DreamingDaemon wrote:Ilyana_the_Red wrote:DreamingDaemon wrote:
Comparing a blacklist of mercs within a guild to online bullying is misleading.
It's closer to child A not inviting child B to his birthday party.
The reasons an individual may be blacklisted are indeed many and varied. It might be down to previous history of mercing with that guild. It may be down to personal dislike on the part of the guild GM. It may be that the individual has developed a reputation as a disruptive influence. It might be that the GM is just being an idiot. Whatever. A guild hosting a raid has as much right to say "we do not want this individual to join" as a store has the right to refuse entry / service to a suspected or confirmed shoplifter.
I believe personally that a blacklist is preferable to a min RPP score from a technical perspective. It's easier to implement and maintain.
It also prevents disruptive individuals from joining a raid, attaining the min RPP, then sitting back and antagonising the host guild and other mercs.
An example - a guild runs a "clean" chat. If an individual disrespects that and behaves in a manner contrary to that guild's standards, then surely it is the guild's right to say that they do not want that person to return, regardless of whether they attain 100RPP or 10k? If their presence is counterproductive to the guild, that guild should absolutely have the right to say "no thanks" in future.
Compare: Mercs know which guilds they like to merc with. Many players will not merc with specific guilds. Many guilds maintain an informal "do not merc with these guilds" list.
Is that also bullying? Simply because that choice isn't technically enforced does not alter the underlying morality of the decision to join / not join based on personal feelings and / or experience of the guild in question.
Note that I have no issue with a min RPP system of some form. I just believe that a blacklist is preferable, easier to implement, and allows the guild in question a greater level of control.
To continue the theme...
MY PERSONAL OPINION
To suggest that selfishness and disrespect is more prevalent in "western" nations than elsewhere is in itself offensive. It's also cobblers.
Self-interest / gratification above the well-being of others is a natural drive of the human machine, and why humanity as a species is the cockroach of the mammals.
To continue this would be to get into the realms of history, politics, religion and morality, and I'm pretty sure I'd get at least silenced. It's also completely OT for this thread. Suffice to say that I have seen casual self-interest at the expense of others from every part of the globe I have visited first hand, and in every aspect of historical study from every corner. It's just in different forms and usually justified with "It's ok because (insert relevant cultural reason here)." This is as true in India as it is in Iraq as it is in Japan as it is in China as it is in the US. Only the justification changes its disguise. To deny this is the case is self-deceptive, to attempt to force otherwise is positively Cnutian.
Well since nitpicking is a very common them on BoH forums, I'll clarify. It is particularly prevalent in Western culture because of our infatuation with consumer society. This encourages a 'me first' attitude...other countries take particular issue with it. Now, I didn't actually say it didn't exist elsewhere in the globe, but you two have taken offence at something that is true...deal with it. As society becomes more globalised these problems will intensify. So, sorry to burst the bubble...you can't just act how you want. It's a common technique when attempting to deconstruct something to focus on minutiae or the very literal interpretations of what someone has or has not said. That's why a lot of politicians refrain from making absolute statements, as that is then held against them later.
I'll bite.
"Me first" is a human condition regardless of location or culture. It manifests itself in the west in, as you correctly state, our infatuation with shiny consumable goodies. In other areas, such as Japan or South Korea or Australia, it manifests itself as - oh...
Snarking aside, let's look at the world right now. In India, for example, there are lean-tos made of corrugated iron forming shantytowns outside mansions, parents cripple their children to increase their begging revenue. Yet the country receives millions in international aid, yet maintains a nuclear arsenal and has just sent a spacecraft to Mars (reached orbit today).
In other countries, the freedom to disagree with the status quo is not at the risk of an quip from an online verbal sparring partner, but a bullet. All of these are self-interest by people witha level of power inflicting harm, passively or actively, on others.
I'm not saying that the west is "better" - far from it, it has its share of problems - but to insist that the west is more selfish than the rest of the world, and that it's down to our plethora of plastic & chrome toys, is to deny both history and our current world state.
I do not believe in acting how I want. Quite the opposite. I actively work in mitigating damage done by those who do believe that they have the right to actively harm others as part of their own self-gratification. I do, however, believe in the right of a person or group of people not to be forced to accept unwelcome guests and unwelcome behaviour.
In summary:
The right of a guild to refuse entry to a raid is the same moral stance as my 4yo son not wanting to invite a boy in his class to his birthday party because that boy ruined another party a few weeks previously by smashing the cake.
How does it deny our current world state? Western society is viewed by a lot of Westerners as inherently better. I've met loads of them. More people in places like India come from genuine poverty, starving to death poverty. People do more extreme things in more extreme circumstances. In the West we view poverty as not being able to have an iPod or shopping at particular supermarkets. That's not to say genuine poverty doesn't exist in the West, it's just viewed differently. This difference is indirectly or directly selfish. There's a lot of people who would be patronised by one of us strolling around their city and commenting on how selfish they are because they're human. They would say, what do you (just to be clear, not aiming this at anyone) know about selfishness? How much do you donate to charity? Have you ever worked in a poverty-stricken area and seen it up close and personal? Some people have, and come back humbled by the experience. A friend of mine went to Kenya and helped install a PC network...they were overjoyed to have a by-now outdated bunch of castoff computers that we might have had 5-10 years ago. We take things for granted...that's the point. I can't make these points without generalising, but the basic idea is clear.
It's a good analogy, the birthday party...but playing devil's advocate, the blacklist would also include anyone you wanted. To use your analogy you would be able to ban a child from the birthday party for being deaf, or Spanish, or because a friend's ex told you some gossip about their parents. That child didn't disrupt your last party but you banned them anyway...that's possibly the best analogy we can use for the problems with that idea.
Again, the blacklist could be abused, it would be abused and it is not inherent abuse in itself! That's why other folk have raised concerns about that idea and have posted alternatives. Even Mith seemed to like the idea of minimum rpps (see above. Also don't want to put words in his mouth, it's above. My interface for typing/referencing isn't that good
Perhaps the real problem is that some people consider anything that happens in 'their' guild (that Venan LET them have and give them carte blanche on a lot of matters) to be absolutely fine. While I understand why someone might believe that, it doesn't give you the right to behave how you want in regards to raids. A blacklist implemented to combat skunk mercs (that everyone knows are a problem, but a tiny minority) would give guilds a tool to ban whomever they like based on their own personal issues and prejudices and I doubt the company condones that.