismatch or a freak fight where you miss everything, but that doesn't mean the game isn't balanced. It's keeping you in your league the way it's coded to. When you get better than those you face, you face better players. Or worse players with higher might. Until you lose. Rinse and repeat.
And the argument that 50/50 win rate is a bad idea.... No matter what, someone will lose, someone will win. But something you complainers consistently don't realize with this system is that you're complaining because you're good. You feel like you're much more skilled than those around your might/level and so you feel like you're being unfairly matched up. But stop and think about the bad pvper. Someone who isn't very good and doesn't do well. If the system wasn't 50/50 and instead based on might, They'd lose the vast majority of their fights... And then quit. Leading to beta syndrome where the same 5 people pvped and no one else.
With the current system, no matter how bad you are (unless you're level 10 or new) are gonna find a happy place where you're 50/50, gain marks, and have the potential to grow and keep pvping without getting discouraged.
EricM wrote:So what's an acceptable solution? Stratify leagues by might? Bronze = those under 33, silver = those <20k, gold = <35k, platinum = anything goes? and then have separate leaderboards for each one?
Meh too easily abused.
Inherently, I fail to see the problem with rewarding might. Isn't that the very point of the game? Boh has never been chess. Everyone isn't playing on the same board with the same pieces. Raiding has been the primary way of gaining might and progressing in the game and I see no reason that progress shouldn't be granted an advantage.
That's akin to running a speed run and complaining you didn't win cause your might is too low. So why should you be on the top of the leaderboards if you can't beat the others at the top.
Sounds like you guys are wanting to only be matched vs your might. So you're Lv 33 and 8k might and can beat every other 8k might in the game... You have every right to be proud and brag about it. But of course you aren't going to beat the 20k might or the 30k mights. So why expect to be higher ranked than them?
Would you prefer to only be matched with those at your might or lower and get 0 points per win? Because that's the only fair alternative. If you can't beat those in say platinum... You should be in gold, etc etc. No matter how good are you, that's where you're at for your might. And there's full reason to take pride in that. My 21k wm is in gold II. I know I can't get to platinum unless I might up. But that sounds perfectly reasonable to me. I may lose a few fights against other golds who happen to be higher might, but I'll also win a few vs lower toons and trade off vs toons my might. And all in all, I'll stay around that league until I get good enough or strong enough to keep progressing.
So what's the solution? Go raid, go grab more gems, enchants, etc and come and try again. Why pvp then if you're not going to progress meanwhile? For the gear if you'll use it, for the gems if you won't.
Ily- it's only around 100 fights per t6 gem at your rank. If you don't want to raid to grow, that's a solid alternative.
Also- when I say rotation, I mean move set used in a match. Of course it's easy to copy someone's gems and ability set but learning to play that particular build in game is a lot more challenging. Purao or taci havn't stayed on top by just bashing the same rotation over and over. The best pvpers have always been those willing to experiment, try new things, and accept they're not always going to win. Yes it's frustrating, yes it makes you want to pull your hair out on a mismatch or a freak fight where you miss everything, but that doesn't mean the game isn't balanced. It's keeping you in your league the way it's coded to. When you get better than those you face, you face better players. Or worse players with higher might. Until you lose. Rinse and repeat.
And the argument that 50/50 win rate is a bad idea.... No matter what, someone will lose, someone will win. But something you complainers consistently don't realize with this system is that you're complaining because you're good. You feel like you're much more skilled than those around your might/level and so you feel like you're being unfairly matched up. But stop and think about the bad pvper. Someone who isn't very good and doesn't do well. If the system wasn't 50/50 and instead based on might, They'd lose the vast majority of their fights... And then quit. Leading to beta syndrome where the same 5 people pvped and no one else.
With the current system, no matter how bad you are (unless you're level 10 or new) are gonna find a happy place where you're 50/50, gain marks, and have the potential to grow and keep pvping without getting discouraged.
See, I don't see any valid reason why might SHOULD be rewarded. Oh don't worry, Venan seems to agree with you and I've been told as much. But it doesn't make it fair. The main issue is with rank loss and gain. It's far too lopsided to fairly reflect how good the player is. Might brackets for leagues is essentially what's happening. I don't have an easy answer, but the lack of an answer doesn't mean a problem isn't investigated...
