Derrin_Watson wrote:See also their in-game news: We are aware of your concerns with the Talk Like a Pirate event. We are currently evaluating the event and will provide more information this weekend to address the event. Thank you for your patience at this time.
Good. That isn't limited to the number of failures. And they promise a response over the weekend. Excellent.
With that, I join in their call for patience. For HJ it is now business as usual and that looks to be true for a bunch of other guilds. Let's give Venan a chance to get it right and keep our cannons quiet until they do. This can still be a fun event.
Thank you Derrin. The constructive posts are much appreciated. I am also happy to to see Venan is at least listening to this thread.
Let me add their latest Facebook post:
We have multiple ideas in mind for the event and will post an update for the community when we are ready to announce any changes.
It seems to me that there are two issues here.
- This is a weekend. And it's tough to get things done on weekends. However, notwithstanding that, I think the developers (who are, after all, employees) are working on this over the weekend. I appreciate their efforts
- There are multiple possible ways to address the problems that exist. They are wise to take the time to devise something that works.
Again, there's a lot of game to enjoy. If you have e, you can spend it in pirates, confident you will receive doubloons. Or you can enjoy one of the many other raids or dungeons in the game. But in the meantime, let's be patient and give them time to get it right.
I have to suggest this. But after the event is done I think the devs should go through the raid reports for the event and do something to those that one hit or obviously low hit multiple raids throughout the event. That is one problem of the event and even for guild raids. Oops happen, but there are some people out there that are just being greedy or lazy that should be dealt with.
My annoyance level with event remains high, but Derrin is a gentleman and he wants constructive suggestions, so here goes: 1) Stop pushing a public raid agenda. They are a failure and they have no purpose except at the very lowest levels. Let guilds run raids and let mercs join them as per usual; 2) The raid is way too long, particularly since you persist in refusing to expel people who only take a few hits. The game is supposed to be fun and there is nothing fun about five hours away from your guild, plus two more hours to recharge. Shorten it or allow more than 40 members to enter. 5 hour raids are highly annoying, particularly when the participants have no accountability to hang in 3) Scale Part 3 so that low might tunes can enjoy it; 4) Provide a reward structure where there is an incentive to burn. Why would one buy an epot, if you get more from simply buying doubloons directly without the hassle of a raid you really don't want to be doing? 5) Remove people from raids who don't have a reasonable level if participation. This would be widely popular and if you instituted it for the whole game (by, for example, allowing gm's and officers the right to expel,anyone from a raid who had not met a specific rpp target by the end of each phase), not just this event, you would find that most of us would concur with the thought that the couple of days annoyance we had experienced were well worth the improvement to the game as a whole; 6) Complete all the prior raids that failed; 7) award doubloons in failed raids, but only for people with more than 4,500 RPP. That is, award those who actually tried to participate beyond taking a couple of hits or even doing one energy dump, and don't award slackers.
I hope this is just a quick fix before a major overhaul. The current system while gives dbls even in failed raids, the dbls rate is laughable. There is no incentive for anyone to burn, since I have yet to see a raid go without at least 10 ppl under 1k rpp in 4-5hours. There is no reason why p3 should be as hard for lower might players as it is. This is an event, what happened to he events that was meant to be fun and relaxing.
And of course payout sometimes wont come after failed raid ...I understand it was a quick fix and likely not flawless but still ...
As to my suggestion:
Why dont you just take the event down Venan and reopen it when you figured out how to make it half decent?
Here's the basic problem I see with this raid: it's too hard for lower-level toons. Everything else stems from that...
Those toons at the bottom aren't trying to be skunks. They are trying to participate in the event just like everyone else. But the problem is that the only phase they can really help in is phase 1. Phase 2 becomes hard for lower-level (or should I say, lower-might toons), and phase 3 is completely out of their reach. For the most part, it's not that they have left because they've dropped a bar of energy and quit. It's because they just can't make any more kills.
Combine that with the fact that 40 other people have jumped in and on average, I've been seeing phase 1 take between 5 and 7 minutes, and you end up with a very small window where low-level/might toons can actually contribute.
Because of the 'open' nature of the raid, I can't see a way around this, unless you have a very disciplined group of players working together, and they all agree to let the lower-level/might toons swing away for phase 1. Then you just have to accept the fact that they are done, and move on from there.
The next thing is that because of the 'open' nature of the raid, you have no idea what kind of mix of level/might players you are going to get. If you don't get that magic number of high-might burners in the group to reach critical mass, the raid is going to fail, or at a minimum, drag out for a long time.
If you want to have a raid-based event, then, the best suggestion I can come up with is to let guilds kick off the raid, let them get their players into the raid for the first 5 minutes, and then after that, let it become public with whatever remaining slots are available. Make the number of slots 50. That accomplishes three big things: 1) it lets an established group of players who are used to working together to drive the raid; 2) it allows lower-level toons to jump in and work with a group of players who can drive the raid. P1 may have to be extended to give those lower-level toons a chance to contribute, or the whatever might-adjusting is done for the monsters needs to be changed so that the monsters aren't an over-match for the lower-might toons. 3) assuming the guild that kicks it off would get guild power, it provides an incentive for a guild to drive these raids.
And please, up the rewards or make the items cost less to purchase. I don't know how anyone can earn enough doubloons in the current paradigm without burning an enormous amount of GS. The work week is coming, and I have no clue how anyone who works could possibly hit enough raids to make the necessary doubloons.
Nightcrawler
Regarding comments on ridiculous return rate...here's a bit of perspective. The raid returns something like 1 doubloon for every 600 RPP for the typical Bronze/fail finish. That's far worse than HitM in terms of ChV per RPP. Meanwhile the T17 gear costs about twice in doubloons what nearly equal T16 gear costs in ChV. That's completely out of whack. The raid return should be about the same as the ChV raids, maybe more since it's harder and there's no onslaught like LoB. The gear prices should be about 40% lower.
I'm a scientist so math is natural to me, but this isn't that hard!!

Venan, in analyzing this you may notice that there are still some gold and silver raids. Hopefully, you understand that this is only because high ranking guilds sized up the situation and realized that the only possible way to get a decent result is to go in together as soon as a raid spawns.
Derrin_Watson wrote:DjCleric wrote:Another suggestion to how this event could be run is to run it like St. Patrick's day event.
Let everyone have a chance to meet Captain DarkThorn in non OS raid phases.
I really enjoyed the St. Patrick's event as well. I thought that was a brilliant concept to simultaneously have an event and support the guilds.
One of the things I like about this event is it gives people a change to finish up their pirate kills feat. Those guilds still working on pirate challenges will find their totals improving as members do the raid. We would lose much of that if we just met Darkthorn
Derrin, it wouldn't take too long to get 5000 pirate kills for the feat per player. Just dump afew spare e at the Shores of Realm every now and then and it will be completed. I did that for my toons.
As for guild challenge, it will take some time but if the guild does the above mentioned, it wouldn't take too long either.
As for the math of this method,
Pirate raid : 2e per 2-3 pirates
Shores of the Realm : 2e for entry into the zone for 1-3 pirate
Then 1e for 1-3 pirate.
I mostly got 2 pirates per 1e spent on the shore.