Mithrid wrote:Gahhhhhh!!!! It is such a target rich environment now that I need to contain myself!!
OK...focus focus ...breath.... I will keep this post to the core topic:
Ilyana, plain and simple, a Blacklist is no more prone to abuse than powers already owned by guilds.
You have yet to justify your position that it would cause new forms of abuse.
The only point you have attempted to make is that people would blacklist those who they disagree with based on gender, lifestyle, orientation, religion etc etc.
Guess what...that already happens. Ever hear of the Guild GrrlPower? Last I checked it was girls only. I know there was a LGBT only guild as well, there have been guilds that only allowed players who spoke a specific language or were from a specific region......just yesterday a new player was advertising for toons to join her Girl and gay man only Guild, named Man-Eaters I believe. If this is the type of abuse you are worried a blacklist would create, with people creating guilds that only cater to people they want to agree with...TOO LATE, that 'abuse' its already here!!!!!
So just how would a blacklist, which would do nothing more then give guilds more flexibility over who can join their raids, and nothing more than what they already do for who can join their guild, lead to any new abuse that doesn't already exist??
So the single question you have to answer: How exactly, would a blacklist, create abusive powers for a guild, that a guild currently doesn't have?
hint: it doesn't. 
Haha, you've been away from the core topic since you first posted.
I've already proven it over and over. Now you've dragged in how guilds are set up for subcultures of people into a debate that has nothing to do with it.
I'll say it plainly and clearly for you. Blacklists aren't inherently abusive. They would however be abused. A guild can't automatically bar anyone from their raid, save via the means of passwording their raids, which is clunky and a lot of guilds don't do it anymore. But that isn't what we're taking about, it's a permanent ban for someone. You cannot do that right now. Saying you can doesn't somehow make it true.
I'd love to know how it took so long for you to pose that question. Days? If it was so obvious to you and your lovely hints why not roll out that earlier? Could it be that your position isn't so strong as you might believe? Should you perhaps pose yourself the counter-question of how could it not be abused? Oh wait, it can be.
Just admit someone disagrees with you and leave them alone for once. I already posted that I considered the matter done considering it was sabotaged.
Maybe forum mods should stop these derailed threads before they get too far into this kind of thing. Lock a thread about something that's actually important elsewhere and let something like this carry on and on.