I don't see the point of this. Even if they weren't implemented in the game mechanics, something like guilds would accrete naturally: people like predictability, and raid schedules need to be predictable in order to get the required mass of players online at the same time.
Mercs fit in quite well with the current guild model; there's no need to change it or add automatic penalties. Guildmasters already have the tools to punish anyone they see fit to punish by means of expulsion or rejection; if you don't like mercs, don't allow your members to hire themselves out as mercs, and don't hire mercs yourself. Simple. Your problem is solved, and you don't need to impose your idea of what a guild should be, or how it should be run, on anyone else. :)
I think I am giving out a wrong impression. My guild is ranked #11 and has enough dedicated members and we raid regularly so that there is no need for mercs in our guild and no need for my guild members to go out as mercs. I was just bringing this up because of what I saw in global chat.
Knagrim wrote:Then what's the point in having guilds to carry out raids. Venan should remove the concept of guilds. There is no use of guilds other than to carry out raids.
I highly disagree with this! My favorite part of the guilds is not the raids but the additional challenges that yield guild bonuses. I find pleasure in hunting down a monster type or retrieving items from around the "world" to benefit the guild. And I would gladly partake in this to boost my own guild AND as a mercenary to help other guilds if the members are kind and helpful!
My previous response was to the original poster who appeared to dislike having Mercenaries join their Guild and then leave.
After some consideration, I really like ability of Mercenary characters to chop and change Guilds as they wish.
Any Guild that does not want a mercenary joining them can set their recruitment options so they have to be accepted by an officer, or even so that nobody can apply to join. Simple. If you recognise a character as a mercenary, ignore them or reject them. If you want mercenaries to be able to join and leave your guild at will, set your recruitment options accordingly.
Mercenaries do help weak guilds who ask for help in Global Chat to complete raids that otherwise would go uncompleted. I generally ignore Global Chat, there are too many ninnies and noodleheads blathering on about nothing, but it does provide a place for Guilds to ask for help, and it appear to work. If I were playing as a mercenary I'd watch the global chat and jump in as required. I'd keep tabs on good Guilds to help, and ones that are so helpless they can't help themselves.
I don't know if Venan expected players to act as mercenaries in this way, but I doubt it. I certainly assumed that players would join an existing Guild or form a new guild with friends, then work together towards completing their challenges. That how I'm playing. The more free spirited, or those who cannot commit to specific raid times, have come up with this way to get some raids in, earn valor and hero points for their own upgrades, and play as they wish. Why should they be punished for this?
By leaving the guild after a raid they lose out on any Favors the guild has earned. Mercenaries live on their own skills, not those Favors earned by others. It's a tough life.
In fact I like the Mercenary idea so much, I'd like to see a specific Mercenary Guild to act as a home for Mercs when they aren't out helping other Guilds. That would create a chat area for Mercs to compare notes, and arrange jumping into a raid together. Venan could set this up with no limit on membership but no specific challenges (or just ignore the challenges). A Mercenary character would leave the Merc Guild to do a raid, return afterwards and be automatically accepted and sure of a warm welcome. The Guildmaster could be a Moderator or a Bot, and no officers would be required.
I like that merc guild idea a lot, Pfaff.
A specific channel to ask for mercs might also be something to consider. And if a trading system is ever implemented, talented mercs could even ask for compensation beyond regular raid rewards, offsetting the lack of guild favors. It'd be an new and interesting way of life in Glenfort.
Marney wrote:I like that merc guild idea a lot, Pfaff. 
A specific channel to ask for mercs might also be something to consider. And if a trading system is ever implemented, talented mercs could even ask for compensation beyond regular raid rewards, offsetting the lack of guild favors. It'd be an new and interesting way of life in Glenfort.
There could be a new point to people yelling in global chat "Hey guys I'm in a raid!"
Being a mercenary would be kinda cool I guess, mostly SW probably, and you would get paid your RPP in silver or something like that.
Hotasfire0Coolasice wrote:
There could be a new point to people yelling in global chat "Hey guys I'm in a raid!"
Being a mercenary would be kinda cool I guess, mostly SW probably, and you would get paid your RPP in silver or something like that.
I'd still want my RPP to be converted to Squire, Soldier or Knight's Valor (depending on the raid), and Hero Points, just like everyone else in the raid. Why mess with that.
Why mostly Shadow Warriors? I don't see why Justicars and War Mages can't be mercenaries, as I'm sure they are currently.
Pfaff wrote:Hotasfire0Coolasice wrote:
There could be a new point to people yelling in global chat "Hey guys I'm in a raid!"
Being a mercenary would be kinda cool I guess, mostly SW probably, and you would get paid your RPP in silver or something like that.
I'd still want my RPP to be converted to Squire, Soldier or Knight's Valor (depending on the raid), and Hero Points, just like everyone else in the raid. Why mess with that.
Why mostly Shadow Warriors? I don't see why Justicars and War Mages can't be mercenaries, as I'm sure they are currently.
I never said " There will be no valor"
So that answers 1.
Hello.. Its in the name SHADOW WALKER it's the rogue of this game, the assassin, the mercenary. I never said NO JUSTICARS OR MAGES ALLOWED so get off my case.
Hotasfire0Coolasice wrote:Pfaff wrote:Hotasfire0Coolasice wrote:
There could be a new point to people yelling in global chat "Hey guys I'm in a raid!"
Being a mercenary would be kinda cool I guess, mostly SW probably, and you would get paid your RPP in silver or something like that.
I'd still want my RPP to be converted to Squire, Soldier or Knight's Valor (depending on the raid), and Hero Points, just like everyone else in the raid. Why mess with that.
Why mostly Shadow Warriors? I don't see why Justicars and War Mages can't be mercenaries, as I'm sure they are currently.
I never said " There will be no valor"
So that answers 1.
Hello.. Its in the name SHADOW WALKER it's the rogue of this game, the assassin, the mercenary. I never said NO JUSTICARS OR MAGES ALLOWED so get off my case.
Relax buddy, pffaff's just expressing his opinion and he never said no Jus or WM are allowed. Back to topic, merc sounds pretty interesting but if such system does exist, guilds that accept only mercs(forceable kick by GM or mandatory leave the guild after each raid) will grow stronger than non merc guilds. Imagine a guild with only GM and few officers, rest all mercs. Then that guild will most of the time get nearly 90%+ of the attendance, hence resulting guaranteed raid completion and more power due to faster completion time. I've never seen my guild having more than 35 people on at the same time and that is rare. Most of the time around 15-25 average. So compare to a merc guild that constantly getting steady online mercs, regular guilds may be outranked. That's just my 2 cents.