I agree with everything Mith said.
I also agree 100% with Mith.
It is the right of a guild to be able to allow whomever they wish. A Blacklist of sorts is a great idea. It's no different then a private social club.
CrzyHopper wrote:
Maybe they can put an option on the raid screen during the raid. It can list the mercs and have a box to click to ban. When the guilds raids show up in raid finder it should have an icon showing they are locked out by the guild. That way if they aren't really a bad merc and was just having issues that day they can communicate with the GM to plead their case so they can merc there again.
If not, a lot of good mercs may get banned because of 1 bad raid. I know I've joined raids and real life unexpectedly pulled me away leaving me with low rpp. I joined with the intention to complete but things happen. I'm sure I'm not alone in this.
Mithrid wrote:Ilyana_the_Red wrote:Kicking someone because you don't like them is abuse.
...
It doesn't matter what you call it, kicking or banning someone without a legitimate reason is abuse of the power. There's a reason Venan have never implemented such a feature, because it would be far too heavily abused. I can think of several guilds who would likely immediately ban half a rival guild from any raid. There would be blacklisting of people you don't like, blacklisting of anyone from a guild that has more power than you, banning all devs or mods from certain guilds, banning Spanish people or anyone whose sexuality you have found out and don't agree with.
First off kicking and banning are two separate things. Kicking people from a raid they have legitimately entered and participated in and deserved rewards from is abuse. I won't argue that. Banning someone from a GUILD is perfectly legitimate for any reason. I view guilds as private property of the GM. They have every right to ban people for whatever reason. If guild A bans me...who cares.
If most of guild A hate Guild B and ban half of guild B..who cares...why get yourself worked up over it. Its not abuse, its not bullying.Ilyana_the_Red wrote:So no, nobody has a divine right to blacklist because abuse will happen.If I start a raid, I own the raid, I should have a divine right to limit it to people I only want participating. It already happens anyway...
1. If a guild doesn't want any others to join, they just don't open it..
......I don't see anyone yelling "abuse abuse, bullying...they wont let me in...bwahahaha"
2. If a Guild wants to open it to only select individuals, they add a password...
....again how come I don't see anyone, "bwahahaha...Guild A won't let me have their password, they are abusing their power and bullying me...bwhahaha".
3. Adding a blacklist, would allow a guild to open it more broadly, publicly, then a password locked raid, but at the same time block those individuals that for whatever reason a guild doesn't want in...it is exactly the same as items 1,2 mentioned above, just with reversed selection limiters... IT is not abuse or bullying..seriously.
4. Even now a Guild has every right to boot guild members who don't fit in or for whatever reason reason they want; sure people complain about it but everyone recognizes it as a Guild right, ...so isn't it hypocritical to say...the guild can't ban specific individuals from joining the guild, but not a guild raid...reality, heck the guilds already can in some degree, the blacklist is just another means of adjusting selection criteria beyond what already exists. It allows for a guild to open more broadly then a password locked raid, yet still control to some degree who enters. It is not abuse, just more flexibility of powers already granted.
Following BJ's disclaimer format:
My PERSONAL OPINION
People are far too sensitive and take too many things personally now-a-days, whether it is a misguided sense of entitlement or rights, they feel everyone owes them everything...sorry, no they don't...the world owes you jack. Grow a thick skin, make your own way, surround yourself with people you like and who value you and forget about the people who like to hate...you don't have a right to go and force everyone to like you. Too many people spend so much time worrying about the feelings of those who disagree with them that they can't find joy with those who do agree with them. They feel obligated to force their beliefs on everyone else...We call them Social Justice Warriors...so busy trying to force what they want on everyone else they end up making life miserable for all around them.
Ilyana_the_Red wrote:
Mith I respect your opinion but you have a habit of belittling people whether its intentional or not.
