Book of Heroes

Proposal for comprehensive pirate event solution · page 5

The problem with allowing GMs to kick people is that it can and will be abused. There will always be people who abuse what little power they have, no matter what form that power takes. Raid tagging is one such thing.

"Oh I can take up a spot in a raid and ruin it for someone. Let's do that."

Now I'm not completely opposed to the idea of auto kicking taggers. Some will say "but real life happens" and it sure does. I used to GM my own guild back in the days and at one point I questioned why some people had only made a few hits in a raid not to be seen again, only to later recieve word from one such player that their baby child had gotten ill and was throwing up all over the place. Obviously I offered my sincere apology for lashing out in general. Lesson learned, BUT..

If your real life is stopping you from making more than a hit or two in a pirate event raid every few hours, a ten day long event isn't going to net you any amount of doubloons that can buy you more than a chest or two total anyway, so why bother with the event? You won't really be losing anything if you're kicked out, and if you are one of the rare few who had an accident that had to be dealt with irl odds are pretty low that you'll have another one during the next raid. So simply join a new one.

Therefor I propose the following:

Between phases, if someone has only made a few hits since start, or the last phase switch, automatically exclude them from the raid and free up the spot.

Or alternatively:

Make the raid instead an infinite zone, with pirates, and have Darkthorn be a random encounter in that zone, like the elite mob zones (Heart of the Ebian et al.). This will of course remove some of the flavour of it being a raid that is finite, but might work better still.

I am well aware that things like events are prepared and coded months in advance, and that it's probably not possible to make any such changes until next year, but I thought I'd propose them here anyway.

Thanks for listening.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorSun Sep 14, 2014 11:47 am
RF_finnpalm wrote:The problem with allowing GMs to kick people is that it can and will be abused. There will always be people who abuse what little power they have, no matter what form that power takes. Raid tagging is one such thing.

"Oh I can take up a spot in a raid and ruin it for someone. Let's do that."

Now I'm not completely opposed to the idea of auto kicking taggers. Some will say "but real life happens" and it sure does. I used to GM my own guild back in the days and at one point I questioned why some people had only made a few hits in a raid not to be seen again, only to later recieve word from one such player that their baby child had gotten ill and was throwing up all over the place. Obviously I offered my sincere apology for lashing out in general. Lesson learned, BUT..

If your real life is stopping you from making more than a hit or two in a pirate event raid every few hours, a ten day long event isn't going to net you any amount of doubloons that can buy you more than a chest or two total anyway, so why bother with the event? You won't really be losing anything if you're kicked out, and if you are one of the rare few who had an accident that had to be dealt with irl odds are pretty low that you'll have another one during the next raid. So simply join a new one.

Therefor I propose the following:

Between phases, if someone has only made a few hits since start, or the last phase switch, automatically exclude them from the raid and free up the spot.

Or alternatively:

Make the raid instead an infinite zone, with pirates, and have Darkthorn be a random encounter in that zone, like the elite mob zones (Heart of the Ebian et al.). This will of course remove some of the flavour of it being a raid that is finite, but might work better still.

I am well aware that things like events are prepared and coded months in advance, and that it's probably not possible to make any such changes until next year, but I thought I'd propose them here anyway.

Thanks for listening.

Prepared and coded months in advance - to be a raid setup already tested and rejected by the players years ago (1.6).

Real life doesn't account for all those non hitters. I doubt it accounts for half of them. Best proposal I can think of is halving the number of waves (or whatever works out best). Make it significantly easier for people to get in and accumulate hits. Then we'd get gold raids, happy people and maybe some nice items.

If the problems with this event are addressed in a satisfactory manner and people are compensated properly, the damage to player goodwill can be limited or even cancelled out.
The way it goes now i go in bank rupt next week !

i simply cannot burn Gold shield for all my tooons , credit card limit ! :shock:

i build army because theres no spirit in this game . you try join team then all work for their own
benefit ...then one day you decide create you own guild . So you need more energy , no rules
against that ? Ok , then you buy here and there , you run half raid and people still dont join ?

Then new rules appear , items you buy are now free ...Public raid appear , why my sooooo
stupid build that much !!! buy that much for nothing !!!

And You All gonna say i Have no Spirit !!!

This is a joke , 3 hours for 100 doubloons ...Closed ticket not help agree ...but yes , i am angry
why , ? :o
Personnal Opinion
Ilyana_the_Red wrote:
RF_finnpalm wrote:The problem with allowing GMs to kick people is that it can and will be abused. There will always be people who abuse what little power they have, no matter what form that power takes. Raid tagging is one such thing.

"Oh I can take up a spot in a raid and ruin it for someone. Let's do that."

