Book of Heroes

Proposal for comprehensive pirate event solution

To our hosts at Venan:

You have heard a number of opinions with regard to the pirate event. I have yet to read one that is positive. I want to offer here my thoughts on the matter. I do so out of respect for your stewardship of the game, and your efforts to make it work. I appreciate and have applauded many of the initiatives that went into the pirate event. I looked forward to participating with members of other guilds and to enjoying a new raid. I'm saddened to see the problems arising from the misjudgments made in execution.

I hope you will regard me as a friend and supporter, because I'm not one to criticize blindly. I have generally counseled patience. Unfortunately, that option is not available to you. The event is only 10 days long and by the time you act, probably after the weekend, it will be 1/3 over. Already people are discontinuing their participation in the event, and that's a real shame because it could have been so much fun.

I had hoped that this event would bring some excitement and novelty into the game. Instead, it is bringing little but hard feelings and accusations. My hope is that you can recover and salvage some of the good will you hoped to bring if you act quickly, humbly, and decisively. I offer the following suggestions:

1. Award gold valor for all pirate raids started before your fix, regardless of completion, and regardless of time. This is a necessary apology for Venan's misjudgment and an attempt to dispel some of the problems the event has caused. You messed up. So 'fess up and pay up. Do not risk further dissatisfaction of your customers by hanging on to something that costs you nothing but some time.

2. Fix the raid by doing some or all of the following:

A. Reducing the difficulty of the final level, particularly for lower level/might players. I had people with me saying they took over 3 minutes for one kill. That's insane. I could handle it fine. It was about the same difficulty as Vilepaw. Others in the raid had substantially more difficulty, and we are all in this together.

B. Increasing the number of toons who can raid.

C. Allowing guilds which have opened Cursed Keep or higher to offer the raids. If a guild does offer it, the raid is open to all guild members and AUTOMATICALLY open to mercs. This will let lower level toons participate while ensuring that higher level toons are there to push it through.

D. Reduce the number of waves without adjusting the time.

3. Consider extending the event so that the 10 day period begins the day you put in the fix, so people can enjoy it as you originally intended and earn the items you've made available. It is still a good idea.

4. We need assurances as soon as possible, that you hear us and will act swiftly to address these issues. Even if your solution differs from mine, we need to here from developers, not just moderators, saying that they understand our concerns and are working as quickly as possible to address them.
Let me add something. I just finished a raid that required 4 of us to lightly burn just to make bronze. Stat-wise 15 people out of the total 40 did not even spend 50e during the entire raid. The payout of dubloon was pathetic considering the amount of burning required to even finish the raid. In all honesty it is smarter for people to spend all the gs they would have burning...on just buying the coins from the market.


Raising the merc cap and raising the reward is of paramount importance.


As for compensation for everyone that participated/burned but still resulted in a failed raid..well venan probably won't refund you gs but they just might compensate in some other way ie e pots or something. I of course do not speak for venan and their decisions are theirs to make. But they have always given something back when real problems/hiccups occured.
I agree with these solutions from Derrin. One other area that needs to be addressed is the reward balance. Buying doubloons in the shop is the 'easy' way to get them but should not be as profitable as earning them in the raid.

The 5gs for 100doubloons is consistent with how past event markers were bought, so the earning rate in raids should be increased (at minimum) so a bronze non-MVP finish yields doubloons at that rate had epots/GS been spent to earn a given level of RPP.
Previously completed (and per Derrin, non-completed) raids should be re-compensated at these new levels.
I would like to suggest having certain level caps for raids.

5-13 raid together
14-25 raid together
26-33 raid together

This would help with the adjustment of the mobs and bosses.

I understand the mobs and bosses level are adjusted to the toons level however lower level toons do not have the same amount of energy the higher levels toons have so the number of mobs and bosses should be adjusted as well.

I also agree with Derrin's suggested changes. Please do something venan. This was such a let down.

WonderTwinFormOfa

Fri Sep 12, 2014 7:58 pm
Those are some awesome suggestions! Thanks for them, hopefully venan takes a look and seriously considers them
This is great. A problem I see in the future is that once those that can afford to burn wise-up and just buy the items they want, raids will be left without any burners. So you will have even more raids fail than you have now. In two days these raids will be useless. This problem will only get worse until something is done.....soon.
Simp wrote:This problem will only get worse until something is done.....soon.

This is why I urge Venan to restart the clock on the event. I got an rpp of 48K for a bronze raid paying about 1500 valor and lasting over 3 hours, valor I could have purchased for 75 shields. Take me out and the raid fails. I will not make that mistake again. And I doubt I am alone.

I am willing to forgo earning essence for much of a week if the rewards in fun, in association with other players, and in interesting gear, are worth it to me. That's why I urge Venan to fix it as soon as they can. But I recognize that likely won't happen until Monday.
People are angry as the freeloader problem is clearly evident. What annoys me is the fact Venan made no reponse to this outcry as of yet. There doesn't need to be a lengthy explaination, a simple we are looking into this can calm a lot of people down. This has been a huge disappointment.
B_Râd wrote:I would like to suggest having certain level caps for raids.

5-13 raid together
14-25 raid together
26-33 raid together

This would help with the adjustment of the mobs and bosses.

I understand the mobs and bosses level are adjusted to the toons level however lower level toons do not have the same amount of energy the higher levels toons have so the number of mobs and bosses should be adjusted as well.
I had the same thing in mind, maybe even with a finer granularity (5-10, 10-15...). Not only will a lower player not have the same amount of energy to start with, you also can't expect a level 10 player to be as dedicated in coming back regularly and using all its energy as a seasoned top guild member.
I don't know how easy it will be to implement for Venan though. Reducing the number of waves and increasing payout, on the other hand, is a quick fix.

Thanks Derrin for this thread. Right now it seems the best way to go through this is getting everyone in your guild to join at the same time…