Personally I think aiming for 50/50 is weird. So the ultimate aim is to flip a coin to win? How is that going to satisfy people?
I'd say at Plat III things aren't too bad. There are huge might mismatches but I'll take that if tweaked a little. Lower down though its horrible and we all know it. People of mights other than 50k want a stab at getting PvP gear and prestige gear. It's easy for us in platinum, some people have a lot of the gear already.
'Only' 100 matches huh? That made me smile

i don't know where you got the idea that I don't raid, though.
I need the PvP gear first. Then I need to enchant it somehow, using the materials dropping at the same rates as before, before I can use it otherwise I'll drop to a lower league.
Alright, is it too much to ask if i say matchmaking system shouldn't match up 10k+ might people with 20k+ might, 20k+ might shouldn't match up with 30k+, 30k+ shouldn't match up with 40k+.....so it remains between 10k-20k, 20k-30k, 30k-40k.....what do you say?
Let's not kid around, might determines how powerful your gears are, how powerful your enchants are, how powerful your gems are, your HT investment, so it would be only fair to atleast not put up people with just 19k might against people with 45k might. It takes time to farm better gears, it shouldn't mean that people who yet doesnt have better tier gears can't enjoy pvp. I think most of the people play this game to cool off their mind, enjoy, have fun, not to take more stress.
On the record with agreeing about the bad might matchups!!!!!,!! I currently show 13 losses in replay......every single one of them to people with over 5k to 15k more might than I do.......
I just want a FAIR fight......
And I'm sick of hearing from 35k might people say all is well.......they are just loving an easy win.
And make winning worth something already!!!!! And mot just in the standings, winning should give more that a loss......just like in Beta....I never heard a complaint about getting less for a loss.
This has turn a fun part of the game into frustration....and as a wealthy old guy, I'm ready to take my entertainment money elsewhere.
I repeat.....the only ones I've seen stand by the system are those with high might preying on easy wins.
And good Lord Eric, as one of the high test might in game, shut up already. You lost any ability to make a valid comment on this long ago.
Things this pathetic, horrible and slapped-together match system shouldn't do:
-match you against players outside your medal ranking (gold II, platinum III, silver I, etc.).
-match you against players outside of a reasonable might range.
-match you against the same player in consecutive matches.
-match you against players not your toons level.
Of course none of this will probably be fixed, and things will only get worse.
AdamM wrote:Things this pathetic, horrible and slapped-together match system shouldn't do:
-match you against players outside your medal ranking (gold II, platinum III, silver I, etc.).
-match you against players outside of a reasonable might range.
-match you against the same player in consecutive matches.
-match you against players not your toons level.
Of course none of this will probably be fixed, and things will only get worse.
Then be prepared to wait an extra long time for it to find you a match.
FYI: before u jump on me about might. 99% of all PvP I have done is with a 13k might toon.
Bbbb wrote:AdamM wrote:Things this pathetic, horrible and slapped-together match system shouldn't do:
-match you against players outside your medal ranking (gold II, platinum III, silver I, etc.).
-match you against players outside of a reasonable might range.
-match you against the same player in consecutive matches.
-match you against players not your toons level.
Of course none of this will probably be fixed, and things will only get worse.
Then be prepared to wait an extra long time for it to find you a match.
FYI: before u jump on me about might. 99% of all PvP I have done is with a 13k might toon.
Bbbb is right, that will make things more complicated. Everyone will start complaining about long waiting times if they implement the things adam have asked and that means it will take more time to get marks.
Imo, the only thing needs to be improved is they shouldn't match you against players outside of a reasonable might range. Like they shouldn't match 10k against 25k, 20k against 40k and likewise. That takes the fun out when might difference is too much.
Agreed, except in addition to might issue Id add one more item:
If you put the effort into a Toon that can win, then give us something for winning. There should be an increase in reward for a win....otherwise, I for one am going to lose incentive for trying very hard in a fight.