Now I'm not completely opposed to the idea of auto kicking taggers. Some will say "but real life happens" and it sure does. I used to GM my own guild back in the days and at one point I questioned why some people had only made a few hits in a raid not to be seen again, only to later recieve word from one such player that their baby child had gotten ill and was throwing up all over the place. Obviously I offered my sincere apology for lashing out in general. Lesson learned, BUT..

If your real life is stopping you from making more than a hit or two in a pirate event raid every few hours, a ten day long event isn't going to net you any amount of doubloons that can buy you more than a chest or two total anyway, so why bother with the event? You won't really be losing anything if you're kicked out, and if you are one of the rare few who had an accident that had to be dealt with irl odds are pretty low that you'll have another one during the next raid. So simply join a new one.

Therefor I propose the following:

Between phases, if someone has only made a few hits since start, or the last phase switch, automatically exclude them from the raid and free up the spot.

Or alternatively:

Make the raid instead an infinite zone, with pirates, and have Darkthorn be a random encounter in that zone, like the elite mob zones (Heart of the Ebian et al.). This will of course remove some of the flavour of it being a raid that is finite, but might work better still.

I am well aware that things like events are prepared and coded months in advance, and that it's probably not possible to make any such changes until next year, but I thought I'd propose them here anyway.

Thanks for listening.

Prepared and coded months in advance - to be a raid setup already tested and rejected by the players years ago (1.6).

Real life doesn't account for all those non hitters. I doubt it accounts for half of them. Best proposal I can think of is halving the number of waves (or whatever works out best). Make it significantly easier for people to get in and accumulate hits. Then we'd get gold raids, happy people and maybe some nice items.

If the problems with this event are addressed in a satisfactory manner and people are compensated properly, the damage to player goodwill can be limited or even cancelled out.

I think you misread my post. I know real life doesn't account for all the non-hitters. That's why I used the term "the rare few" for those who actually have a reason to leave a raid.
I think something which could work is allocating slots according to level.

Level 30-33 20 slots
Level 20-30 15 slots
Level 10 and under 5 slots

I do think the amount of slots need to be increased from 40.

The biggest problem is gotta be deadbeat raiders, there's got to be a way to kick them from raid after certain amount of time.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon Sep 15, 2014 3:55 am
RF_finnpalm wrote:
Ilyana_the_Red wrote:
RF_finnpalm wrote:The problem with allowing GMs to kick people is that it can and will be abused. There will always be people who abuse what little power they have, no matter what form that power takes. Raid tagging is one such thing.

"Oh I can take up a spot in a raid and ruin it for someone. Let's do that."

Now I'm not completely opposed to the idea of auto kicking taggers. Some will say "but real life happens" and it sure does. I used to GM my own guild back in the days and at one point I questioned why some people had only made a few hits in a raid not to be seen again, only to later recieve word from one such player that their baby child had gotten ill and was throwing up all over the place. Obviously I offered my sincere apology for lashing out in general. Lesson learned, BUT..

If your real life is stopping you from making more than a hit or two in a pirate event raid every few hours, a ten day long event isn't going to net you any amount of doubloons that can buy you more than a chest or two total anyway, so why bother with the event? You won't really be losing anything if you're kicked out, and if you are one of the rare few who had an accident that had to be dealt with irl odds are pretty low that you'll have another one during the next raid. So simply join a new one.

Therefor I propose the following:

Between phases, if someone has only made a few hits since start, or the last phase switch, automatically exclude them from the raid and free up the spot.

Or alternatively:

Make the raid instead an infinite zone, with pirates, and have Darkthorn be a random encounter in that zone, like the elite mob zones (Heart of the Ebian et al.). This will of course remove some of the flavour of it being a raid that is finite, but might work better still.

I am well aware that things like events are prepared and coded months in advance, and that it's probably not possible to make any such changes until next year, but I thought I'd propose them here anyway.

Thanks for listening.

Prepared and coded months in advance - to be a raid setup already tested and rejected by the players years ago (1.6).

Real life doesn't account for all those non hitters. I doubt it accounts for half of them. Best proposal I can think of is halving the number of waves (or whatever works out best). Make it significantly easier for people to get in and accumulate hits. Then we'd get gold raids, happy people and maybe some nice items.

If the problems with this event are addressed in a satisfactory manner and people are compensated properly, the damage to player goodwill can be limited or even cancelled out.

I think you misread my post. I know real life doesn't account for all the non-hitters. That's why I used the term "the rare few" for those who actually have a reason to leave a raid.

Was thinking more generally when I wrote it, but cos I just quoted the whole thing it didn't sound/work how I wanted. So agree there are those that might hit and leave through circumstance IRL but these are likely a small minority.