Book of Heroes

Mercs- Skunk Mercs(Locked) · page 3

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorThu Sep 11, 2014 9:29 am
Sigèé wrote:What's wrong with mercing a LoB at the start and doing all your RPP on the twins rather than hitting in the first 5 minutes? And setting a minimum RPP required to get rewards would be fraught with problems leaving people who tried their best not getting any rewards. All this seems too complicated! As I said, my solution is ~almost~ perfect, at worst ;)

It isn't complicated. It's a common sabotage technique in debate to call a proposition too complex to draw attention away from it. My personal objection to a 'rating' system is the time it would take to develop and make fair. What determines 'good' merc performance? It has to be rated by the guild and their own requirements. Which is why a guild would need to set their own RPP minimum reqs. Everyone knows what constitutes skunking (whether deliberate or not) and what is a fair amount of RPP in any given raid.

I'm telling you now, if you merc a LoB and wait until P4 to take any hits, people will be out for blood. You will get a very bad merc rep. This system would not allow you to do that. Want to take all your hits in P4? Join the guild proper and don't sabotage their raid by taking up a slot for so long. Or hit throughout the raid and burn later.

The point is to take the power away from the selfish mercs and put it in the hands of the guild while also allowing for the fact that a merc wouldn't be able to be kicked just for joining. Pretty simple actually.
Sigèé wrote:What's wrong with mercing a LoB at the start and doing all your RPP on the twins rather than hitting in the first 5 minutes?

Well, there are people who do that and then never come back. I probably see an average of one per raid end up this way. However, a high percentage of that is just 2 people who do it over and over again. People have complained to them but they won't change their behavior. If I could blacklist those 2, problem is solved for me.

Personally, I respect my fellow mercs and don't hog spots. I would never join a LoB raid in P1 and wait for P4 to start hitting.
I am for a merc revamp! Either no limit or as GM I want an ignor button for raids if person is ignored by GM then they can not see or enter that guild raid! I guess a blacklist. If I ignore everyone then my problem why I have no mercs! Also if I join a failing raid would like a way to leave it. Keep my e and give me no valor but let me go!!!!!
Bbbb wrote:
Sigèé wrote:What's wrong with mercing a LoB at the start and doing all your RPP on the twins rather than hitting in the first 5 minutes?

Well, there are people who do that and then never come back. I probably see an average of one per raid end up this way. However, a high percentage of that is just 2 people who do it over and over again. People have complained to them but they won't change their behavior. If I could blacklist those 2, problem is solved for me.

Personally, I respect my fellow mercs and don't hog spots. I would never join a LoB raid in P1 and wait for P4 to start hitting.

So a merc who joins LoB at the start but only dumps 50e in P4 isn't ideal I agree, however I think it's actually more useful than a merc who dumps 50e in P1 and never comes back, which is much more common. Both are better than someone who only hits 3 times of course! But is there something you dislike about a merc who joins at the start of LoB, doesn't hit until P4 but then does 15-20k RPP? I find that even more helpful than someone who enters with full e, uses it all and keeps coming back with regen.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorThu Sep 11, 2014 2:34 pm
Waiting until P4 (because it has the best drops, presumably) and then spending any amount of e is freeloading. Hitting in P1 moves the raid along quickly and helps negate the effect of freeloaders and those people who only hit in P2-3 (you know who you are) sitting on a couple of hits for a long time while they wait for other people to push the raid along. Now it's a greyer area when you don't have any pots or shields. Some people might think waiting to onslaught and then hitting Phases 2-4 is fine.

