Book of Heroes

Proposal for comprehensive pirate event solution · page 3

Good ideas from everyone here!
Drop some doubloons instead of silver after each wave, as Raiden suggested, and at least the energy spent in a failed raid wouldn't be a total waste.
And please "nerf" that last boss. Lower might toons (with respect to their level) just keep dying here, making it no fun for them, and reducing further the number of active raiders...
Social loafing is an obvious problem in public raids and creates ridiculous headaches for those invested in the raids. The ideas above could be real remedies for those headaches!

Bringoutyourdead

Sat Sep 13, 2014 4:56 am
Ill be blunt.. this event sucks.. its a money grab by Venan. I know you are a business out to make money... but you have
alienated past and future customers with this abomination.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorSat Sep 13, 2014 6:33 am
aredherren wrote:Social loafing is an obvious problem in public raids and creates ridiculous headaches for those invested in the raids. The ideas above could be real remedies for those headaches!

I was told the raid rewards were fine because I had to do loads of raids to get enough valour for a T16 piece of gear in comparison. However the event only lasts 10 days. I don't burn so I'm on regular 50 plus regen.

It's a problem in the majority of opened raids, public, guild or event, that some mercs just join and don't hit. The eye-opening thing is that this problem has been obvious since 1.6.

The lessons of 1.6 were:

I) Don't make raids too difficult. Karnak, LoB and HiM were all tweaked because you aimed too high. What's wrong with aiming it lower...surely there is now a mountain of data on those three raids?

II) The mercing system got broken. It was tweaked slightly but it's STILL broken. How many people have to say it? There are many good ideas out there about fixing it. My perception is that you just don't want to or can't agree how. Make a decision.

III) A large amount of goodwill was lost by implementing Guild Loyalty, goodwill I'm not sure ever returned.

Why weren't these lessons learned? Seriously it's been pointed out so many times what the above issues were and they've all come back in this event. Is it that the serious comments are being drowned out by the wash of everything else? Do you need a more concise place or means for feedback?
Let me remind and request that this thread is not for comments saying essentially "Venan is dumb and greedy and the raid is awful." Such comments don't help. Venan knows we don't like the raid. They get it and they will deal with it. They have told us they will and they have a good track record when it comes to responding to members. They said they will make an announcement this weekend and I believe them. They've requested patience and that is a reasonable request. If you don't like the event, then do some normal raids until they fix it.

The purpose of this thread is for positive suggestions of things Venan can do to make it right and improve this event going forward. There have been several unique ideas that have been introduced and I appreciate those who have taken the trouble to make those constructive comments.
Another suggestion to how this event could be run is to run it like St. Patrick's day event.

Let everyone have a chance to meet Captain DarkThorn in non OS raid phases.

That would work well for us as well.
DjCleric wrote:Another suggestion to how this event could be run is to run it like St. Patrick's day event.

Let everyone have a chance to meet Captain DarkThorn in non OS raid phases.

I really enjoyed the St. Patrick's event as well. I thought that was a brilliant concept to simultaneously have an event and support the guilds.

One of the things I like about this event is it gives people a change to finish up their pirate kills feat. Those guilds still working on pirate challenges will find their totals improving as members do the raid. We would lose much of that if we just met Darkthorn
B_Râd wrote:I would like to suggest having certain level caps for raids.

5-13 raid together
14-25 raid together
26-33 raid together

This would help with the adjustment of the mobs and bosses.

I understand the mobs and bosses level are adjusted to the toons level however lower level toons do not have the same amount of energy the higher levels toons have so the number of mobs and bosses should be adjusted as well.

I also agree with Derrin's suggested changes. Please do something venan. This was such a let down.


I like this level cap idea better than having guilds run the raids. If guilds run this event we will be stuck with a few high level guilds getting all the goodies and everyone else getting bupkiss.
B_Râd wrote:I would like to suggest having certain level caps for raids.

5-13 raid together
14-25 raid together
26-33 raid together

This would help with the adjustment of the mobs and bosses.

I understand the mobs and bosses level are adjusted to the toons level however lower level toons do not have the same amount of energy the higher levels toons have so the number of mobs and bosses should be adjusted as well.

I also agree with Derrin's suggested changes. Please do something venan. This was such a let down.


I like this level cap idea better than having guilds run the raids. If guilds run this event we will be stuck with a few high level guilds getting all the goodies and everyone else getting bupkiss.
B_Râd wrote:I would like to suggest having certain level caps for raids.

5-13 raid together
14-25 raid together
26-33 raid together

This would help with the adjustment of the mobs and bosses.

I understand the mobs and bosses level are adjusted to the toons level however lower level toons do not have the same amount of energy the higher levels toons have so the number of mobs and bosses should be adjusted as well.

I also agree with Derrin's suggested changes. Please do something venan. This was such a let down.


I like this level cap idea better than having guilds run the raids. If guilds run this event we will be stuck with a few high level guilds getting all the goodies and everyone else getting bupkiss.