Ilyana_the_Red wrote:I did not, if you read carefully, my primary post was in response to theReaping, where I suggested that I believed a Blacklist was the easiest and best option. Apex then responded and was the first to suggest that a Blacklist would be an abuse tool in-game. I completely disagreed with him and made my points why I disagreed that a Blacklist would not be abuse. You then responded that you believed it was abuse and bullying (your words...I didn't mention it first, you did). My final response to you was to explain and detail how normal guild activities, such as opening guild only raids, or password locked raids, or even booting toons from the guild, are all activities, everyone considers normal, and that a blacklist is exactly like that. If you want, view it as a password locked raid where the guild hands out the password to everyone EXCEPT the individuals they don't want. No different, just more flexible controls of the raid as a Guild.
The mistake here is that you've taken the idea of what is 'abuse' and applied it to normal guild activities. I was never talking about guilds opening raids, passwording them or anything like that. You decided to bring it into the conversation.
Ilyana_the_Red wrote:I don't know if this is directed explicitly to me or people in general, but I am more then willing to accept that people will disagree with me....however I also have every right to argue my position when it is disagreed.
Whether you like it or not, and no matter how many free speech advocates pipe up, online bullying does exist in this game. I've seen it a lot being a mod. I've really seen the worst of the player base in this game so don't tell me about thick skins. If anything you need to accept when someone disagrees and suggest legitimate compromises or alternatives.
Ilyana_the_Red wrote:Again, if you examine the conversation Ilyana, I am not destroying or attacking anyone else's proposals..merely defending my own.
Sometimes you just have to go back and read right to the roots of a topic and find out what people were actually proposing.
Ilyana_the_Red wrote:This is a viable option, albeit a slightly more complicated one. But I didn't attack it or disagree with it.
The idea is a guild-set rpp minimum. Yes, that's right, I WANT the guild to be able to set their own rpp minimums. I also want Venan to set each raid to have an rpp minimum that you must do to be protected from booting. It probably wouldn't be particularly large, maybe 2k? This wouldn't be set by the guild, but would be based on the waves within the particular raid.
I'm actually advocating something that doesn't go near the problems of abuse...implement it properly and no more skunk merc problem, which was the reason the thread existed in the first place
Ilyana_the_Red wrote:
MY PERSONAL OPINION:
Too many people in the world today don't really care about anyone else. It's particularly prevalent in Western countries. People are so busy with their own personal gratification and beliefs they don't consider the feelings of family, friends and partners in some cases. You don't have a right to be as vile as you like to anyone else, just because they disagree with you, don't have the same lifestyle choices as you, or are even just in your way. Too many people are impolite, disrespectful and generally inhumane to their fellow citizens...and often have the gall to criticise other countries that don't use the same political systems or religious systems as them. And in light of this 'force their beliefs' comment above, I find this both ironic and hypocritical.
Ilyana_the_Red wrote:
Mith I respect your opinion but you have a habit of belittling people whether its intentional or not.
The mistake here is that you've taken the idea of what is 'abuse' and applied it to normal guild activities. I was never talking about guilds opening raids, passwording them or anything like that. You decided to bring it into the conversation.
Whether you like it or not, and no matter how many free speech advocates pipe up, online bullying does exist in this game. I've seen it a lot being a mod. I've really seen the worst of the player base in this game so don't tell me about thick skins. If anything you need to accept when someone disagrees and suggest legitimate compromises or alternatives.
Sometimes you just have to go back and read right to the roots of a topic and find out what people were actually proposing.
The idea is a guild-set rpp minimum. Yes, that's right, I WANT the guild to be able to set their own rpp minimums. I also want Venan to set each raid to have an rpp minimum that you must do to be protected from booting. It probably wouldn't be particularly large, maybe 2k? This wouldn't be set by the guild, but would be based on the waves within the particular raid.
