Book of Heroes

Mercs- Skunk Mercs(Locked) · page 2

CrzyHopper wrote:
King_Fizz wrote:
Ilyana wrote:Don't think they exist ;) even the top guilds open sometimes.

The hidden guild (Salad's Army) doesnt need mercs

Any guild can gold a GG raid ;)

Way to ruin my secret .... ;)

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon Sep 1, 2014 7:41 am
Ilyana wrote:
Rokk wrote:I would like to propose that toons who join a raid as a merc and then do not hit or hit once and leave thereby effectively sabotaging the raid be banned from mercing for a week. Perhaps with the option of presenting extenuating circumstantial evidence to over-turn their ban.

I think it's time to introduce minimum rpp limits that are set by the guild. Don't do the rpp, you don't get anything but your hits still count towards the raid. The guild can also kick you if you don't meet a set rpp count (also guild-set) within a certain period. This would balance things by protecting mercs from vengeful guilds kicking them just because their rpp is too low, too high or is just a player they don't like.

And yes abuse would happen if guilds were allowed to kick anyone they liked at any time.

Thread derailed, shameless bump.
I'm so tired of that one high might guy (all the top guilds know who I am talking about) taking up slots in raids and then not hitting 90% of the time. I'm more annoyed from the player side because it is hard to get LoB slots at times and he is selfishly wasting one.

Just give guild's a blacklist is probably the solution.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorWed Sep 3, 2014 4:34 am
Bbbb wrote:I'm so tired of that one high might guy (all the top guilds know who I am talking about) taking up slots in raids and then not hitting 90% of the time. I'm more annoyed from the player side because it is hard to get LoB slots at times and he is selfishly wasting one.

Just give guild's a blacklist is probably the solution.

Agree. Though blacklists would be abused, we all know it. I don't care who's guild it is, nobody should get a free pass to be vindictive.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorWed Sep 3, 2014 6:04 pm
Sigèé wrote:I already suggested an ~almost~ perfect solution :-)

viewtopic.php?f=5&t=6179

I wouldn't call it perfect - it needs a foolproof method of calculation. If a merc doesn't hit more than five times, how does the system know to lower their rating?

The solution needs to be scaleable and set by the guild while also being fair to those people who might be victimised by certain guilds.
If a merc doesn't hit more than five times, that would be enough to lower their rating in most cases. An exception would be MVP raids, but the calculation to decide if they did well or not needs to look at their RPP compared to the average and their position. To be fair to mercs with lower than 50 max e it could also look at max e, time in the raid and e spent. I don't think the formula would be that complicated, but perhaps if I come up with one it will give my suggestion more credence.

I don't know what you mean by scaleable and set by the guild. The guild would set a merc rating that mercs must have or exceed to be able to join the raid. A guild would not be able to victimise anyone!
If someone has joined a raid and has not hit sufficiently in the phase they come in on then the guild should be able to boot them

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorTue Sep 9, 2014 6:48 pm
Sigèé wrote:If a merc doesn't hit more than five times, that would be enough to lower their rating in most cases. An exception would be MVP raids, but the calculation to decide if they did well or not needs to look at their RPP compared to the average and their position. To be fair to mercs with lower than 50 max e it could also look at max e, time in the raid and e spent. I don't think the formula would be that complicated, but perhaps if I come up with one it will give my suggestion more credence.

I don't know what you mean by scaleable and set by the guild. The guild would set a merc rating that mercs must have or exceed to be able to join the raid. A guild would not be able to victimise anyone!

Scaleable and set by guild - a minimum rpp count that the guild sets. Below this rpp level your hits count toward the raid, but you get NO rewards until you cross the rpp minimum.

The guild can also only kick you if you don't do a certain rpp (probably Venan-set) within an allotted amount of time. For example:

Merc RPP threshold: 5000 RPP.
Kick Threshold: must post 1500 RPP within the first 5 minutes.

These are just examples. As I said Venan would probably have to set the kick threshold while the merc rpp would be set by the guild. It would also have to be fair. So no setting your merc RPP req to 15,000 or something unrealistic. The top and bottom limits of the merc rpp threshold would also probably have to depend on when the raid was opened, how many waves there are, whether the raid is onslaught etc etc.
What's wrong with mercing a LoB at the start and doing all your RPP on the twins rather than hitting in the first 5 minutes? And setting a minimum RPP required to get rewards would be fraught with problems leaving people who tried their best not getting any rewards. All this seems too complicated! As I said, my solution is ~almost~ perfect, at worst ;)