However 'I do high RPP' isn't an excuse to onslaught and then abandon the raid. Lots of people manage to help the raids outside those phases.
Personally, I have no problem with mercs who join p1 and hit to keep their e from totally refilling until OS, just so long as they hit through the whole raid. If a guild is running a raid(LoB/KFS) and is constantly relying on mercs to get them through p1, they probably shouldn't be running said raid in the first place. I generally try to bring 2 toons to a raid in mercing so one can help push through p1, but that is neither here nor there.
With that being said, i would foresee some problems with having a min RPP in a certain amount of time with LoB/KFS unless mercs could see what the limitations/expectations were prior to entering a raid. Another possibility is for Venan to have an inactivity timer added to P1 so that if you have a merc that one or two hits and "squats" for the remainder of the phase, say after 7-10min, an officer/GM would have the ability to boot the player from the raid and would be unable to rejoin(similar to the cooldown process in PvP after challenging someone).
This whole setting peramaters for booting mercs in raids is tricky but thought I'd give my 2 cents.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon Sep 22, 2014 3:56 am
GunpowderSara_PirateQueen wrote:Personally, I have no problem with mercs who join p1 and hit to keep their e from totally refilling until OS, just so long as they hit through the whole raid. If a guild is running a raid(LoB/KFS) and is constantly relying on mercs to get them through p1, they probably shouldn't be running said raid in the first place. I generally try to bring 2 toons to a raid in mercing so one can help push through p1, but that is neither here nor there.
With that being said, i would foresee some problems with having a min RPP in a certain amount of time with LoB/KFS unless mercs could see what the limitations/expectations were prior to entering a raid. Another possibility is for Venan to have an inactivity timer added to P1 so that if you have a merc that one or two hits and "squats" for the remainder of the phase, say after 7-10min, an officer/GM would have the ability to boot the player from the raid and would be unable to rejoin(similar to the cooldown process in PvP after challenging someone).
This whole setting peramaters for booting mercs in raids is tricky but thought I'd give my 2 cents.

The idea would be that every merc would know what was expected of them in terms of the whole raid (minimum RPP, below which your rewards are zero) and the hitting req to stay in the raid (hit a minimum amount in a certain period or guild officers can kick you). Both would be obvious when joining the raid, as easy as a pop-up showing you the reqs before you enter. This way, if a skunk merc joins your raid, hits once then leaves, once the time to meet the early req expires, you can kick them. It also means someone who has a genuine reason to not hit can be politely removed without taking up a slot for the whole raid.
Sigèé wrote:
So a merc who joins LoB at the start but only dumps 50e in P4 isn't ideal I agree, however I think it's actually more useful than a merc who dumps 50e in P1 and never comes back, which is much more common. Both are better than someone who only hits 3 times of course! But is there something you dislike about a merc who joins at the start of LoB, doesn't hit until P4 but then does 15-20k RPP? I find that even more helpful than someone who enters with full e, uses it all and keeps coming back with regen.

As I said, I was specifically talking about a couple of people who hop on at the beginning of P1, never do more than a couple of hits on P1, and have a good chance (50% or higher) of ending the raid with like 100 RPP because they never came back at all. In fact, I think they hop on a LoB and a KFS at the same time and whatever hits onslaught first is the one they do. Usually they magically vanish when onslaught ends too. That's why I want a blacklist - get rid of this small group of people. One person is so bad that several people in my guild have just started insulting him to his face in hopes that he will go away.

My guild would much prefer the merc who dumps 50e in P1 than P4 (numerous members will burn P4), but either way that's not who I'm complaining about it at all.

Anyway, please note that Ilyana and I are promoting different things. I just want to permanently ban a couple of people from joining raids. She wants a more complex system that addresses the problem at a more granular level. I'm neither for or against her request.

Famous_Fella_O_Nutella

Mon Sep 22, 2014 1:56 pm
I had an idea I posted on my topic "Suggestion for Deadbeat Mercs" This is a recurring complaint, I hope Venan can think of a fair solution.
@B4...most of the guilds probably know who you are referring to if they think long and hard enough. I agree with Ilyana that the "ban" method could and probably would be abused. A better solution would be to have the devs ban those 2 individual players (and anyone else who has shown repeated abuse) from mercing any raids whatsoever and limiting them to irritating their own guilds, that way if they wanted to participate in a raid they would have to actually join a guild to raid with them and thus not needlessly take up a merc spot.