I'm actually advocating something that doesn't go near the problems of abuse...implement it properly and no more skunk merc problem, which was the reason the thread existed in the first place
MY PERSONAL OPINION:
Too many people in the world today don't really care about anyone else. It's particularly prevalent in Western countries. People are so busy with their own personal gratification and beliefs they don't consider the feelings of family, friends and partners in some cases. You don't have a right to be as vile as you like to anyone else, just because they disagree with you, don't have the same lifestyle choices as you, or are even just in your way. Too many people are impolite, disrespectful and generally inhumane to their fellow citizens...and often have the gall to criticise other countries that don't use the same political systems or religious systems as them. And in light of this 'force their beliefs' comment above, I find this both ironic and hypocritical.
DreamingDaemon wrote:Ilyana_the_Red wrote:
Mith I respect your opinion but you have a habit of belittling people whether its intentional or not.
The mistake here is that you've taken the idea of what is 'abuse' and applied it to normal guild activities. I was never talking about guilds opening raids, passwording them or anything like that. You decided to bring it into the conversation.
Whether you like it or not, and no matter how many free speech advocates pipe up, online bullying does exist in this game. I've seen it a lot being a mod. I've really seen the worst of the player base in this game so don't tell me about thick skins. If anything you need to accept when someone disagrees and suggest legitimate compromises or alternatives.
Sometimes you just have to go back and read right to the roots of a topic and find out what people were actually proposing.
The idea is a guild-set rpp minimum. Yes, that's right, I WANT the guild to be able to set their own rpp minimums. I also want Venan to set each raid to have an rpp minimum that you must do to be protected from booting. It probably wouldn't be particularly large, maybe 2k? This wouldn't be set by the guild, but would be based on the waves within the particular raid.
I'm actually advocating something that doesn't go near the problems of abuse...implement it properly and no more skunk merc problem, which was the reason the thread existed in the first place
MY PERSONAL OPINION:
Too many people in the world today don't really care about anyone else. It's particularly prevalent in Western countries. People are so busy with their own personal gratification and beliefs they don't consider the feelings of family, friends and partners in some cases. You don't have a right to be as vile as you like to anyone else, just because they disagree with you, don't have the same lifestyle choices as you, or are even just in your way. Too many people are impolite, disrespectful and generally inhumane to their fellow citizens...and often have the gall to criticise other countries that don't use the same political systems or religious systems as them. And in light of this 'force their beliefs' comment above, I find this both ironic and hypocritical.
Comparing a blacklist of mercs within a guild to online bullying is misleading.
It's closer to child A not inviting child B to his birthday party.
The reasons an individual may be blacklisted are indeed many and varied. It might be down to previous history of mercing with that guild. It may be down to personal dislike on the part of the guild GM. It may be that the individual has developed a reputation as a disruptive influence. It might be that the GM is just being an idiot. Whatever. A guild hosting a raid has as much right to say "we do not want this individual to join" as a store has the right to refuse entry / service to a suspected or confirmed shoplifter.
I believe personally that a blacklist is preferable to a min RPP score from a technical perspective. It's easier to implement and maintain.
It also prevents disruptive individuals from joining a raid, attaining the min RPP, then sitting back and antagonising the host guild and other mercs.
An example - a guild runs a "clean" chat. If an individual disrespects that and behaves in a manner contrary to that guild's standards, then surely it is the guild's right to say that they do not want that person to return, regardless of whether they attain 100RPP or 10k? If their presence is counterproductive to the guild, that guild should absolutely have the right to say "no thanks" in future.
Compare: Mercs know which guilds they like to merc with. Many players will not merc with specific guilds. Many guilds maintain an informal "do not merc with these guilds" list.
Is that also bullying? Simply because that choice isn't technically enforced does not alter the underlying morality of the decision to join / not join based on personal feelings and / or experience of the guild in question.
Note that I have no issue with a min RPP system of some form. I just believe that a blacklist is preferable, easier to implement, and allows the guild in question a greater level of control.
To continue the theme...
MY PERSONAL OPINION
To suggest that selfishness and disrespect is more prevalent in "western" nations than elsewhere is in itself offensive. It's also cobblers.
Self-interest / gratification above the well-being of others is a natural drive of the human machine, and why humanity as a species is the cockroach of the mammals.
