ÅpêxØfThëZømbøçålÿpsë wrote:
Still, abuse can occur AFTER the raid, because if the guild was attempting to tie and one merc messed it up, they could blacklist him because he/she simply wanted/needed valor, ht, or silver. Or if a toon joined, and the GM did not like that person, they'd blacklist immedhately after a raid.
I do not see any of this as abuse, I see this as legitimately allowing the guilds to control who they want to enter their raids. Specificv to your example, if a merc is a guest and the guild tells him they want a tie, and he blows it for his own self interest, thats the guilds legitimate prerogative to say, you are not welcome back". Again, none of what you have mentioned is abuse. Its giving guilds better control over who they will allow to enter.
ÅpêxØfThëZømbøçålÿpsë wrote:
There's no real effective way to do this without someone finding a way to abuse it. Hell, I was in a guild for a total of two days before an officer kicked me because of past problems from us being in a different guild. I don't want to say it, but I will: It's been proven, time and again, that people with power will abuse it at some point in the duration that they have power.
Of course they do; its human nature. But in this case the abuse is not detrimental to anyone, other than they are not welcome to one specific guild. Per your example, You were booted by an officer that didn't like you, well if the GM did you would have been reinstated easily by a few whispers, the GM would have set it straight...the fact that your weren't represents that you weren't necessarily welcome then and it was probably time to move on anyway.
What you are complaining about is what I feel a guild can legitimate decide within its own governing body. Now if the guild wants to behave like a bunch of affhats, that is their choice and guess what, they wont last long, good toons will not stay.
But the primary abuse most people are worried about is for a merc to contribute to a raid and then get booted just prior to finish and the guild collects his RPP that they didnt earn...that is legitimate abuse. But banning someone from a guild because the guild leadership simply doesn't like them should be legitimate power for any guild...they should be allowed to do it for something as stupid as they don't like the toons name or any other reason...that is not abuse. The point is too allow the guilds control over who can come and go within their own domain.
And again, I've known some of the best GMs in the game, they don't tolerate BS or boot toons to be jerks, and they don't allow their officers to do the same. They should be allowed power to control who enters and leaves their raids. And those guilds/GM's/Officers who do behave poorly by most standards, with their blacklists and bootings, well I already stated that poorly managed guilds never survive long. Thus why Im not worried about that.
ÅpêxØfThëZømbøçålÿpsë wrote:
It'd be A LOT of work, but the best way to prevent no hitters, in my opinion, is to set up a system that is able to use a toon's current energy to figure out a minimum amount of RPP. Such as, toons with 26 e+ should have a minimum of 2000 RPP and as their e increases, so does the minimum amount of RPP they need. If the same toon goes under that minimum RPP, let's say 4 times within a day, they should be prohibited from mercing for a set amount of time that is determined by the tier of Raid they are participating in. I'm not sure if Venan could manage to do this, but it seems like it'd be the best option currently until a better system is figured out.
No need for such a system, and it would punish legitimate activities. Example, it is not unheard of for Spoons to setup a dummy raid for me to enter simply so I can chat with them, nobody hits jack, but then I leave and they cancel. If this system was implemented, that simple means of visiting other guilds would be tossed and suck.
I think simply giving guilds a blacklist option, without power to boot from an active raid but block them from future raids, is valid, and not subject to abuse. There is nothing wrong/abusive with a guild simply telling a toon, "you are not welcome to our future raids".
FULL DISCLOSURE: I know several guilds that may very well have blacklisted me in the past, and deservedly so. Jump, DJ...remember the good old RSA raids with Rome. I miss Rome...good times...
Prior to that, Leeloo can attest that LunaTabby would have blacklisted Fero and my behind so fast from Blue Harvest...gawd Luna hated Fero so much it was too funny. On second thought a blacklist really would ruin our ability to harass guilds..maybe its not such a good idea after all...
