Sigèé wrote:What's wrong with mercing a LoB at the start and doing all your RPP on the twins rather than hitting in the first 5 minutes? And setting a minimum RPP required to get rewards would be fraught with problems leaving people who tried their best not getting any rewards. All this seems too complicated! As I said, my solution is ~almost~ perfect, at worst
It isn't complicated. It's a common sabotage technique in debate to call a proposition too complex to draw attention away from it. My personal objection to a 'rating' system is the time it would take to develop and make fair. What determines 'good' merc performance? It has to be rated by the guild and their own requirements. Which is why a guild would need to set their own RPP minimum reqs. Everyone knows what constitutes skunking (whether deliberate or not) and what is a fair amount of RPP in any given raid.
I'm telling you now, if you merc a LoB and wait until P4 to take any hits, people will be out for blood. You will get a very bad merc rep. This system would not allow you to do that. Want to take all your hits in P4? Join the guild proper and don't sabotage their raid by taking up a slot for so long. Or hit throughout the raid and burn later.
The point is to take the power away from the selfish mercs and put it in the hands of the guild while also allowing for the fact that a merc wouldn't be able to be kicked just for joining. Pretty simple actually.