To continue this would be to get into the realms of history, politics, religion and morality, and I'm pretty sure I'd get at least silenced. It's also completely OT for this thread. Suffice to say that I have seen casual self-interest at the expense of others from every part of the globe I have visited first hand, and in every aspect of historical study from every corner. It's just in different forms and usually justified with "It's ok because (insert relevant cultural reason here)." This is as true in India as it is in Iraq as it is in Japan as it is in China as it is in the US. Only the justification changes its disguise. To deny this is the case is self-deceptive, to attempt to force otherwise is positively Cnutian.
Mithrid wrote:Ok Ilyana, this thread is getting tedious now, but I owe you an response as well as defend my position against your implications.Ilyana_the_Red wrote:
Mith I respect your opinion but you have a habit of belittling people whether its intentional or not.
Yeah not much I can do about that, its a weakness I have; when you are as awsome as I am its hard not to do...just ask Pimm, he gives the Raja to everyone else in my guild because he knows where it is at. #Winning!!Ilyana_the_Red wrote:I did not, if you read carefully, my primary post was in response to theReaping, where I suggested that I believed a Blacklist was the easiest and best option. Apex then responded and was the first to suggest that a Blacklist would be an abuse tool in-game. I completely disagreed with him and made my points why I disagreed that a Blacklist would not be abuse. You then responded that you believed it was abuse and bullying (your words...I didn't mention it first, you did). My final response to you was to explain and detail how normal guild activities, such as opening guild only raids, or password locked raids, or even booting toons from the guild, are all activities, everyone considers normal, and that a blacklist is exactly like that. If you want, view it as a password locked raid where the guild hands out the password to everyone EXCEPT the individuals they don't want. No different, just more flexible controls of the raid as a Guild.
The mistake here is that you've taken the idea of what is 'abuse' and applied it to normal guild activities. I was never talking about guilds opening raids, passwording them or anything like that. You decided to bring it into the conversation.
Again, my position is that a blacklist is NOT abuse (the position suggested by Apex) or 'abuse and bullying", the position you hold. Now in your defense, you did seem to focus on kicking/banning mid-raid as a big risk for abuse, and I agreed which is why I made the distinction explicitly between kicking/booting during raids and blacklisting prior to opening a raid.Ilyana_the_Red wrote:I don't know if this is directed explicitly to me or people in general, but I am more then willing to accept that people will disagree with me....however I also have every right to argue my position when it is disagreed.
Whether you like it or not, and no matter how many free speech advocates pipe up, online bullying does exist in this game. I've seen it a lot being a mod. I've really seen the worst of the player base in this game so don't tell me about thick skins. If anything you need to accept when someone disagrees and suggest legitimate compromises or alternatives.
Our last 3-4 posts have been focused soley on my defending my suggestion of the Blacklist. Not tearing into anyone else's suggestions. (Ok, I did suggest to Apex that the min Raid amount had it issues from my experience, but that wasn't the focus of my response to him)Ilyana_the_Red wrote:Again, if you examine the conversation Ilyana, I am not destroying or attacking anyone else's proposals..merely defending my own.
Sometimes you just have to go back and read right to the roots of a topic and find out what people were actually proposing.Ilyana_the_Red wrote:This is a viable option, albeit a slightly more complicated one. But I didn't attack it or disagree with it.
The idea is a guild-set rpp minimum. Yes, that's right, I WANT the guild to be able to set their own rpp minimums. I also want Venan to set each raid to have an rpp minimum that you must do to be protected from booting. It probably wouldn't be particularly large, maybe 2k? This wouldn't be set by the guild, but would be based on the waves within the particular raid.
I'm actually advocating something that doesn't go near the problems of abuse...implement it properly and no more skunk merc problem, which was the reason the thread existed in the first place
I did however make a case for why my suggestion of the blacklist is not abuse, or bullying and how it is no different than current guild powers, just easier to effect the guild powers already in play.Ilyana_the_Red wrote:
MY PERSONAL OPINION:
Too many people in the world today don't really care about anyone else. It's particularly prevalent in Western countries. People are so busy with their own personal gratification and beliefs they don't consider the feelings of family, friends and partners in some cases. You don't have a right to be as vile as you like to anyone else, just because they disagree with you, don't have the same lifestyle choices as you, or are even just in your way. Too many people are impolite, disrespectful and generally inhumane to their fellow citizens...and often have the gall to criticise other countries that don't use the same political systems or religious systems as them. And in light of this 'force their beliefs' comment above, I find this both ironic and hypocritical.
Isn't suggesting it is prevalent in western societies racist/nation-ist or something...I thought it was politically incorrect to single out any socio-economic group for stereotyping? However, I'm tired now so I will let the fact that you basically implied that I treat people in a vile manner because they disagree with me, implied I am impolite, disrespectful and inhumane and then called me a hypocrite... fly....no skin off my teeth...my skin is plenty thick enough to take it.
Ilyana_the_Red wrote:DreamingDaemon wrote:
Comparing a blacklist of mercs within a guild to online bullying is misleading.
It's closer to child A not inviting child B to his birthday party.
The reasons an individual may be blacklisted are indeed many and varied. It might be down to previous history of mercing with that guild. It may be down to personal dislike on the part of the guild GM. It may be that the individual has developed a reputation as a disruptive influence. It might be that the GM is just being an idiot. Whatever. A guild hosting a raid has as much right to say "we do not want this individual to join" as a store has the right to refuse entry / service to a suspected or confirmed shoplifter.
I believe personally that a blacklist is preferable to a min RPP score from a technical perspective. It's easier to implement and maintain.
It also prevents disruptive individuals from joining a raid, attaining the min RPP, then sitting back and antagonising the host guild and other mercs.
An example - a guild runs a "clean" chat. If an individual disrespects that and behaves in a manner contrary to that guild's standards, then surely it is the guild's right to say that they do not want that person to return, regardless of whether they attain 100RPP or 10k? If their presence is counterproductive to the guild, that guild should absolutely have the right to say "no thanks" in future.
Compare: Mercs know which guilds they like to merc with. Many players will not merc with specific guilds. Many guilds maintain an informal "do not merc with these guilds" list.
Is that also bullying? Simply because that choice isn't technically enforced does not alter the underlying morality of the decision to join / not join based on personal feelings and / or experience of the guild in question.
Note that I have no issue with a min RPP system of some form. I just believe that a blacklist is preferable, easier to implement, and allows the guild in question a greater level of control.
To continue the theme...
MY PERSONAL OPINION
To suggest that selfishness and disrespect is more prevalent in "western" nations than elsewhere is in itself offensive. It's also cobblers.
Self-interest / gratification above the well-being of others is a natural drive of the human machine, and why humanity as a species is the cockroach of the mammals.
To continue this would be to get into the realms of history, politics, religion and morality, and I'm pretty sure I'd get at least silenced. It's also completely OT for this thread. Suffice to say that I have seen casual self-interest at the expense of others from every part of the globe I have visited first hand, and in every aspect of historical study from every corner. It's just in different forms and usually justified with "It's ok because (insert relevant cultural reason here)." This is as true in India as it is in Iraq as it is in Japan as it is in China as it is in the US. Only the justification changes its disguise. To deny this is the case is self-deceptive, to attempt to force otherwise is positively Cnutian.
Well since nitpicking is a very common them on BoH forums, I'll clarify. It is particularly prevalent in Western culture because of our infatuation with consumer society. This encourages a 'me first' attitude...other countries take particular issue with it. Now, I didn't actually say it didn't exist elsewhere in the globe, but you two have taken offence at something that is true...deal with it. As society becomes more globalised these problems will intensify. So, sorry to burst the bubble...you can't just act how you want. It's a common technique when attempting to deconstruct something to focus on minutiae or the very literal interpretations of what someone has or has not said. That's why a lot of politicians refrain from making absolute statements, as that is then held against them later.